4 ms·
First, nullify all the patents ... Seriously, back around the turn of the century I was pretty heavily into graphics and rendering and was frustrated by all th
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
First, nullify all the patents ...
Seriously, back around the turn of the century I was pretty heavily into graphics and rendering and was frustrated by all the constraints on getting access to documentation. I finally figured out a way to pin down a vendor with all the necessary NDAs and all the necessary agreements so that I could actually get 100% access to the inner workings of the GPU. As long as I read the documents onsite at the vendor's office and brought no means to make copies. And after all of that, in discussions with the vendor's counsel, their biggest fear was that as GPUs were so competitive, and so heavily protected by IP, that they did not disclose any details to people who might see something that might be protected by some patent somewhere and defending a lawsuit, which always settled before discovery because nobody wanted to actually share their documents! It was insane.
That said, I think an open GPU is an excellent idea, however while I don't think it will get built any time soon I think just publishing all the techniques and algorithms will draw out all these lawyers and we could hopefully arrive at the 'available set' of features which one can implement. I expect though that you need a Google level VP8 kind of program for this to make progress (and Google failed there if you recall)
- theandrewbailey 11y ago> I expect though that you need a Google level VP8 kind of program for this to make progress (and Google failed there if you recall) Google paid off MPEGLA so they wouldn't sue for anyone using VP8. That smells like success. http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/03/google-mpeg-la-agree-to-royalty-free-terms-for-vp8-video-codec/ http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/03/google...
- robbies 11y agoI'm actually amazed that you were able to get an IHV to give you that access. Interestingly, most console developers currently have this sort of access. If they are just targeting consoles (or better, a specific platform), they're able to get a lot done. The tricky part is if they have to target PC and consoles. They have the access they want on consoles, but can't replicate on PC. Actually, on top of that, replicating that task on PC would mean giving developers a nightmarish mix of varying, quirky architectures to target. Realistically, what most _engine_ devs want on PC are more current and lower level access APIs (DX12 and Vulkan) and maybe even an OSS shader compiler. The compiler wouldn't be even for them to poke at. I think they'd hope that the OSS community might do a better job than the IHVs at maintaining the compiler.
- Narishma 11y ago> That said, I think an open GPU is an excellent idea This isn't what the article is about.
- k33n 11y agoNullify the patents? Why? A lot of R&D has gone into making the best GPU's what they are. What makes you feel entitled to that IP?
- camperman 11y agoHe doesn't - it's written in jest. The next sentence starts with 'Seriously, ..'
- Symmetry 11y agoI feel a rant on software patents coming on. I've been in groups that have been on the receiving end of patent lawsuits twice. Both times the patents were transparently invalid. The first time involves my dorm at MIT. Back before I arrived there some enterprising student had hooked up our laundry machines to the internet so we could all find out when there was a free one and when our laundry was done. The internet at large got wind of this and sadly the servers were Slashdotted in both senses of the word. Shortly after the idea appeared on Slashdot some enterprising entrepreneur filed for a patent on the idea of hooking laundry machines up to the internet and was granted it. Several years later our dorm, through MIT, was sued for patent infringement. Luckily the MIT administration had spines so they didn't get anywhere. But the patent is still in force and other universities still have to pay millions of dollars to this group to hook their laundry machines up to the internet. The second time involved the first company I worked for out of grad school, a sensors consultancy. They had some ideas about structural health monitoring using piezoelectrics and sent their designs off to another company to be fabbed. They filed for patents on their ideas and shortly after the fab house filed for patents on those same ideas. They mostly got their patents but for some reason the fab house got one in first despite filing later causing their patent application to be denied. Then the fab house sued them and somewhere in the process there were layoffs and I lost my job. Just because something is patented doesn't mean that it is original and non-obvious. The Patent Office doesn't actually have enough resources to do the job that has been set out for it. The number of patent applications being submitted has increased exponentially over the years but the USPO staff hasn't. You might ask why they just don't fail to grant a patent until they've examined it carefully. Well, they used to do that but the backlog got big and Congress In Its Wisdom passed a law saying that they couldn't have a backlog. You might ask why they don't raise filing fees and use the money to hire more workers. Well, Congress In Its Wisdom has decided what the fees are and has also decided that the USPO can't keep all the money it collects since there are needy people in many other Congressional districts. So that's where we are. It would not surprise me in the least if many NVidia and AMD patents cover the same ideas in different language. But just because AMD happens to have a patent on the technique they're using doesn't mean that NVidia can't sue them with their own patent on that same technique. Legally patents have a presumption validity behind them so courts are bound to assume the USPO gave them the sort of inspection the USPO is unable except in certain complicated cases.
- cbetz 11y agoI would not be surprised if designing a GPU requires more lawyers than engineers. I also cannot conceive of many industries where the barriers to entry are higher.