4 ms·
> how quickly you can Americanize immigrants, not land area. Well that's an easily defined metric, isn't it... There's nothing that says you must let immigran
by davidw 11y ago
> how quickly you can Americanize immigrants, not land area.
Well that's an easily defined metric, isn't it...
There's nothing that says you must let immigrants become citizens right away, or give them all the same privileges citizens are entitled to. For instance, it wouldn't be at all unfair to kick people out for certain classes of crime.
- rayiner 11y agoI'm not talking about privileges. I'm talking about getting immigrants to buy into the attitudes and values that make America worth living in. I'm talking about integrating immigrants into American society as neighbors so they're not living in their own neighborhoods where they can insulate themselves from the prevailing culture. There is a limit on how quickly you can do this.
- davidw 11y ago> the attitudes and values that make America worth living in. I'm going to go out on a limb and say that codifying exactly what those are and if someone is going to be able to accept them in X months/years is not going to be an easy task.
- rayiner 11y agoJust because delineating something isn't easy doesn't mean the line has no distinction. Here's an example. I'm an immigrant from the subcontinent. Even among educated people there, coming out as gay can be downright dangerous.[1] I'll go out on a limb and say that we should not allow people to immigrate here any more quickly than we can expect to disabuse them of these sorts of beliefs. [1] I'm cognizant of the fact that it can be dangerous in some Americam communities too. Alas, we're stuck with that. But there is no need to make the task of progress and civilization harder than it already is.
- davidw 11y agoI see your point, but realistically, you have to put something down into laws, and I have no idea how you would do that. There are plenty of people in the US who loathe gay people and would deny them a variety of rights. Look at what this guy has to say: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawrence_v._Texas#Scalia.27s_dissent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawrence_v._Texas#Scalia.27s_d... Perhaps the problem is that he is the son of an immigrant? Historically, "people not like us" has been used for far more bad than it has for good.
- rayiner 11y agoYou can't ignore the fact that, statistically, those outside the U.S. and certain other countries have many attitudes and values we don't want to encourage in the U.S., at a higher rate than the prevalence of those attitudes within the country. Of course you can't impose ideological tests to get into the U.S. Which is all the more reason to limit immigration to what you can comfortably assimilate. As an immigrant myself I'm really thankful for our melting pot policies. Life will be better for my daughter growing up surrounded by American attitudes. Had our family immigranted en masse with a million other Bangladeshi families, she might very well have been deprived of that.
- davidw 11y agoSo why are you even arguing about H1B's? That's a drop in the bucket compared to people on family visas. I'm pretty much ok with anyone who accepts the rules and laws even if they don't think like me. I'd like them to integrate to some extent prior to gaining citizenship, but that's different than a work visa.
- rubikscube 11y ago> There's nothing that says you must let immigrants become citizens right away [...] There's nothing that says you must let immigrants come. Fixed that for you.
- davidw 11y agoActually, there is: economics. You can't have a successful country and exclude everyone who wasn't smart enough to be born there. In a world of N billion people, a lot of talented people are going to be born abroad. Keep them out, and they'll concentrate in other places. Do you realize how much of the tech world was built be people from all over? HTTP, Linux, Google, Java, C++ and so on.
- rubikscube 11y agoRestricted immigration that allows the top talent of various countries is not the same as mass immigration that replaces the host population and culture. Your dream of an open-borders utopia is incompatible with a successful country. Israel has had a strict immigration policy, far more restrictive than the post-1965 US policy. They don't seem perturbed by your claimed economic requirement of not "exclud[ing] everyone who wasn't smart enough to be born there" (while you've already shown you really mean open borders). The US prospered with very restricted immigration for decades. > Keep them out, and they'll concentrate in other places. Let them concentrate, especially those from the Third World, so their countries have a chance to benefit from their talent and develop. I don't understand why you are against their home countries prospering. Xenophobia-at-a-distance has no place in modern civilization.
- davidw 11y agoIsrael has seen a lot of immigration: http://www.migrationpolicy.org/programs/data-hub/charts/foreign-born-population-percentage-total-population http://www.migrationpolicy.org/programs/data-hub/charts/fore...
- rubikscube 11y ago
- serge2k 11y ago> There's nothing that says you must let immigrants become citizens right away, or give them all the same privileges citizens are entitled to. You already have a process of green card + a bunch of time leading to eligibility. Isn't that good enough? > For instance, it wouldn't be at all unfair to kick people out for certain classes of crime. you mean prior to them getting citizenship right?