3 ms·
>Uber and Lyft would need to pay hourly wages, along with all of the associated taxes due. Not true. You can be an employee with a non-hourly pay structure.
by SilasX 11y ago
>Uber and Lyft would need to pay hourly wages, along with all of the associated taxes due.
Not true. You can be an employee with a non-hourly pay structure. Just one of many misconceptions batted around about the implications of driver reclassification, along with (these aren't all false per se, just not-necessarily-true):
- Drivers would have to get the Uber-paid lavish health care plan that developers there get.
- Driver cash payments would remain the same and not be reduced.
- Drivers would get fixed work schedules.
- Drivers would value the compensation package that includes employee benefits but has lower cash pay, over the compensation they get now.
- Uber would have to provide the vehicles.
- The economic incidence of FICA taxes would shift to Uber (not how economic incidence works[1]).
Again, the employee/contractor distinction depends on a number of factors; you can be classified as an employee without meeting all of criteria.
[1] Good explanation: https://www.reddit.com/r/badeconomics/comments/422av5/some_good_old_fashioned_101level_errors_on/cz73e8g https://www.reddit.com/r/badeconomics/comments/422av5/some_g...
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI agree those are all things that should happen. But can Uber be profitable in that configuration? I would argue not, but maybe they pull it off.
- SilasX 11y agoMy point was that the reclassification as employees does not imply that any of those would be true (very unlikely for a few, false as a matter of law in at least one). You can't just assume that the change would achieve this state where workers get strictly more benefits and Uber's profits are sucked out. You need to take into account how much they can cut driver cash payments in that circumstance (i.e. paying them via benefits), where the economic incidence of car costs and FICA taxes currently lies, what the law says about piecework, etc.