15 ms·
The real fix to this is to make sure that people brought over with an H1-B can easily change jobs. That way they're not beholden to some low-wage job, and comp
by davidw 11y ago
The real fix to this is to make sure that people brought over with an H1-B can easily change jobs. That way they're not beholden to some low-wage job, and companies that bring people in merely for low wages will face high rates of churn.
- untog 11y agoThe real fix to this is to make sure that people brought over with an H1-B can easily change jobs When I was on an H1B visa I changed jobs multiple times, very easily. Part of the problem is that people (including potential employers) aren't aware how easy it is.
- calvinbhai 11y agoI think he meant, change jobs without needing to file for an H1b transfer or any documentation. Once a high skilled immigrant is in US, instead of giving work permit to a specific employer, make it so that its a work permit, with a time limit. 3 years, immigrant can work anywhere, any number of employers. Guess how many illicit h1b employers will be interested in bringing an immigrant, if they are not guaranteed that the immigrant will stay with them?
- prostoalex 11y agoThe transfer documentation is not that onerous, to be honest. Allegedly it's a gatekeeper against H1 program turning into a spout for unqualified immigration where "an employer" hires you for extremely high salary, and you quit on day 2 to start an exciting career in dishwashing.
- bsder 11y agoThe simplest way is to convert to a green card after being employed for 12 months. Employer is responsible for all legal fees, background check fees, etc. over the course of your employment. If you quit at day 2, the employer is still on the hook for all the fees. It can be gamed, but if you make the fees something like 30-40K, genuine employers will simply shrug as they'll amortize that over 3-4 years. Sweatshops, however, will lose bad.
- prostoalex 11y agoMy understanding is that current employment-based green card process is constrained entirely by slow turnaround by Department of Labor and USCIS, not some company shenanigans or legislative provisions for artificial delays, at least according to http://www.uscis.gov/sites/default/files/USCIS/Resources/E2en.pdf http://www.uscis.gov/sites/default/files/USCIS/Resources/E2e... And that slow turnaround is predicated by DoL / USCIS budgets and their ability to hire and train proper employees.
- bsder 11y agoYou are 100% correct. HOWEVER, you don't see the companies lobbying to increase the funding to DoL/USCIS. The reason is that the choke point benefits these companies. If you cleared the backlog so that a green card was a 12 month process, the companies would quit asking for H1-B's unless they really wanted them.
- calvinbhai 11y agonot true. these green cards are given (in addition to employment based GC requirements) based on the country of birth (to maintain diversity). If US gives X green cards to nationals of Y countries (X>>Y) in a year, each country is allocated X/Y number of green cards. This puts Indians, Chinese and other high population countries at a disadvantage. An Indian applying for green card in EB-3 category (minimum qualifications being undergrad degree + 3 yrs experience i think) has to wait for ~12 years from the date his gc process was started. EB-2 (advanced degree and/or 5+ yrs experience) is ~10 years (these are my ballpark numbers) Its not the turnaround time, but the concept of diversity based green cards that slows down the process.
- logfromblammo 11y agoI think the problem may be with those who intend to apply for permanent residency while legally present on an H1B. Once you apply for a green card, you have to maintain legal immigration status continuously. Furthermore, nationals of India and China have to wait longer, due to country quotas and relative demand. There is something called a priority date, which is somewhat akin to taking a number instead of waiting on queue, except it's really more like a number for the secondary queue to get a number for the real queue. There is an I-140 form that is part of the process, which is filed by the employer. If this form is withdrawn, perhaps in response to changing jobs, it can reset priority dates or cause extensions to be denied.
- hpagey 11y agoi-140 can transferred between employers and you retain your PD. Typically, sponsoring companies do not revoke i-140.
- e15ctr0n 11y agoThe previous employer can choose to withdraw the I-140 petition, and typically does so because keeping I-140 petitions around for ex-employees can create problems for the I-140 petitions of current and potential new employees.
- diogenescynic 11y agoIn my opinion, the real fix is to make the H-1B 'lottery' into an auction. Instead of accepting 65,000 H-1Bs at random--accept the 65,000 H-1Bs with the highest wages. That way we are getting the immigrants with the highest valued skills and stopping companies like Cognizant and Infosys that game the immigration system by applying for the cheapest H-1Bs possible.
- davidw 11y agoWhat is special about the number 65,000? Absolutely nothing. It's central planning for something that doesn't require it: http://johnhcochrane.blogspot.com/2014/06/the-optimal-number-of-immigrants.html http://johnhcochrane.blogspot.com/2014/06/the-optimal-number...
- rayiner 11y agoThat's a pretty ignorant article. The limiting factor for immigration is how quickly you can Americanize immigrants, not land area. As for why it's imperative to Americanize immigrants. Look at how much trouble the U.S. has had cultivating democracy in places like Iraq. Most people acknowledge that the Iraqi people aren't ready for Democracy. Do you think they would be any more ready for democracy if you moved them en masse to Minnesota?
- davidw 11y ago> how quickly you can Americanize immigrants, not land area. Well that's an easily defined metric, isn't it... There's nothing that says you must let immigrants become citizens right away, or give them all the same privileges citizens are entitled to. For instance, it wouldn't be at all unfair to kick people out for certain classes of crime.
- rayiner 11y agoI'm not talking about privileges. I'm talking about getting immigrants to buy into the attitudes and values that make America worth living in. I'm talking about integrating immigrants into American society as neighbors so they're not living in their own neighborhoods where they can insulate themselves from the prevailing culture. There is a limit on how quickly you can do this.
- protomyth 11y agoNo, the real fix is to make sure the actual goals of the program align with what actually happens. At this point, saying that each H1-B worker must make $117,700[1] or more to prove they are skilled beyond US workers seems to be a fair change. After all, if you can hire US citizens cheaper, you are not fulfilling the goals of the program[2]. 1) 10x poverty guidelines in US for 2015. 2) http://www.dol.gov/whd/immigration/h1b.htm http://www.dol.gov/whd/immigration/h1b.htm
- calvinbhai 11y agoit is not fair. Its not fair for genuine h1b sponsoring companies in geographic locations where cost of living is low. $117,700 in San Francisco is not the same as $117,700 in Austin. Again, any minimum salary requirement, becomes very easy to game (employee can be expected to pay back in cash, for the difference). This will put genuine companies (that cannot do such shady deals) at a great disadvantage
- protomyth 11y agoPerhaps I should have put the full poverty level tables which are calculated at https://aspe.hhs.gov https://aspe.hhs.gov but 10x the local poverty level seems more than fair. > Again, any minimum salary requirement, becomes very easy to game (employee can be expected to pay back in cash, for the difference). This will put genuine companies (that cannot do such shady deals) at a great disadvantage Paybacks are illegal now and should stay that way. A couple of criminal prosecutions would do wonders for fraud.
- calvinbhai 11y agoKickbacks certainly are illegal (and it should remain that way). But, just because it is illegal, doesn't mean it doesn't happen.
- protomyth 11y agoRobberies happen but we don't stop trying to put criminals away or give up and make it legal to rob people.
- ones_and_zeros 11y agoTo me the real fix is to abolish the entire system. It was a half baked program cooked up by industry lobbyists that invented and perpetuated the myth of a "STEM" shortage. There is no shortage and the character and education system of the US produces plenty of well trained and proven trainable people.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- darkarmani 11y agoAbsolutely! They can be abused to work long hours because they have their visa hanging over their head. Let labor be free to change jobs and suddenly the economic incentives are greatly reduced. Who wouldn't want to hire a bunch of people that are beholden to you to stay in the country? Remove that from the equation and wages will move back up to market.
- calvinbhai 11y agoTotally agree with this! This will make the employers think twice before sponsoring H1b, and will ensure that they treat (in terms of pay and work load) their immigrant employees equal (to americans). Until this happens, Americans are going to be at the receiving end. Even limiting number (drawn out of thin air) of visas, or increasing the cost of the visa, doesn't solve any issues. If anything, it'll make it worse for the legit h1b sponsoring company to bear the costs and handle the immigration process.
- ergothus 11y agoThis. My first experience with H1-B workers was working with contractors at a state agency (in Virginia). They were nice, but not highly skilled overall, and terrified of losing the job as they didn't have any guarantee of getting another U.S. job. This, in turn, made work life worse for everyone, as they'd never complain about anything on the job, even when it was egregious and not just software devs being whiny. My second experience with H1-B workers was when I moved to Seattle. My colleagues were often H1-B, and were vastly skilled (still nice). Good workers (generalizing, of course), but perfectly willing to complain if the workplace or work was subpar, because they knew they could land another job in the U.S. more easily than our employer could replace any of us. That said, the paperwork process was amazingly bad, and many of them got stuck in jobs (even avoiding promotions) because they had started the citizenship process, and for at least one phase changing your job starts the process over. Ugh. The difference between the two, and the impacts it had on the workplaces were stark. My leaving the first job was in the middle of most of their non-H1-B talent leaving (you could call that a self-correction, but that just left those that stayed worse off). My second experience left me rethinking everything I thought I learned from the first experience.
- calvinbhai 11y agoI concur. As someone who is here in US on this visa (fortunately, my workplace presence resembles your seattle experience), I can totally understand what you are pointing out. Something that'll genuinely solve all the problems (qualified americans losing jobs, outsourcing companies abusing loopholes, salaries racing to the bottom), would be to have a concept of temporary green card. Instead of a 3 year H1b, have a 3 year green card (lets call this the Super H1b). Once an immigrant is here in the US on a Super H1b visa, he/she will be free to take up any employment if need be, even with multiple employers. This will ensure that an employer sponsoring the Super H1b visa will be paying at or above market rate salary, because the employer truly needs this employee. Are there chances of this visa being abused? sure. But its way low, much more beneficial (to americans, to the immigrant and also to the genuine Super H1b sponsors). @ergothus : Do you think having such a visa would have helped (considering your experiences in Virginia and Seattle?)
- 11y ago
- prostoalex 11y agoEasier than current H1 transfers? You're introducing a loophole where unqualified labor will be hired (and let go on day 2) to switch to even lower-wage jobs.
- dredmorbius 11y agoAuction + transfer tends to guard against this. Don't shell out for labour which walks.
- mc32 11y agoAnother one is denying the visas to a company which is obviously replacing people 1:1. So they can't argue that they cannot find qualifying candidates just because they just so happen to have fired them to make them unqualified. This isn't a cold trail of off shore shell accounts and obfuscating financials dealings. The trail is pretty clear.