3 ms·
It's an interesting article. There's certainly a lot of untapped talent out there doing relatively menial work when they've shown capability to do very differen
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
It's an interesting article. There's certainly a lot of untapped talent out there doing relatively menial work when they've shown capability to do very different and more effective things. Sponsoring such people or just being more likely to hire them could bring benefits. Well, it's already been proven by the companies doing it while reaping those benefits. Plus the occasional academic team asking for funding on something that might be a game-changer and is to some degree. So, we need more of it.
That said, the author is wrong about the title and doesn't get Silicon Valley. Most don't because they don't know the historical context of how it became what it is. If you want to re-create or beat it, you have to either imitate or improve on the components that went into creating it. This is the best article I've seen summarizing the big picture of how Silicon Valley came to be:
https://medium.com/backchannel/why-silicon-valley-will-continue-to-rule-c0cbb441e22f https://medium.com/backchannel/why-silicon-valley-will-conti...
Note: I bet many people didn't think Zuckerberg and others paid visits to the old guard to learn old lessons for IT. Probably thought it was all modern, fresh thinking "disrupting" the old stuff. A mix as usual. ;)
- ThomPete 11y agoI think there is some selection bias going on here. I am not sure about Jobs but it seems like Zuckerberg had already founded Facebook before he met with the old timer. So he was already onto something. On another note I must say that although the phrase "to invent the future you must understand the past" (another popular phrase is; "Those who don't understand history are doomed to repeat it") I don't believe it's true. In fact Silicon Valley is the perfect example of why this is not the case. At least from all the things I have bean reading up on, with regards to the history of Silicon Valley it started because of some demands for computing power and was cemented with the semiconductor which then ended up creating the real reason why Silicon Valley kept attracting talent. (you could probably go even further back and claim that the "Manhattan Project" was as important for SV too. So the "real" reason SV was popular was because a lot of factors went into place none of them by design. In other words. You can't design a silicon valley because it wasn't designed to begin with. It evolved from a number of factors and "after the fact realizations" which are not possible to copy. And so whatever becomes the new SV will not be designed either, it will evolve when the right circumstances allow for it.
- eloisant 11y agoYes, actually Facebook started to grow with east-coast VCs, already had some success before they got Silicon Valley investors to go to the next step (because east coast VCs weren't used to the SV amount of money). And obviously, moving to SV was a condition.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThat fits in with my theme a bit. These people presumably had the business experience Zuckerberg lacked. They get it started. Then, SV grows it huge. Then, most people forget about east coast VC's and it's merely a "Silicon Valley success story." Revisionist history. Gotta love it. :)
- rhc2104 11y agoPeter Thiel was their lead angel investor, and Accel led their Series A funding. Both are Silicon Valley investors.
- nickpsecurity 11y ago"In other words. You can't design a silicon valley because it wasn't designed to begin with. It evolved from a number of factors and "after the fact realizations" which are not possible to copy." I'll agree with that. Far as the past, there were lessons being created every step of the way for future efforts to learn from. Certainly there's going to be plenty of new things in an area focused on creating new things. Obvious. There are old things that apply, though. We even see Silicon Valley founders trying to draw from past lessons and successes as they create and grow their companies. That's smart of them. Those trying to re-create or exceed Silicon Valley aren't playing it as smart as they leave off components from its past. The Strategic Computing Initiative, DARPA, government contracts... lots of public investment in many creative teams in physical proximity happened. In parallel, we had the various booms going on in the private sector on both VC and demand side creating all kinds of companies and experience. On top of it, all these new people and developments like Y Combinator. Silicon Valley emerges and is sustained from all of this. Probably more factors I haven't even mentioned. A lot of components to copy that the copycats either aren't copying or can't.
- lpsz 11y agoEnjoyed the article, thanks. For those who like trivia: bit of history at the current shopping center construction site around San Antonio Rd. "Demolition has already begun on a row of buildings along San Antonio Road, including the International Halal Market and the Barron Park Plumbing Supply sites. The unassuming-looking market was the former site of Shockley Semiconductor a seminal, albeit unsuccessful, business credited with kicking off the silicon chip industry in the South Bay and considered by many to be the true birthplace of Silicon Valley. As of now, the only mark left of the former building is a signpost mounted years ago summarizing the history of the Shockley site. As part of their plans, Geiser said the finished development would include a variety of silicon-transistor-themed artwork as well as a plaque and photos to commemorate the Shockley building. (http://www.paloaltoonline.com/news/2015/06/01/big-changes-afoot-at-san-antonio-center http://www.paloaltoonline.com/news/2015/06/01/big-changes-af...) Bonus: progression of the building over the years: 1. https://videogamehistorian.files.wordpress.com/2014/09/12shockleysemiconlabs-1384982690614.jpg https://videogamehistorian.files.wordpress.com/2014/09/12sho... 2. http://telco.lk/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/Silicon-Valley-Roots-Shockley-Semiconductor-Lab.jpg http://telco.lk/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/Silicon-Valley-Ro... 3. http://i0.wp.com/siliconvalley.town/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/DSCF2889.jpg?fit=1200%2C700 http://i0.wp.com/siliconvalley.town/wp-content/uploads/2015/...
- forgetsusername 11y ago>Note: I bet many people didn't think Zuckerberg and others paid visits to the old guard to learn old lessons for IT I see a couple of anecdotes, not a recipe for success, or even a pattern. I agree that Silicon Valley arose from magic (or luck), and that it can't be recreated. But it doesn't need to be. The Valley will lose influence for precisely the reason it claims strength in the article; money and computer software can move anywhere, now more than ever. And mobility is increasing fast. Technology development is diffusing, globally. Believe it or not, many people have cultural roots and don't want to leave their home town...or country. SV is still highly influential, but that will wane over time.
- digitalengineer 11y agoMagic? Luck? Or just plain old government money? ... In fact, he says, before there was was Silicon Valley, there was Microwave Valley, which specialized in electronic intelligence—spying on Soviets air defenses, basically—and the seed capital for it came exclusively from the CIA and military. Private capital arrived much later. At one point, says Blank, the institutions of the Valley were so totally in the pocket of the Department of Defense that Stanford became essentially a research lab for the CIA. A number of engineering Ph. D. theses were actually classified. The largest employer at the time—and still the third largest for-profit employer in the valley is not Google, and certainly not Facebook. It’s Lockheed Martin." http://www.inc.com/eric-schurenberg/inconvenient-history-of-silicon-valley.html http://www.inc.com/eric-schurenberg/inconvenient-history-of-... Is this correct?
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThere was a ton of government work over there. Many tech in the U.S. are also funded with DARPA, NSF, etc. By the time it hits press, the involvement of U.S. government or academia is usually minimized if we're talking a product rather than research result. Anyway, this great (and long...) book will give you an idea just how much the U.S. government (esp defense) funded our computing advances back in the day. A chunk of that probably went to Silicon Valley, too. http://monoskop.org/images/d/d4/Roland_Alex_Shiman_Philip_Strategic_Computing_DARPA_and_the_Quest_for_Machine_Intelligence_1983-1993.pdf http://monoskop.org/images/d/d4/Roland_Alex_Shiman_Philip_St...