3 ms·
One of the outcomes is that doctors spend up to 50% of their time making notes instead of seeing patients. But, is that a bad thing? If the notes are relevant/
by alistairSH 11y ago
One of the outcomes is that doctors spend up to 50% of their time making notes instead of seeing patients.
But, is that a bad thing? If the notes are relevant/useful and can only be entered by a doctor, then I'd say that's just part of practicing medicine.
How much of that 50% is purely red-tape? And, if it is red-tape, can that work be off-loaded to a less valuable employee?
- ThomPete 11y agoWhat benefit are you thinking would be the outcome of the increasing need for doctors and nurses to document what they do? I am in complete agreement that it would be great to get more data but it should never be on the expense of time that a doctor can use to do what they are most needed for. If the increase in data is so valuable then it should be no problem hiring "professional" notators who can do the job for the doctor. In the end this is a problem of not having found a practical solution to a political problem which then in turn is being solved with a political solution (NPM).
- alistairSH 11y agoWhat benefit are you thinking would be the outcome of the increasing need for doctors and nurses to document what they do? The complaint above was about "making notes". In a hospital setting, those notes would be used when shifts change. Or, when patients come back for follow-up. That would be part of "practicing medicine" and not something we can remove completely (though we can make it more efficient). I have no idea how much of that type of note-taking has to be done by the MD (or nurse). Or, how much of it is simply red-tape.
- ThomPete 11y agoBut that data is already available. it's just that the doctor is writing it down twice. First on his paper journal then into a system where he/she is also forced to add all sorts of other info.
- alistairSH 11y agoMy GP, cardiologist, and dermatologist all use laptops or tablets. Are they also double-entering data, or do they have newer systems that support newer devices? Serious question, I have no idea.
- lloyd-christmas 11y ago> If the notes are relevant/useful and can only be entered by a doctor My father's secretary has done it for 20 years. Now she does less, liability has decreased slightly, my father works longer hours and sleeps less while seeing the same amount of patients. All in all, a big win for everyone except the doctors and patients. What I don't think people are realizing is that the data DOES exist. It just isn't entered into a central electronic database. They already took notes. Now they have to write them twice. It's not a bad thing that they are centrally located, but from watching my father's life change since this happened, I struggle to see how it benefits patients. From my side, I have epilepsy. When I was younger, I went to see a different doctor, and the physical MRI was sent between hospitals. The images and accompanying notes were misread, and they thought I had a brand new brain tumor. Not exactly awesome to hear at the ripe old age of 14. Had EMR existed, that mistake would be much less likely to have happened. It obviously CAN be beneficial. On the flip side, since this legislation, I don't see my neurologist anymore. I go every 6 months to get a "checkup". Which really means visiting the nurse practitioner to re-up my prescriptions. Since my epilepsy is stable (and I've known him 20 years), it's a time saver for both of us to just fake the appointment. I can't complain too much as it's a time saver for me as well, but the legislation doesn't seem to be in my medical best interests in that my doctor is willing to take that shortcut. I used to have to fight to see him less frequently (taking days off work to strap electrodes to my head or sit in a tube can be draining on the vacation/sick days).
- ThomPete 11y agoExactly.