3 ms·
I still don't understand why snowflakes are symmetrical. There is symmetry across 3 "planes of reflection." What is the mechanism that transmits information fro
by stcredzero 11y ago
I still don't understand why snowflakes are symmetrical. There is symmetry across 3 "planes of reflection." What is the mechanism that transmits information from one side of each plane of reflection to the opposite side?
Pop science explanations never explain this:
http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-are-snowflakes-symmet/ http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-are-snowflakes...
By analogy, one could say that Courier New zeros "arrange themselves in predetermined spaces and in a specific arrangement." But this gives us any number of patterns across a line of symmetry, including a few non-symmetrical ones.
00000
0 0 0
0
-----
0
0 0 0
00000
000
0 000
0
-----
0
0 0 0
00000
So how does the communication happen? (I realize the communication is happening from the inside going out, with additional information being provided over time by the environment.)
- thaumasiotes 11y agoFrom a vague memory of something I read about snowflake formation, the mechanism that transmits information from one side of the snowflake to the other is just the fact that snowflakes are very small. Their formation is driven by the atmosphere around them, and the relevant properties of the atmosphere (like temperature) are continuous, so the same on both sides of the snowflake. Similarly, we don't believe the cosmic background radiation is the same everywhere because there is currently a massive faster-than-light communication network linking every point in the universe with every other point for purposes of temperature coordination; we believe that it's the same everywhere because the universe was very small in the past, like a snowflake.
- kazinator 11y ago> Their formation is driven by the atmosphere around them, and the relevant properties of the atmosphere (like temperature) are continuous, so the same on both sides of the snowflake. So what you're saying is that basically the ability to make twin snowflakes (by manipulating the conditions) proceeds from exactly the same circumstances which already makes their six branches identical? Based on that hypothesis, you're likely to get twins if you simply grow them in adjacent spaces: together, those spaces are still small and the atmospheric properties are even across them. And that's what he seems to be doing.
- Retric 11y agoActual snowflakes are not actually identical on each side. Each side can seem close, but zoom in and there are plenty of differences. Though, as you say similar conditions can make each side close approximations of the others.
- jdmichal 11y agoI'm going to assume it has to do with the crystalline structure of ice. Crystals like to have a very specific structure, so there's only a few particular ways for it to grow from a given point. For instance, the three-plane symmetry is going to be due to the hexagonal shape of ice crystals [0]. That's also going to inform how branches of branches are formed; note that secondary branches are all parallel to the sides of the entire hexagonal structure of the flake [1]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ice_crystals#Geometry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ice_crystals#Geometry [1] http://static01.nyt.com/images/2016/01/22/science/22Snowflake3/22Snowflake3-superJumbo.jpg http://static01.nyt.com/images/2016/01/22/science/22Snowflak...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tgb 11y agoI thought a lot about this, am equally frustrated by the 'explanations' given in pop science, and have tried to research it without getting great answers, but I have some ideas and points on the matter: 1) Most ice crystals are not symmetric! The pretty ones you see in pictures are the cream of the crop or even artificially grown like these. Even artificially grown ones are often imperfectly symmetric, see the stunted arm in one of the pairs in this article, for example. 2) Many snowflakes are thought to form around dust particles or such. This makes their symmetry more remarkable since their base is not symmetric! 3) A stable structure that forces its pattern out sounds like something that should be invariant under a lot of changing conditions, but the sheer diversity of snowflakes argues that it actually depends heavily upon many parameters. So it's extra remarkable that such structure is both sufficiently stable to form symmetry across the millimeter scale and sufficiently unstable to form many different patterns 4) But the things it's sensitive to appear to be humidity, temperature, etc. that are essentially constant across the length of a snowflake even though they change significantly across the duration of the snowflake's growth.
- andrewflnr 11y agoThis SciAm article ( http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-do-snowflakes-crystal/ http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-do-snowflakes-... ) helped me. It's hard to summarize, but it looks like branching starts (in certain conditions) on corners and amplifies existing projections. Corners start hexagonally symmetrical, and to the extent that the formation of "dendrites" proceeds in lockstep around the crystal (due to uniform conditions?), they stay symmetrical. The amplification effect is weaker for the smaller sub-branches, so those are somewhat but not always symmetrical. It doesn't help that there's a couple missing diagrams, but I think the first one is just a hexagonal prism and I didn't really need the second.