4 ms·
> important to realize that the majority of automobile safety improvements came before 1960: This is an absurdly false claim. Cars in the 60s had bias ply tir
by mywittyname 11y ago
> important to realize that the majority of automobile safety improvements came before 1960:
This is an absurdly false claim. Cars in the 60s had bias ply tires (which blew out frequently and had no traction), drum brakes (awful), single circuit brake systems that would fail if there was a leak, solid rear axles (tail happy), lap belts (if anything).
Old cars were several orders of magnitude more difficult and dangerous to drive. Airbags, ABS, crumple zones, traction/stability control, and radial tires have all massively improved the safety of driving.
Car safety has improved so much in the past 10 years that the NHSTA and IIHS have needed to make their tests more stringent because so many cars were getting perfect scores. A ten year old Camry would have a perfect score in 2006, but would likely fail a 2016 crash test.
- ars 11y ago> drum brakes (awful) What's so bad about drum brakes? I know they are more involved to work on, and have more parts. But as far as safety, aren't they easier to activate, which is important if you don't have power assist brakes? (Say engine dies, so just didn't come with power brakes.)
- mikeash 11y agoWorse cooling and worse behavior when hot mean that it's much easier to overheat them and experience brake fade compared to disc brakes.
- mywittyname 11y agoYou are correct, that's why they were originally used, but that's the only advantage they have over discs. Drums don't stop very well. There isn't much surface area for friction and they suffer from brake fade (overheating causing a reduction in braking capability).
- carsongross 11y agoI dunno, man. My 4000 pound '85 land cruiser stops fine with the drums. And Toyota still runs drums on the rear of Tacomas. Discs are probably better, but I don't think the safety gains for them are that significant.
- Sanddancer 11y agoDrums are cheaper, which is why they're still used, even if they're much more of a pain in the ass to maintain. Most of the stopping in a car's brake system comes from the front brakes, so a lot of manufacturers cheap out on the rears, even if it means losing a bit of braking power.
- mikestew 11y agoThey're easier to activate because they're self-energizing (I'm sure Wikipedia has a handy diagram that explains). But drums don't stop as well (not an issue when you're on crappy bias-ply tires), and they tend to fade under repeated braking. They also loss stopping power in the rain more than discs do. Not as important, but I've found disc brakes to be easier to modulate as well. There's no power assist on most motorcycle brakes. I've owned motorcycles with drum brakes. OMG, I'll take the disc brakes any day, power assist or no.