4 ms·
> […] creating a walled garden around the user’s own data is a shady move. All of my private data should be easibly accessible to me though open API without any
by kuschku 11y ago
> […] creating a walled garden around the user’s own data is a shady move. All of my private data should be easibly accessible to me though open API without any gimmicks. In its press release Nest promised introducing a public API[,] however [it] seems limited in many ways compared to the internal API used by Nest mobile app - and to add insult to injury - many of its features require an active Nest subscription.
This is exactly one reason why using "Cloud" services for long-living things, like Hardware, is a great risk.
When Google shuts down Google Reader, we can all migrate to an alternative easily.
When Google shuts down Nest, people are left with non-working thermostats, and have to spend money and rebuild their systems to continue on.
Even worse, if just the internet goes down – not that rare in areas in the US only served by one ISP which doesn’t have to fear competition – one is even left without heating.
The reaction of the people on the recent case where Nest went down itself, and people were left without heating, fits well as context for the following excerpt from "The Sorcerers Apprentice" (1797, Johann Wolfgang von Goethe):
Herr, die Not ist groß! Sir, my need is sore.
Die ich rief, die Geister Spirits that I've called
werd ich nun nicht los. My commands ignore.
- jedberg 11y ago> When Google shuts down Nest, people are left with non-working thermostats, and have to spend money and rebuild their systems to continue on. No, they are left with a normal programmable thermostat with a nicer interface than most. > Even worse, if just the internet goes down – not that rare in areas in the US only served by one ISP which doesn’t have to fear competition – one is even left without heating. This is not true. The Nest operates perfectly fine without internet. > The reaction of the people on the recent case where Nest went down itself, and people were left without heating That's not exactly what happened. What happened was there was a bug in the software that had an issue when their server became unavailable. But this could happen with any device that is controlled by software. And even if they had a totally open and accessible API right on the device, this problem still would have happened. I don't like the fact that they lock up the data, but we should probably try to stomp out the myth that the device is totally useless without their servers.
- supergeek133 11y agoYeah I'm not sure where/how that started. A firmware update broke the battery charging, device died, and cut off the heat. That's a software problem, not a thermostat problem. If you bought a Nest, and never connected it, that problem would have never impacted you.
- cptskippy 11y ago> No, they are left with a normal programmable thermostat with a nicer interface than most. Ehh... I don't think the Nest Thermostat is completely programmable from the hardware itself. You can definitely set temperatures and toggle between heat/cool, heat, and cool; but I don't think you can edit the schedule. Even if you could, I don't think I'd want to. The hardware's UI is beautiful but UX leaves much to be desired.
- supergeek133 11y agoYou can edit the schedule from the thermostat (at least v3 I think). But scheduling interfaces are hard.
- mikestew 11y agobut I don't think you can edit the schedule. Second time I've seen this in this thread, so I walked over and checked our V1 Nest: yup, you can edit it on the device. And I rescind my earlier comment on usability: it's actually not that bad. Certainly easier than the programmable thermostat it replaced.
- cptskippy 11y agoI just checked my v1 and I was able to edit the schedule but I have no way of knowing if I was editing my weekly schedule or making a 1-off correction. I'm guess it's the later and not the former because the change isn't reflected in the App. From my perspective it is pretty bad. While I could edit an entry in the schedule (e.g. move it, change temp range), I had no way to add or remove an entry in the schedule, had no idea what the original values were, how to cancel/undo, or know what I was editing without making a change. It was frustrating at best.
- outside1234 11y agoThe Nest thermostat actually works without an internet connection. You just can't control it remotely without one (or get updates). If Nest vanished, we'd just have what many people currently have, a disconnected thermostat that is never updated.
- ljk 11y agoPrecisely - https://twitter.com/internetofshit https://twitter.com/internetofshit