3 ms·
> Ouch, yet another way in which running on Windows can lead to poor technical decisions. I've never heard from anyone that choosing/using Mercurial was a poor
by theandrewbailey 11y ago
> Ouch, yet another way in which running on Windows can lead to poor technical decisions.
I've never heard from anyone that choosing/using Mercurial was a poor decision. Are you biased?
- zeveb 11y ago> I've never heard from anyone that choosing/using Mercurial was a poor decision. I liked hg too, but as the passage of time has indicated choosing it for one's project would have been a mistake, as git has effectively won.
- dvdgsng 11y agowon what?
- acveilleux 11y agoIt has won GitHub, that's mostly it. Separately, GitHub has won the "place where you share you project code" prize that used to belong to sourceforge.
- theandrewbailey 11y agoYou haven't mentioned why you think Git won. If by "won", you mean "is more popular", then yes, it won. But that criteria alone doesn't make a decision bad. When changing gives you no clear advantage, why change to something more popular?
- lsaferite 11y agoIsn't that akin to arguing that choosing to distribute your movies only on Betamax is not a bad decision?
- jgraham 11y agoWell arguably the long-term result for Mozilla is that we have ended up having to support two version control systems for everything because there has been less resistance to that than trying to force people to use mercurial for everything (for the projects that were already in mercurial people wrote git bridges, and for new projects people tended to start them on GitHub). I strongly doubt that there would have been the same problem if we had used git from the start. I suspect this is a net negative, even if you believe the rhetoric that mercurial (or future-mercurial) has technical advantages in some areas. Edit: to be clear, the kind of "everything" I have in mind is the code review system which now has to support two version control tools. Indeed if we'd used git from the start there might well have been an off-the-shelf code review tool we could have used without putting multiple man years of effort into customisations.