3 ms·
If you extend this to the now-debunked notion's common usage as an metaphor for the uniqueness of people, I'd say it's safe to say we're primarily products of o
by nkrisc 11y ago
If you extend this to the now-debunked notion's common usage as an metaphor for the uniqueness of people, I'd say it's safe to say we're primarily products of our unique environments and anyone brought up under the same conditions as us has a good chance of turning out just like us.
No, I'm not completely serious. (We're not special)
- chimeracoder 11y ago> If you extend this to the now-debunked notion's common usage as an metaphor for the uniqueness of people, I'd say it's safe to say we're primarily products of our unique environments and anyone brought up under the same conditions as us has a good chance of turning out just like us. This is the old 'nature vs. nurture' debate, and while it's pretty much impossible to decide perfectly due to the practical challenges to creating a proper controlled experiment at scale, it's pretty much accepted by this point that the answer is 'yes, both matter'.
- thaumasiotes 11y ago>> I'd say it's safe to say we're primarily products of our unique environments and anyone brought up under the same conditions as us has a good chance of turning out just like us. > it's pretty much accepted by this point that the answer is 'yes, both matter'. No, "anyone brought up under the same conditions as us" seems more likely to refer to shared environment than unique environment. It's pretty much accepted by this point that while a lot of interpersonal variation can be attributed to the catchall "unique environment", almost none of it can be attributed to shared environment (or in other words, the effect of an environment on one person has basically no predictive value for the effect of the same environment on a different person).
- paulisnowflake 11y agoi'd argue pauli(o) already answered the question of whether all snowflakes are wholly unique that said, this tech demo is an awesome display of environmental control and deterministic macro processes i am unsure why people are so fond of fetishising the "we're not special" mantra it seems an agenda driven denial of reality with dubious consequences relying on the agreement of the definition of words without actually defining them i suppose the problem lies in the innate ambiguity of the word 'special' and in the case of the article's headline 'alike' how alike? because in the examples in the videos i can see with only my eyes that these twins have minute differences so the question arises: are the inconsistencies an issue of mechanical precision? (o) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pauli_exclusion_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pauli_exclusion_principle