3 ms·
> This is certainly dramatic, but it is important to realize that the majority of automobile safety improvements came before 1960 Uhh what? Incorrect. In 1960
by Someone1234 11y ago
> This is certainly dramatic, but it is important to realize that the majority of automobile safety improvements came before 1960
Uhh what? Incorrect.
In 1960, 20.147 per 100K population died, in 2013 10.345 per 100k population died. Approximately a 50% decline (9.802 actual) between the two periods.
In 1937, 29.357 per 100K population died, in 1960 20.147 per 100K population died. Approximately a 32% decline (9.21 actual) between the two periods.
So both as a % and in literal terms the delta between 1960 and today is greater than the difference between the worst year (1937) and 1960.
> We've become increasingly safety obsessed and jammed more and more expensive and heavy safety technology into vehicles as the returns have diminished dramatically.
But yet vehicles are lighter and cheaper today than they were in 1960 (adjusting for inflation). So even if this safety technology is increasing both price and weight (and I agree that it does), we're still in a very good place.
While reduction in deaths has slowed in the last ten years, we're just on the brink of moving into automated safety systems (e.g. auto-breaking) that will likely move things forward yet again.
- mikeash 11y agoMeasuring automobile deaths per population is highly uninformative, because of the massive difference in exposure over time. People were driving way more in 1960 than 1937. If safety were constant, you'd expect the fatalities per population to also go way up. Fatalities per vehicle mile or passenger mile, while still not telling the whole story, is a much better measure.
- Someone1234 11y ago> Fatalities per vehicle mile or passenger mile, while still not telling the whole story, is a much better measure. And says the same thing, that safety has continued to improve dramatically since 1960. But fundamentally if population bound statistics are unfair in one direction, miles driven statistics are unfair in the opposite. I picked the statistic which actually makes it hardest to prove my point, and still proved my point. If I used miles driven I'd prove my point even harder.
- mikeash 11y agoI know. I am objecting to your reasoning, not your conclusion. Edit: wait, how are mileage based statistics unfair in the opposite direction? The inaccuracy with those comes from inconsistent exposure to danger (i.e. city roads versus divided highways versus narrow rural roads) and inconsistent numbers of people per vehicle. It's really hard to say which way that inaccuracy goes, only that it exists.