3 ms·
A linear scale for a graph like that is terribly misleading. The graph looks almost flat lately, but that's just because it's relatively near zero. Blow that se
by mikeash 11y ago
A linear scale for a graph like that is terribly misleading. The graph looks almost flat lately, but that's just because it's relatively near zero. Blow that section up to give it some vertical room and it will tell a different story.
Edit: just to put some actual numbers on this, Wikipedia says that deaths per 100 million vehicle miles in the US was 1.07 in 2014, and 1.44 in 2004. That's an improvement of 25% in just the past ten years. You only have to go back 25 years to reach a fatality rate double that of 2014.
- carsongross 11y agoYes, I acknowledge that, but it's important to bear in mind that costs for improvements are typically linear (or super-linear) so the cost/benefit of more safety has increased markedly. I didn't expect my comment to provoke such a tremendous backlash.
- mikeash 11y agoSure, all the low-hanging fruit is gone. It's a lot easier and cheaper to cut fatalities by X% by installing three-point seat belts in every car than it is to do it by building advanced stability control systems. But still, the returns are still significant and the dangers are still huge. I'd guess that your tremendous backlash comes from using a deeply misleading graph as the foundation of your comment and from the strong implication that additional safety improvements are no longer worthwhile.
- carsongross 11y agoAnd that's where I would disagree with what is obviously an overwhelming majority: I don't think the returns, compared to costs, are significant and I don't think that the dangers are still huge. Modern cars are very, very safe and have been for years, and I think the industry should begin to prioritize other things (costs, simplicity, aesthetics, etc.) in some cases. I would be less obstinate if much of the safety equipment was optional, rather than required by law. OTOH, given the absolute blow out that this comment took, I can see that mine is not a popular position. And I would be lying if I didn't admit that a lot of my animus comes from the fact that the vehicles I prefer (the 70-series landcruiser, the Defender 90) are not available in the U.S. due to safety restrictions.
- vkou 11y agoNot to mention that the death rate is a tailing indicator for safety - there were a lot more deathtrap junkers from the 70s and 80s on the road in 2004 then there are in 2016.
- mikeash 11y agoThat's a good point. You could freeze safety at the current model year and you'd still see significant improvements for another decade or two as older cars age out of the fleet.