4 ms·
One of the outcomes is that doctors spend up to 50% of their time making notes instead of seeing patients. Another issue is that by making these overly control
by ThomPete 11y ago
One of the outcomes is that doctors spend up to 50% of their time making notes instead of seeing patients. Another issue is that by making these overly controlled environments you are basically being forced to higher more control people.
I.e. you are getting more "cold hands" (administrators, controlllants, bureaucrats) than "warm hands" (doctors, nurses, caregivers)
This at least has been one of the main issues in Denmark. Can't speak for Norway but my guess is the issue is the same.
Denmark has fallen far down the list of the places with most effective care. It is however (mostly) "free".
There is a real groundbreaking business hiding there. How to ensure control of whats going on without burdening the wrong people.
- lmm 11y ago> I.e. you are getting more "cold hands" (administrators, controlllants, bureaucrats) than "warm hands" (doctors, nurses, caregivers) That's a good political talking point, but it just begs the question. How much good do those two groups do in terms of ultimate outcomes?
- ThomPete 11y agoI would guess that no matter how you slice and dice it 50% of the time a doctor spend on reporting is 50% too much. The same goes for other types of caregivers btw. Of course there needs to be a control system but the problem with NPM is that it puts optimization over outcome and because getting the data is the only way they know how to optimize it basically ends up being the goal justifying the means. This has created layer upon layer of highly paid middle managers and is basically right now crippling the Danish healthcare system. It used to be one of the best in the world but have slipped down to 36 now.
- Consultant32452 11y agoThe next step is to get rid of most of those people and replace them with medical AI. I personally can't wait for Watson or whatever to come along and replace even my doctor with someone simply trained to perform whatever procedures Watson suggests.
- ThomPete 11y agoEven the procedures will be automated away if we are lucky. Already now testicle cancer is often being treated that way.
- Consultant32452 11y agoOh yeah, I agree that's the long term solution. I was also using the term "procedure" loosely. In the mid-term a human will actually do things like check for swollen glands, but it doesn't need to a doctor.
- alistairSH 11y agoOne of the outcomes is that doctors spend up to 50% of their time making notes instead of seeing patients. But, is that a bad thing? If the notes are relevant/useful and can only be entered by a doctor, then I'd say that's just part of practicing medicine. How much of that 50% is purely red-tape? And, if it is red-tape, can that work be off-loaded to a less valuable employee?
- ThomPete 11y agoWhat benefit are you thinking would be the outcome of the increasing need for doctors and nurses to document what they do? I am in complete agreement that it would be great to get more data but it should never be on the expense of time that a doctor can use to do what they are most needed for. If the increase in data is so valuable then it should be no problem hiring "professional" notators who can do the job for the doctor. In the end this is a problem of not having found a practical solution to a political problem which then in turn is being solved with a political solution (NPM).
- alistairSH 11y agoWhat benefit are you thinking would be the outcome of the increasing need for doctors and nurses to document what they do? The complaint above was about "making notes". In a hospital setting, those notes would be used when shifts change. Or, when patients come back for follow-up. That would be part of "practicing medicine" and not something we can remove completely (though we can make it more efficient). I have no idea how much of that type of note-taking has to be done by the MD (or nurse). Or, how much of it is simply red-tape.
- ThomPete 11y agoBut that data is already available. it's just that the doctor is writing it down twice. First on his paper journal then into a system where he/she is also forced to add all sorts of other info.
- 11y ago