2 ms·
"Comments really are a hard problem." Bit tangential, but has anyone (e.g., start-up) solved the problem of massive discussions? Anything over a hundred or two
by prawn 17y ago
"Comments really are a hard problem."
Bit tangential, but has anyone (e.g., start-up) solved the problem of massive discussions? Anything over a hundred or two hundred comments becomes unmanageable in a hurry. Some of the larger sites (e.g., Huff Post) routinely have 2000-comment threads that would take days to plow through.
Is there a solution that combines karma, upvotes as a means of identifying the 'cream' as well as grouping of sub-discussions and points-counterpoints? I haven't seen any solution take a serious shot at a way of grouping sub-arguments and discussions.
The level of comments on the typical news article here in Australia is embarrassingly bad. Any discussion quickly becomes a confusing read without threading and a complete waste of time without persistent identities or moderation. Disqus has taken a crack at the basics, but is it much better for discussions over, say, 500 posts?
- cstross 17y agohttp://nielsenhayden.com/makinglight http://nielsenhayden.com/makinglight (Making Light) is routinely in the 200-1000 comments-per-thread range. They manage okay, mostly due to have a strong sense of community and several moderators and having Teresa Nielsen Hayden to ride herd on it (one of the folks who moderated BoingBoing when they reinstated comments). Here are her (very cogent) thoughts on how to moderate massive discussions: http://nielsenhayden.com/makinglight/archives/008856.html http://nielsenhayden.com/makinglight/archives/008856.html