5 ms·
Other kind of considerations: I'll be buying paper books until 1) I can send an ebook as a gift. AFAIK Amazon allows that only in the USA. 2) I can backup my
by pmontra 11y ago
Other kind of considerations: I'll be buying paper books until
1) I can send an ebook as a gift. AFAIK Amazon allows that only in the USA.
2) I can backup my ebooks and move them to other readers I own.
I suspect that #1 and #2 are related, technically and in the business model.
- adwf 11y ago3) Loaning books. I frequently give family and friends print books that I've recently read. Currently Amazon's loan functionality is very poor (only once per book, must be read within 14 days). This leads me to buying books twice, first as an ebook and second in print to loan. Whilst publishers may well like this, it's scummy behaviour if they do and scummy business practices always come back and bite you eventually. Or alternatively I never buy the ebook because I want the print book to loan, but the print is too expensive so I never buy either...
- steveeq1 11y agoFrom a publisher's point of view, you're infringing on their intellectual property. To them, it's no different than simply pirating the book out of piratebay since they'll never see the revenue from it. I think "case based reasoning" is going on. We have no problems loaning books out to friends because we always have. But pirating a copy is considered unethical, even though the net effect on the publisher is the same. One can argue that the former is slightly better because the both of us can't read it at the same time, but in my view we're just rationalizing.
- Piskvorrr 11y agoBAN PUBLIC LIBRARIES NOW!!! ;)
- virmundi 11y agoThe loan view was just an extension of private property. We can loan a chair because we lose access to it while loaned. With immaterial things like ebooks, we do not lose access while on loan. That has always been the reasoning. Ebooks are not considered property. You are licensed a nontransferable copy of the book.
- steveeq1 11y agoYeah, I covered this: > One can argue that the former is slightly better because the both of us can't read it at the same time, but in my view we're just rationalizing. With books, most of us just lend books when we're done reading them. It's rare where both need to read at the same time, although (I guess) that can happen. My greater point is that we, as a society, are perfectly comfortable lending books out to friends or having public libraries simply because we've grown up doing it that way. In an alternative universe, if public libraries or paper books were invented today, most people (especially intellectual property lawyers) would view it as a form of intelletual property theft and consider those things "morally wrong". Not that I'm saying that's right or wrong, it's just that people have a tendency to understand the present in terms of the past (case-based reasoning).
- manaskarekar 11y agoBoth these problems can mostly be solved, at least for technical books, by buying directly from the publisher. I buy technical e-books from oreilly, informit, springer or nostarchpress. They are more often than not, cheaper than amazon and you can download them in various formats, including but not limited to pdf. Buying books for Kindle feels like you're renting them from Amazon.
- mogigoma 11y agoI agree, and deal with this by using a Kobo and purchasing books from DRM-free publishers such as No Starch Press. It's not ideal -- the hardware is lacking polish and the book selection is limited -- but it works.
- pjmlp 11y agoEasy, there are lots of online bookstores selling DRM free ebooks. One just needs to stay honest and don't spread those ebooks around. I seldom buy anything from Amazon, although I own a Kindle.
- pmontra 11y agoWould you mind sharing the links of those stores? It would be a service to them and us. Thanks.
- pjmlp 11y agoHere they are: http://shop.oreilly.com/ http://shop.oreilly.com/ http://www.informit.com/store/browse/ebooks http://www.informit.com/store/browse/ebooks https://www.packtpub.com/ https://www.packtpub.com/
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoI agree those are useful. But consider they are also hard(er) to do with paper books. Pack a paper book up in a box; write an address label; hike down to the Post office? And backup? What does that even mean for a paper book? Photocopy? EBooks are in the cloud; you can never actually lose one forever. Just buy it again, which is very, very likely to be cheaper than photocopying a paper book. Just saying.
- duaneb 11y ago> you can never actually lose one forever unless ANYTHING happens to that part of the cloud. In which case, you've lost your entire collection forever.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoBooks are all still in some cloud service somewhere. I can safely predict, the human race will never lose a book ever again. Barring an apocalypse. And you can also have a fire at your house. Which is quite a bit more likely?
- duaneb 11y agoSure, but your access to the books is (at least currently) highly restricted, legally. I'd say it's much more likely I'm going to have some issue with accessing my kindle books (who knows, maybe I break my kindle) than I am having a fire.
- DanBC 11y ago> EBooks are in the cloud; you can never actually lose one forever. Just buy it again, which is very, very likely to be cheaper than photocopying a paper book. In 2012 I bought some music in electronic format from Amazon. A bit later they introduced the Amazon music service. I looked in my purchased music section, and the music I'd bought in 2012 wasn't there, and if I lose the downloaded files it's not available to me unless I buy it again or the rights holders come to some agreement with Amazon. It's possible that stuff will drop out of the cloud when the rights become impossible to work out. I'm not sure how likely that is with books, but it happens with films. The most well known is "Point Break", which now can't be shown in public by cinemas because no-one knows who owns the rights.
- yitchelle 11y agofor the same reason as the 2nd point above, I would only buy technical books in paper format. For the other books that I can read and then forget, I choose ebook. If I lose it, its not much of an issue.
- panzagl 11y agoHow do you backup your paper books?
- DrScump 11y agoDidn't you read Fahrenheit 451?