3 ms·
> When there's a possibility that she dresses in a certain way Obviously I wasn't referring to the clause about her attire. > And a defined masculine jaw woul
by pron 11y ago
> When there's a possibility that she dresses in a certain way
Obviously I wasn't referring to the clause about her attire.
> And a defined masculine jaw would probably help you raise money
Absolutely, but that was not my point. The point is that if the matter of appearance is commonly brought up when a woman is involved but rarely when a man is, then there's a problem. If the matter of Agassi's jaw had been brought up as a likely reason for his ability to fool (or not) investors as often as Holmes's natural physical appearance comes up, I wouldn't have said a thing.
I'm not objecting at all to the likely hypothesis (perhaps a well-supported theory by now) that physical appearance matters a lot in all sorts of circumstances, but to the tendency to bring up physical appearance as a significant cause for success only (or almost only) when discussing women, and when the actual amount information supporting this hypothesis in both cases (of men and women) is similarly nonexistent (and possibly similarly likely in both cases).
- DanBC 11y ago> The point is that if the matter of appearance is commonly brought up when a woman is involved but rarely when a man is, then there's a problem. Yes. And now it's a bit circular: here appearance was heavily commented on when theranos was starting and beginning to raise money; and so now when people write about Theranos they keep mentioning it.
- adwn 11y agoIn this case, her gender and her looks are actually relevant, since most VCs are male, and it would be naive to assume that VCs are completely immune to the influence of a young, attractive woman.
- pron 11y agoSo what you're saying is that SV's well-documented sexism is (among many other things, also) may also be a significant contributing factor for reckless investment. But in this case, I don't see the problem. If in 9 cases out of 10 women get the short end of the stick due to sexism, that some of them are occasionally able to turn the tables and use it for their own advantage is nothing but a cause for celebration: "Ingenious Woman Turns Investors' Harmful Sexism Against Them". Social hacking at its best! If women were only truly able to pull-off "a Holmes" (i.e., con male investors out of their money using their sexual charms), maybe that threat would finally get investors to start seeing sexism as a serious problem. The only thing that's bugging me about your solution to sexism, is that according to that logic, women should be at a great advantage when raising money from VCs (unless you also claim that their natural lack of cunning offsets that advantage), yet in practice we see the exact opposite. So it's unclear to me how -- without any other information on investors' reasoning -- femininity could be at all mentioned as an advantage when fundraising, while data shows it to be otherwise.
- adwn 11y ago> So what you're saying is that SV's well-documented sexism is (among many other things, also) may also be a significant contributing factor for reckless investment. No, I'm not saying that at all, and my point was completely unrelated to sexism. You can be entirely un-sexist and still be subconsciously influenced by the attractiveness of the opposite sex (in case of heterosexuality; applies correspondingly to homosexual people). It's a natural bias which we should be aware of and recognize in ourselves, so that we can compensate for it. My point was that the majority of SV's VCs are male (and presumably mostly heterosexual, like the rest of the population), so it is plausible that Holmes' gender and looks influenced VC decisions to a certain degree.
- 50CNT 11y agoWouldn't the outcome that they just start investing less in women due to (subconscious) group association be just as likely? After all, if you're getting investment through your belonging in a certain group, and then never deliver, you're muddying the waters for other members of your group, whether that be expats, women, young founders, old founders, etc. Even though I'm all for using your weaknesses as strengths, getting back what's owed to you, etc, I'm seriously doubtful that "pullin'a 'olmes" is a cause for celebration. If anything, it tarnishes the image of female founders in the long term, and at best its short sighted revenge. There's a lot more good to be had if there were female founders publicly pulling a Zuckerberg or a Gates, and I'm sure there will be.
- pron 11y agoI was being sarcastic. Clearly the data show that not only do women not have a better chance at getting investment, they have a worse chance, in spite of their supposed irresistible charm and the fact that they are less likely to be swindlers. Which is why I find it funny that not only do looks get mentioned only when women are concerned, they are mentioned as an obvious advantage while women are empirically at a disadvantage when it comes to convincing investors. If you read testimonials of female entrepreneurs online you will see that while investors' attraction towards them may manifest itself in several ways, increased chance of investment is generally not one of them.
- cbsmith 11y ago> it would be naive to assume that VCs are completely immune to the influence of a young, attractive woman. ...and it would require completely ignoring the data to think that young, attractive women do well in front of VC's. There's a real world out there where female founders are fighting to get in the door.
- adwn 11y ago> ...and it would require completely ignoring the data Can you show me this data, so that I can stop ignoring it? This is a genuine request, I'm not trying to be snarky.
- cbsmith 11y agoThere is data on this everywhere. It'd be hard to miss if you looked at even a handful of funding rounds (though the industry is getting better at this). Clarity came up at the top of the Google search: http://blog.clarity.fm/why-women-founders-matter/ http://blog.clarity.fm/why-women-founders-matter/ It shows 4-9% of VC funding goes to companies with female founders, roughly tracking the percentage of women at top VC firms. People need evidence to accept this blatant reality of the tech scene, but making assertions about young, attractive women being blindly handed billions of dollars...