5 ms·
Fairytales much older than previously thought, say researchers
- jedberg 11y agoWhat's that quote from the movie producer? "All the good stories have already been told, it's just a matter of how you tell it"? Something like that. There are volumes and volumes of books about how every story can be described by just a few "proto" stories. It's not entirely surprising that there were proto stories before the written word.
- BurningFrog 11y agoThis comment is not very original.
- bottled_poe 11y agoYour humour is wasted here.
- david927 11y agoCarl Jung talks about a collective unconscious and I have to say that I find it absolutely fascinating that our symbols are so durable and our desires petrified. We have a core psychology of what it means to be human that remains unchanged and so its stories remain unchanged.
- Outdoorsman 11y agoHumans do indeed love a narrative...start telling a story, particularly one with an unusual character(s) in an interesting situation, then stop telling it and see what happens...you'll be prompted: "Go on, what happened next?"....at our core I think we're very hungry for knowledge, and eventually the closure provided when a story comes to a satisfactory ending... For the majority of our time on the planet the oral tradition was all that was available to us... I think the simpler the elements of a story are--e.g., good vs evil, good eventually wins, etc., (easily remember-able) the greater the odds are that it will be passed down through generations, or the ages, with changes and embellishments...
- pessimizer 11y agoI think that they're glossing over the fact that many/most of these old narratives have been viewed as extremely difficult to relate to by different generations in different ways, all of which have rewritten, simplified, changed the morals of, and bowdlerized them in hundreds of different ways and abandoned the originals. Many/most of the Grimm stories were virtually unknown in their original forms over the past century - until they were published again over the past 5 years or so. edit: of course, I'm calling the Grimm publications the "original forms" here - I'm sure that most were unrecognizable even then from whatever they had been when they were first told (if they were ever told a first time rather than just evolving from nothing through a continual telephone-game/repurposing process.)
- jhanschoo 11y agoWhile the idea of a collective unconscious is romantic, the primary reason why fairytales date back so far is because the ancient Europeans practiced a culture that prized the ability to recite old poetry and stories. When you consider that there are so many variations on fairytales due to innovations in ora transmission, yet we are able to pretty much accurately piece together one editorially authoritative version of the Illiad, the ability for oral tradition to preserve stories doesn't seem so impressive anymore.
- the_af 11y agoI have a copy of the collected stories of the Brothers Grimm from my childhood, but when I was young I skipped the preface (and to be honest, most of the "Christian" stories, which I found boring, preferring instead the fairy tales with blood, monsters, witches and the prototypical "the youngest of three brothers gets the princess/treasure"), but when I was older I did finally read the preface and was surprised to learn the Brothers Grimm were researchers, not authors of children's stories. These guys weren't trying to collect stories for their entertainment value, but they were trying to analyze European folk tales instead!
- tsieling 11y agoNot just researchers of stories, but also talented linguists who saw evidence of the lineage between different languages, and some of the rules of how words and sounds moved between them.
- david927 11y agoCharles Perrault in France was the originator here, but most countries had their version of the Grimm Brothers. The Czech Republic, for example, had Bozena Nemcova who did similar research of Czech stories at the same time as the Grimms in Germany.
- DasIch 11y agoThese stories weren't meant to be children's stories. They just became popular as such and have been edited to make them more child friendly to the point that with Disney they're hardly recognizable anymore.
- david927 11y agoThat's not remotely true. Many of these stories were specifically to protect children. If you can't watch your children all the time, you can't just tell them, "Don't go too close to the water." They'll go anyway. So you tell them, "There are Wassermen (German) / Vodnik (Czech) who will grab you by the feet and pull you in."
- adekok 11y agoThe Australian aborigines have told the same stories for 10,000 years: http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/ancient-sea-rise-tale-told-accurately-for-10-000-years/ http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/ancient-sea-rise-t... The same for India: http://www.earthporm.com/5-mind-blowing-underwater-cities/ http://www.earthporm.com/5-mind-blowing-underwater-cities/ See #3. Most people don't realize just how deep human history is. Words people use every day are ~2000 years old. e.g. "via", goes back to the Roman times.
- danieltillett 11y agoI am none too convinced by the evidence of the Australian aborigines stories. They are so vague they could just be made up. To give you an idea how unlikely a story would survive being passed down for 10,000 years is, the Tasmanian aborigines lost the ability to fish and and even start fire [1]. Given the critical nature of this information to survival how likely is it that a random story with no survival value would last 10,000 years? 1. http://scienceblogs.com/gregladen/2010/08/08/why-did-the-tasmanians-stop-ea/ http://scienceblogs.com/gregladen/2010/08/08/why-did-the-tas...
- c22 11y agoI'm out of my element here, but presumably the fact that they're able to tell stories implies that the fishing knowledge became no longer necessary for survival. It seems completely reasonable that entertaining stories would have more staying power than uneccesary procedural knowledge.
- danieltillett 11y agoNot been able to fish or make fire in a place like Tasmania if you are living a hunter gather lifestyle is quite a loss. We know from the archaeological record that the Tasmanian aboriginal population was able to fish for thousands of years after the sea level rose and cutoff Tasmanian from mainland Australia. No one really know why, but after thousands of years of fishing they somehow lost the knowledge of how to catch fish. If something as useful as fishing is lost (the seas around Tasmania teem with fish) then how likely is it that a folk tale would be passed down for 10,000 years by oral tradition.
- xefer 11y agoThere is a theory that the common motif of a bear associated with the constellation Ursa Major may have been brought to the New World from Siberia during the Ice Age over 13,000 years ago. http://www.folklore.ee/folklore/vol31/berezkin.pdf http://www.folklore.ee/folklore/vol31/berezkin.pdf This theory goes back over a 100 years: "Its stars seem to have been called the Bear over nearly the whole of our continent when the first Europeans, of whom we have knowledge, arrived. They were known as far north as Point Barrow, as far east as Nova Scotia, as far west as the Pacific Coast, and as far south as the Pueblos." - Stansbury Hagar, “The Celestial Bear”, The Journal of American Folklore (JAF), Apr.-Jun., 1900 "Occasional local names notwithstanding, the possibility of the bear as Ursa Major having originated independently is inconceivable. Classical Old World mythology is replete with the bear in its role as Ursa Major. Ancient Greek, Hebrew, and Arabic all contain references to this motif." - William B. Gibbon, “Asiatic Parallels in North American Star Lore: Ursa Major”, JAF, Jul.-Sep., 1964.
- WalterBright 11y ago> inconceivable I'm skeptical. Bears used to be very commonplace and a big (literally) deal to anyone who lived in N. America. I don't find it inconceivable at all that bears would figure prominently in N. American spiritualism, which would include the stars.
- freshyill 11y agoWhile the length of time these stories have survived is impressive, it doesn't seem so shocking that many stories would be passed on despite not having been written. I can imagine that even at the time they were collected by the Brothers Grimm, they were usually passed along orally, not on paper. I can't imagine the literacy rate was very high for most of that time.
- WalterBright 11y agoOr perhaps some stories may be so archetypical that they get reinvented repeatedly. Stories that share some similar plot points does not mean they must have a common origin.
- kagamine 11y agoGiven that Europe is a similar natural landscape: forest, river, mountain, and has the same wildlife: bears, pigs, wolves, and that it was sparsely populated by modern standards with travel going fastest by horse if you even had a horse, I can see why there are common threads throughout. The dangers were the same, the outcome the same, the weapons of defense the same. The common origin I would assume, is no more than common experiences.
- sveme 11y agoSeriously, there are guys researching this topic for years, applying sophisticated linguistic analyses and then finally propose a novel hypothesis to the world - then comes a guy on the internet and after a quick snap of their thoughts destroys their work and claims they're wrong, it is no more than common experiences. Reminds me of all those internet scientists that ask "but what about the sun?" when the topic of AGW comes up. No shit, Sherlock, never thought about that blinding thing in the sky before! Sorry for the rant and attacking you, but sometimes a bit of humility is warranted when it comes to science.
- kagamine 11y agoYeah, there are a lot a lot of people in universities wasting time and money while trying a make a name and career for themselves. I once studied literature, have you delved into the amount of BS people will write about Shakespeare just to come up with something original? Academia is an industry too. But you know, a common ancestor who imparted the wisdom of ye olde wurld on to generations to come, like a LotR type sceanrio, that's not making the square evidence fit in a round hole. /sceptic
- moultano 11y agoI've always wondered if stories with trolls and dwarves date from a time when there actually were other hominids around.
- kagamine 11y agoTake a walk in a Norwegian forest at twilight and marvel at how easily it is to see trolls in the roots of fallen trees. A lot of black twisted shapes against a darkening sky are like hallucinations as your mind tries to make sense of it, tries to assess the danger of the situation (wolves etc) and you begin looking for higher ground.
- WalterBright 11y agoConsider the Bigfoot stories. No evidence seems to be required.
- mclovinit 11y agoI would not be surprised if stories of other worldly beings aiding in the construction of the pyramids of Egypt long after the pyramids are gone, becomes another fairy tale or at least a derivative in part of that theory.
- marshray 11y agoI have this theory that the Bigfoot story goes back to the time when there really were multiple species of humanoids living in tense proximity. Perhaps it predates even language and became embedded instinctually, thus explaining the sightings.
- kuschku 11y agoWell. the Yeti/Mountain Ape stories have existed for centuries. It's just hard to prove.
- thisnews 11y agoA related story featured on HN a couple of days ago [1]. I'll echo JonnieCache and recommend Jordan Peterson's lectures [2]. If you are concerned about investing the time in an entire lecture, check out the video "Dragons, Divine Parents, Heroes and Adversaries: A complete cosmology of being" [3]; it gives a high level overview of the content contained within his lectures. I believe 'Personality and its Transformations' (2014 series) followed by 'Maps of Meaning' (2015) to be the best approach, though I haven't yet had a chance to listen to the 2016 releases. Jordan has uncanny ability to piece together observations on human behavior with science and mythology; expounding humanity's nuances, ticks and everyday common behavior through the lens of ancient mythology, evolution and ideas and theories by notable psychologists and philosophers. Keep an open mind while listening, but also be prepared to think critically about many of his assumptions and assertions as Jordan takes a number of 'educated' leaps (and demands you follow) in regards to published studies and what they may infer, but the leaps are never illogical - just yet to be soundly proven. Overall, listening to these lectures truly was a transformative experience for myself. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10941363 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10941363 [2] https://www.youtube.com/user/JordanPetersonVideos https://www.youtube.com/user/JordanPetersonVideos [3]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nqONu6wDYaE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nqONu6wDYaE edit: linked this story and not the previous one.
- coco1989 11y agoReligion and superstition - there has to be a story that is not true for there to be a True story. Goblins and evlves are not real but ghosts and demons and angels and gods are.