4 ms·
Eh, I am not for the CoCs and I agree with some of the points made here. But it also comes across as rather insensitive and blind to the very real problems of t
by Mz 11y ago
Eh, I am not for the CoCs and I agree with some of the points made here. But it also comes across as rather insensitive and blind to the very real problems of the people who are dreaming up CoCs etc.
I have spent a lot of years working to try to find a better path forward. I appear to be the highest karma openly female member of HN. So far, that doesn't seem to have done that much for me. I sometimes question my stance. It gets little attention or support and the bitching from both sides gets a lot more attention and upvotes and...I am not sure there is any point to anything I do.
I don't expect to have a regular job ever again, so some of the concerns that other marginalized people express kind of do not apply to me. But I do feel that I face very real barriers as a woman that posts like this one completely dismiss as not real. I generally do not agree with the approach of the people dreaming up CoCs, but I am sympathetic to the frustrations that fuel those choices and this post does not offer real solutions to very real problems. Unfortunately, it comes across as very dismissive of people who have very real problems.
I don't think this is the way to start a constructive discussion about how to find a real path forward.
- thescribe 11y agoI found your perspective quite insightful, so thank you for taking the time to respond. I believe the author represents a very valid sense of alienation and dismissal many people feel when a code of conduct appears on a project they may have worked on for years. While I cannot speak for the author, I have had several conversations with people who hold views similar to that of the author in the past week thanks to current events. People are afraid. They see the Contributor Covenant and other codes of conduct and view them as at best a cudgel for exclusion and at worst a power grab by political groups they feel unwelcome with. I'll be honest, when I first read this article I pretty much pumped my fist in the air, this is like a call to arms against those awful codes of conduct. So I may be so blind to the issues of the people who call for codes of conduct that it is in the 'unknown unknowns' for me. I just don't know about them.
- Mz 11y agoThanks. If you want to get a little insight into some of those unknown unknowns from my perspective, you might be interested in reading my personal blog. Some of the more salient posts are listed in my profile.