3 ms·
Carbon nanotubes are seductive. They are very strong, diamond like, in that circularized plane. But when you extend the tube to macro dimensions, you have probl
by Balgair 11y ago
Carbon nanotubes are seductive. They are very strong, diamond like, in that circularized plane. But when you extend the tube to macro dimensions, you have problems with phonons and the 'rogue waves' that add up over such long distances (relative to atoms). These phonon effects can and do add up to break the nanotube as there is so much energy in the phonon that it overcomes the intermolecular bonds. You can help a bit with an onion layering of nested nanotubes, each a little bit bigger. But that doesn't get you much further. Doping the tubes with other atoms reduces the strength by a lot, but may increase the length. Isotopes of carbon, like C10 or C14, do help a fair bit. However, they tend to be too radioactive to be stable for a project like this. You'd have to continually replace the rope as the dopant isotopes would decay away and the nanotubes would self destruct again. In the end, we need new ideas to help with this. Perhaps some strange electron-phonon interaction? I don't know.
- icebraining 11y agoYes, but so what if you need to continuously replace parts of the cable? As long as you can identify the damage and cheaply perform the repair, it doesn't seem that bad.
- Balgair 11y agoThe idea is that the cable would be one long crystal, not sections. You'd have to continuously extrude the crystal from orbit to the ground or something. You can't bolt in new pieces. Whatever the solution will be, cheap is not one of the answers. Just the maintenance on it would be a world-wide effort. And for what? Cheap orbital travel? The real hard part is to find a reason to leave Earth that the oceans and Antarctica don't already fulfill. The only one I can think of is orbital foundries or other processes that need 0g. Living space we have a lot of, though cold, Antarctica has air, something Mars and Venus do not.