4 ms·
A few years ago, DHS and DOE set up a test power plant using similar equipment to what is actually in widespread production use, and invited select hackers to s
by tzs 11y ago
A few years ago, DHS and DOE set up a test power plant using similar equipment to what is actually in widespread production use, and invited select hackers to see what they could do to it.
Here are the results: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fJyWngDco3g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fJyWngDco3g
There was some discussion of this on the excellent Nova episode "Rise Of The Hackers", where they mentioned that the damage to the generator was extensive enough that it would not be just a quick in place repair. It would have to be replaced, which could take months (they don't have these things lying around in stock...). If someone did a successful coordinated attack on several power plants, it quite possibly could knock a very large number of people off the grid for many months.
We need to stop allowing this. If this trend of putting everything online without paying serious attention to security continues, two things are going to happen:
1. The bad guys are going to succeed at some point in causing a major disaster. If we are lucky it will just cause widespread economic loss and inconvenience. More likely, though, there will be widespread loss of life too.
2. You think 9/11 prompted too big a swing in the wrong direction on the "safety vs. civil liberties" scale? That will seem quaint and mild in comparison once an attack knocks a large region off the grid for months, or causes a chemical plant to release a large toxic cloud, or takes down air traffic control, and so on.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoAgreed 100%. IT'S A NATIONAL SECURITY ISSUE. There's no grey area here. Get this wrong and there's potential for foreign state or terrorist attacks that are as destructive - in their own way - as 9/11. Currently IOT has the makings of the next Pearl Harbour. It would be good if that didn't happen.
- tptacek 11y agoOne of the problems is that SCADA has its own software culture and its own security culture. There are specialty SCADA security firms (for no good reason I can come up with) and it sometimes feels like software security research is progressing in parallel on two (or three, or four) separate tracks. Industrial control software doesn't get the attention that normal software does because it takes a specially-seasoned consulting sales person to get industrial software on the docket for a consultancy. The really good consultancies are overbooked anyways (the big 5 Internet firms buy consultant/years the way smaller firms buy consultant/hours), so there's not much incentive for the best talent to get applied to these projects. If Charlie Miller and Chris Valasek hadn't gotten on stage in track suits to talk about car hacking, the same might be true of automotive, but now every consultancy wants a car-hacking practice. I've managed a few energy-sector projects. The targets were really, really bad.
- superuser2 11y agoIt's disingenuous to suggest that the solution is simply keeping them off the internet. Their own proprietary network cables/radio comms can be spliced into and reverse engineered when running through public places. Low-level employees can be tricked into plugging in flash drives (i.e. Stuxnet). When you're building a target, security aneeds to be designed for across the board. If you want to shortcut your way out of that, don't use general-purpose operating systems and don't build networks.