6 ms·
People Are Still Trying to Build a Space Elevator
- Beltiras 11y agoI remember back in the early 2000's when predictions for when it would be built was 2015-2020. 4 years to go.....
- blammail 11y agoTo be fair, the advances in space tech by the private sector have been nothing short of amazing as of late. It's really an exciting time.
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoI fear we're heading into Year of Linux Desktop memes with the private sector. I'd love to be proved wrong.
- cgrubb 11y agoSpace elevator shadow wouldn't look like that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Umbra,_penumbra_and_antumbra https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Umbra,_penumbra_and_antumbra
- CountHackulus 11y agoYes, people are still working on it. It's not going to get built if no one tries.
- meddlepal 11y agoSome things aren't worth trying because they are batshit insane.
- zatkin 11y agoIt might be more cost effective to build a really long, narrow elevator into space vs. paying $450 million per launch of a rocket/large spacecraft.[1] And keep in mind that launching a large spacecraft usually carries less than 12 individuals. [1] http://www.nasa.gov/centers/kennedy/about/information/shuttle_faq.html#10 http://www.nasa.gov/centers/kennedy/about/information/shuttl...
- dogma1138 11y agoNot really this is like saying that It would be more cost effective to build jumbo jets instead of sail boats in the 15th century. Even if an alien descended from the sky and gave you the materials to build it we don't have a single analogy as far as the actual engineering and construction process goes to even begin drawing blue prints. So yeah in the "long run" it might be more cost effective but it's irrelevant you can say the same thing about any hypothetical technology but you can't stop spending money in the mean time if nothing else we need to be able to be really good at launching extremely heavy payloads and building stuff in micro-gravity before we can even begin to start dreaming about how to build a space elevator. We also need rockets that can go out quite far and come back with a huge payload like a small asteroid for the anchor and even most likely have to master asteroid mining for the raw materials for any potential space elevator. My bet is that it may become feasible around 2250-2500 (yes I know this is a 250 years window :)) if it's possible at all (because when all said and done even carbon nano-tubes aren't good enough they are a good candidate and most likely will be used but we need much stronger composites than what carbon-nano tubes alone can offer).
- ceejayoz 11y agoSee also: horseless carriages, flight, splitting atoms.
- ju-st 11y agofusion power?
- matt-attack 11y agoWhat I never seem to see addressed, is the following: As the elevator ascends the cable, it's "ground speed" must continually increase. What is the source of the force that provides that acceleration (parallel to the ground)? A traditional rocket expends a great deal of energy firing its rockets with a component parallel to the surface of the earth to gain acceleration in that direction. Where is the equivalent coming from w/ the space elevator?
- CapitalistCartr 11y agoThat is not at all how it works. The elevator does not go into low-Earth orbit(LEO). It is part of the elevator system whose center of gravity is at Geostationary Orbit. So the craft itself, and the ribbon, is always over the same spot on the Equator.
- Retric 11y agoThe earth's rotation. Much like how your rotational velocity increases when you climb stairs. Also, the cable is not vertical, you want a large mass past geostationary orbit which pulls the cable fairly thought though there is some bend. PS: Try and calculate just how much energy is in earth rotation it's a rather large number.
- willismichael 11y ago> climb stars I love this typo.
- parenthephobia 11y agoThat's caused by the Coriolis force. Rising elevator cars would leach the Earth's angular momentum, whilst lowering cars would replenish it.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- johngalt 11y ago> As the elevator ascends the cable, it's "ground speed" must continually increase That is backwards. The higher you are the less speed you need. This is true in all orbits. Contrast the orbital velocity of Mercury vs Neptune. The rocket is aiming for low orbit. I.E. you go fast enough that you fall around the earth rather than into it. The only reason a rocket's ground speed increases as it's altitude increases because it's hard to add a lot of speed while still in the denser sections of the atmosphere. Altitude is needed merely to clear the drag imparted by the atmosphere. We go fast and low because it's the easiest way to get something to stay in orbit using rockets. But mechanically as we gain altitude we go slower relative to the ground. Eventually when you go high enough you are standing still relative to the ground (geosynchronous orbit) or even go backwards relative to the earths rotation (high orbit). A space elevator is aiming to go so high that there is no parallel acceleration necessary. The rotation of the earth provides all the acceleration needed. A space elevator that ends in geosynchronous orbit requires no parallel acceleration relative to the ground. A space elevator in high orbit could get something of a free ride out of earth's gravity well powered by the rotation of the earth.
- eternauta3k 11y agoThe article could have mentioned Skyhook [1], which can be built with existing materials. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skyhook_%28structure%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skyhook_%28structure%29
- jrcii 11y agoMy understanding of the biggest challenge is that each point in the cable must be strong enough to carry the weight of all the cable beneath it, which by the time you reach the upper atmosphere would be tremendous even using carbon nanotubes. The cable would also be perpetually struck and damaged by high velocity micrometeoroids.
- icebraining 11y agoCould one use a counter-weight, as in Kim Stanley Robinson’s Red Mars?
- Fargren 11y agoCan't you have multiple stages with multiple cables? I guess acceleration and deacceleration between stages could be costly, though.
- ajmurmann 11y agoWhat do you connect your stages to other than the next stage?
- Fargren 11y agoI would imagine the cabin could stop halfway, were it would attach to some magnetic or mechanic lock system. There it would detach from it's cable and be attached to another one that would pull it out the rest of the way. Actually, the first cable could be the lock system; you just have to keep it attached until you setup the second one.
- sandworm101 11y agoA space elevator only provides access to geostationary orbit. One can climb up to LEO altitudes along an elevator, but that doesn't mean much. You wouldn't be in orbit, but sitting stationary as if atop a tall building. So we would still need to launch rockets for any space use in LEO (GPS and imaging sats for example). And any such orbiting objects would of course have to be navigated around this obstruction. Many useful orbit types would have to be outlawed to protect the elevator. I wonder, is easier to launch into a LEO from the ground or from a fixed point at say 300km altitude? If you climbed a space elevator you would still need 8km/s of speed laterally. So you jump off and fire your rocket. You still fall towards the ground, requiring some thrust to keep out of the atmosphere. Without the arcing trajectory of a ground launch you would have to accelerate roughly twice as quickly, requiring larger engines. Is that really any better than starting from the ground as we do today? Or you could climb to a near-geostationary position, burn retrograde until you touch the atmosphere, then aerobrake down to LEO. That's still a heck of a lot of effort.
- didgeoridoo 11y agoYou wouldn't have to contend with gravity loss (energy expended by performing work against gravity) or atmospheric drag, so all else being equal it would be a net energy win. Definitely not a free ride though.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mixedmath 11y agoI believe you have a fundamental misunderstanding of the speed of the top of a space elevator. The counterweight at the top of a space elevator would be approximately at geostationary orbit. If you were to be up there and "drop" a baseball, say, it would appear to hang there motionless, as it would also be (approximately) at geostationary orbit.
- sandworm101 11y agoI believe you have misread my post. I see no issue with geostationary orbits. I'm talking about the low earth orbits on which we so depend.
- w1ntermute 11y ago> pls don't ask me about space elevators until someone at least builds a carbon nanotube structure longer than a footbridge https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/559557786514632704 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/559557786514632704
- mixedmath 11y agoI certainly believe an underthought of this article, which is that improved capabilities with materials such as carbon nanotubes might lead to a paradigm shift in the possibilities of what can be done with materials.
- garethrees 11y agoThe article says, "His conclusion: The space elevator could be built with existing technology—minus the super-lightweight tether necessary to make the whole thing work." In other words, it cannot be built with existing technology. NASA uses the idea of "Technology Readiness Level (TRL)" [1] to help assess speculative technology, the (obvious) idea being that each stage of deployment of a technology relies on passing tests at previous stages. On this scale, it's not clear to me that space elevators are at TRL1 ("basic principles observed and reported") yet. Space elevators depend critically on having a material that's strong enough to build the cable. Feasible designs for climbers, debris avoidance systems, power transmission and so on, can't make up for the lack of this critical component. [1] http://www.hq.nasa.gov/office/codeq/trl/trl.pdf http://www.hq.nasa.gov/office/codeq/trl/trl.pdf
- Symmetry 11y agoA space elevator on Earth is very hard to build and would require exotic materials which we can't yet synthesize in bulk. But you can make a decent lunar space elevator with Kevlar. http://hopsblog-hop.blogspot.com/2012/09/beanstalks-elevators-clarke-towers.html http://hopsblog-hop.blogspot.com/2012/09/beanstalks-elevator...
- joshuagross 11y ago"But you’ve had civilizations rise and fall by a change in material strength by a decimal point, and now you’re talking about orders of magnitude." Does anyone know what he's referring to in this comment?
- mattmanser 11y agoI would assume Bronze -> Iron -> Steel would be the changes he's alluding to.
- Balgair 11y agoCarbon nanotubes are seductive. They are very strong, diamond like, in that circularized plane. But when you extend the tube to macro dimensions, you have problems with phonons and the 'rogue waves' that add up over such long distances (relative to atoms). These phonon effects can and do add up to break the nanotube as there is so much energy in the phonon that it overcomes the intermolecular bonds. You can help a bit with an onion layering of nested nanotubes, each a little bit bigger. But that doesn't get you much further. Doping the tubes with other atoms reduces the strength by a lot, but may increase the length. Isotopes of carbon, like C10 or C14, do help a fair bit. However, they tend to be too radioactive to be stable for a project like this. You'd have to continually replace the rope as the dopant isotopes would decay away and the nanotubes would self destruct again. In the end, we need new ideas to help with this. Perhaps some strange electron-phonon interaction? I don't know.
- icebraining 11y agoYes, but so what if you need to continuously replace parts of the cable? As long as you can identify the damage and cheaply perform the repair, it doesn't seem that bad.
- Balgair 11y agoThe idea is that the cable would be one long crystal, not sections. You'd have to continuously extrude the crystal from orbit to the ground or something. You can't bolt in new pieces. Whatever the solution will be, cheap is not one of the answers. Just the maintenance on it would be a world-wide effort. And for what? Cheap orbital travel? The real hard part is to find a reason to leave Earth that the oceans and Antarctica don't already fulfill. The only one I can think of is orbital foundries or other processes that need 0g. Living space we have a lot of, though cold, Antarctica has air, something Mars and Venus do not.