4 ms·
I'm an adjunct, and I've written about various aspects of being an adjunct (e.g. here: http://jakeseliger.com/2014/12/22/how-do-you-know-when-youre-being-insens
by jseliger 11y ago
I'm an adjunct, and I've written about various aspects of being an adjunct (e.g. here: http://jakeseliger.com/2014/12/22/how-do-you-know-when-youre-being-insensitive-how-do-you-know-when-youre-funny/ http://jakeseliger.com/2014/12/22/how-do-you-know-when-youre...). But I'll add that there is a very good "excuse" why universities treat adjuncts how they do: because they can. When people stop signing up for grad school and/or to be adjuncts, universities will have to offer better pay and/or conditions.
Until that happens, universities won't. Markets are clearing.
- jgalt212 11y ago> I'll add that there is a very good "excuse" why universities treat adjuncts how they do: because they can. That's very true, and current and potential adjuncts should wisen up. That being said, just because you can take advantage of someone doesn't mean you should.
- SilasX 11y agoIt would also help if they weren't the locus of indignation at corporations for not treating workers well enough.
- SilasX 11y agoYep. When you flood two generations with easy college money and tell them they have to go or they're a failure, don't be surprised when a disproportionate number of people are exposed to post graduate options and they seem like their best choice. Even so, stuff like this reminds me not to take too romantic a view of "non-profit" higher education.
- sdalfakj 11y ago> When you flood two generations with easy college money and Would that be why they are drowning in higher education debt? Such failures in logic occur when you try to express a systematic social problem (erosion of labour rights and lack of unionisation in higher education institutions among adjuncts and graduate students) to individualist argumentation ("it's their fault for being exploited").
- diogenescynic 11y ago>Would that be why they are drowning in higher education debt? I think by 'easy college money' they meant student loans.
- cousin_it 11y agoThey shouldn't "stop signing up". They should unionize. Many adjuncts are already doing that and it's helping.
- SilasX 11y agoUnionization can only enable workers to capture more of the producer surplus; it can't fundamentally reverse a case of extreme oversupply. For rough numbers, an epically good adjunct union might secure a 50% pay raise. But sane PhD pay rates would have to be something like 2x what they are now for it to be a viable career path for high-IQ white collar professionals. And that requires the supply to (take an economic hint and) contract.
- cousin_it 11y agoHuh? There's an extreme oversupply of actors too, but Hollywood is unionized and the minimum daily rate for actors is pretty high. Sure, there's massive unemployment. The same will happen with adjuncts if they unionize. But it'll be better than the current situation.
- SilasX 11y agoYes, and just as my claim would predict of Hollywood: - Actors (in the aggregate) get a bigger fraction of the returns than the typical worker in other industries. - The overwhelming number of people who make some money from acting have to supplement it with something else since they can only get a few days per year. - Full time acting is not a viable career option for most people who would like to do it and are qualified. - Unionization did nothing for the above dynamic, though it did have other benefits, like improving pay somewhat for those who find part-time work at all. IOW, yes, it has benefits, no it will not return us to the state where getting a PhD becomes a viable full-time career path.
- cousin_it 11y agoYeah, I agree now. Thank you.
- refriedbeans3 11y agoIt already is happening. So many graduates see the higher level of skill they have and the joke of a salary that adjuncts make and 'nope-ing' out into industry. Academia is going to starve itself of it's best performers by low pay and horrible standards for adjuncts and tenure track positions alike.
- SilasX 11y agoYeah, that's the smart thing to do, especially when there's strong demand for their skills, like from silicon valley. Heck, that would make a great plot for the show of the same name: PP is looking to academia to hire and they informally offer a candidate "100", by which they mean "$100k/year", but (they later find out) the heavily underpaid post-doc took to mean "$100/day", and they debate whether they should write up the offer letter with the lower amount.
- Shivetya 11y agoThis. The fix for the pay issues is for the over supply to go away. If we attempt to legislate or worse, unionize the field, we will just end up with many who want to work with no job as requirements will spell out exactly who gets employed and how, effectively locking out any who cannot get on board. I still of the opinion that the university system needs a good hair cut. They are able to rake in billions of federal dollars for student loans and unlike the medical care field where federal money also goes no attempt is made to course rates. As in, if you want students on federal loans this is what you can charge per course hour for this course.
- HarryHirsch 11y agoThe problem with the market-based approach is that the oversupply won't go away anytime soon. Right now there is a surfeit of chemists on the East Coast from the Dow-Dupont merger that added to the surfeit from the pharma crisis that started fifteen years ago and hasn't really ended. What exactly is wrong with the union-based approach (the AMA works rather nicely for physicians), and why can't the US have a proper science policy?