10 ms·
There Is No Excuse for How Universities Treat Adjuncts
- jseliger 11y agoI'm an adjunct, and I've written about various aspects of being an adjunct (e.g. here: http://jakeseliger.com/2014/12/22/how-do-you-know-when-youre-being-insensitive-how-do-you-know-when-youre-funny/ http://jakeseliger.com/2014/12/22/how-do-you-know-when-youre...). But I'll add that there is a very good "excuse" why universities treat adjuncts how they do: because they can. When people stop signing up for grad school and/or to be adjuncts, universities will have to offer better pay and/or conditions. Until that happens, universities won't. Markets are clearing.
- jgalt212 11y ago> I'll add that there is a very good "excuse" why universities treat adjuncts how they do: because they can. That's very true, and current and potential adjuncts should wisen up. That being said, just because you can take advantage of someone doesn't mean you should.
- SilasX 11y agoIt would also help if they weren't the locus of indignation at corporations for not treating workers well enough.
- SilasX 11y agoYep. When you flood two generations with easy college money and tell them they have to go or they're a failure, don't be surprised when a disproportionate number of people are exposed to post graduate options and they seem like their best choice. Even so, stuff like this reminds me not to take too romantic a view of "non-profit" higher education.
- sdalfakj 11y ago> When you flood two generations with easy college money and Would that be why they are drowning in higher education debt? Such failures in logic occur when you try to express a systematic social problem (erosion of labour rights and lack of unionisation in higher education institutions among adjuncts and graduate students) to individualist argumentation ("it's their fault for being exploited").
- diogenescynic 11y ago>Would that be why they are drowning in higher education debt? I think by 'easy college money' they meant student loans.
- cousin_it 11y agoThey shouldn't "stop signing up". They should unionize. Many adjuncts are already doing that and it's helping.
- SilasX 11y agoUnionization can only enable workers to capture more of the producer surplus; it can't fundamentally reverse a case of extreme oversupply. For rough numbers, an epically good adjunct union might secure a 50% pay raise. But sane PhD pay rates would have to be something like 2x what they are now for it to be a viable career path for high-IQ white collar professionals. And that requires the supply to (take an economic hint and) contract.
- cousin_it 11y agoHuh? There's an extreme oversupply of actors too, but Hollywood is unionized and the minimum daily rate for actors is pretty high. Sure, there's massive unemployment. The same will happen with adjuncts if they unionize. But it'll be better than the current situation.
- SilasX 11y agoYes, and just as my claim would predict of Hollywood: - Actors (in the aggregate) get a bigger fraction of the returns than the typical worker in other industries. - The overwhelming number of people who make some money from acting have to supplement it with something else since they can only get a few days per year. - Full time acting is not a viable career option for most people who would like to do it and are qualified. - Unionization did nothing for the above dynamic, though it did have other benefits, like improving pay somewhat for those who find part-time work at all. IOW, yes, it has benefits, no it will not return us to the state where getting a PhD becomes a viable full-time career path.
- cousin_it 11y agoYeah, I agree now. Thank you.
- refriedbeans3 11y agoIt already is happening. So many graduates see the higher level of skill they have and the joke of a salary that adjuncts make and 'nope-ing' out into industry. Academia is going to starve itself of it's best performers by low pay and horrible standards for adjuncts and tenure track positions alike.
- SilasX 11y agoYeah, that's the smart thing to do, especially when there's strong demand for their skills, like from silicon valley. Heck, that would make a great plot for the show of the same name: PP is looking to academia to hire and they informally offer a candidate "100", by which they mean "$100k/year", but (they later find out) the heavily underpaid post-doc took to mean "$100/day", and they debate whether they should write up the offer letter with the lower amount.
- Shivetya 11y agoThis. The fix for the pay issues is for the over supply to go away. If we attempt to legislate or worse, unionize the field, we will just end up with many who want to work with no job as requirements will spell out exactly who gets employed and how, effectively locking out any who cannot get on board. I still of the opinion that the university system needs a good hair cut. They are able to rake in billions of federal dollars for student loans and unlike the medical care field where federal money also goes no attempt is made to course rates. As in, if you want students on federal loans this is what you can charge per course hour for this course.
- HarryHirsch 11y agoThe problem with the market-based approach is that the oversupply won't go away anytime soon. Right now there is a surfeit of chemists on the East Coast from the Dow-Dupont merger that added to the surfeit from the pharma crisis that started fifteen years ago and hasn't really ended. What exactly is wrong with the union-based approach (the AMA works rather nicely for physicians), and why can't the US have a proper science policy?
- zanewill9 11y agoThis is a dangerous trend (especially since I've noticed other articles questioning a University education altogether). I was first alerted to it by (of all places) The magic-the-gathering professor: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vcQ4KIOqNic https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vcQ4KIOqNic (bonus if you're looking for some great magic-the-gathering videos)
- rhino369 11y agoPaying them more would increase tuition. Maybe colleges should shift the funds from elsewhere but that not as simple as just paying them more. What is never talked about in these articles about the plight of the adjunct is that adjunct professor is supposed to be a fun side gig. Almost charity work. You are supposed to do it for the experience. I'd had many adjuncts at northwestern when I was getting my law degree. They were partners at major law firms. They mad millions a year. They would have done this job for free. Maybe they did. My wife considered adjuncting at her old college for the same reason. It seems a huge part of this problem is some are treating these jobs as real, life supporting careers. They aren't meant that way. Maybe colleges are taking advantage. But these adjuncts are also taking advantage of themselves willingly.
- wmagato 11y ago"It seems a huge part of this problem is some are treating these jobs as real, life supporting careers. They aren't meant that way." The problem is that the universities do not advertise it that way. They don't take thousands of dollars from parents and tell them "thanks, hopefully we will find a volunteer to teach your kid by the time class starts next week".
- bphogan 11y agoYou're right. They say "professor with experience in her field." Which is what an adjunct provides when done right. Unfortunately enrollment is a big deal at schools, and sometimes more classes are offered than there are people to teach them. And some adjuncts are simply just not qualified to teach anything because they have no experience that's relevant. Seen it too often in my time in public higher ed.
- SilasX 11y agoYeah, I think it would look different to prospective students and their parents if they were explicitly told, "you will be taught by a barely-scraping-by post doc who won't be devoting her full attention to the class because she's panicking about whether her food stamp application will go through".
- Animats 11y agoThink of it as capitalism in action. At least it's a step up from "do you want fries with that?"
- danharaj 11y agoIt's funny how the most essential work in society is under constant pressure of debasement. Feeding people is considered an ignominious job. Teaching people too is constantly debased. Now it's affecting higher education. The neoliberal transformation of capitalism decouples the value of goods and services from their value to humanity and instead pegs them against markets. Markets no longer merely transmit information about value. They are the definition of value. This is the ideological difference between liberal free market capitalism and neoliberalism; at least the former paid lip service to the idea that truth and value are ours to define. Not so. Capital determines value. Universities are capitalist entities. They are trying to compete and appreciate in value for their shareholders. The market has replaced whatever value systems justified universities in the past.
- _yosefk 11y agoErm... isn't the actual root cause of the problem raised in TFA the opposite of debasement? Namely excess supply of people who're willing to go into academia to "do the most essential work in society", whatever the terms, as a sister comment from an insider pointed out? If the perceived value of being in academia was low enough, the market would force the universities to treat adjuncts better. Also, aren't most or at least a great many of the most famous universities non-profits, competing for donations instead of trying to maximize shareholder value? I hear that in for-profit education, the average student is treated better and so is the average lecturer (you want to please your students whose money feeds you and you want to attract lecturers whose primary motivation is financial and who're good enough to please your students, so the for-profit institution kinda has to treat both well to survive.) Somebody living off donations, on the other hand, only has to please people donating the money (and someone living off taxes only has to please government officials), while pleasing either students or the teaching staff is no longer essential. (I don't have firm or specific opinions on how higher education should be run, in general, just commenting on your points.)
- jimmar 11y agoI'm faculty at a regional university in the U.S. Our enrollment is dropping by 5% a year, and short term positions are becoming the norm. Tenure track positions are risky in that once you've got somebody with tenure, it's difficult to get rid of them (intentionally). Short term positions give universities flexibility. We are not a Harvard or Yale with billions of dollars in endowments. Tuition is 80% of revenue, and our existence in 20 years is in no way guaranteed. I don't know how many universities are flush with cash and are just being stingy by using adjuncts, but where I work (small regional university), we have intense budget pressure. We'd have to raise tuition a lot to cover the cost of converting adjust to tenure-track positions. I don't like how adjuncts are treated, but seeing the problem from our administration's point of view, I know why we have so many adjuncts.
- bjd2385 11y agoThey're dropping for various reasons, I'm sure. But first and foremost because a bachelor's degree isn't worth anything anymore. Both my sister and my father have Bachelor's degrees and my dad's a janitor and my sister's a nurse. Granted, a nurse isn't that bad, but cleaning up people's feces on top of everyone in the practice being against her going to school to become a doctor (so she doesn't have to "ask permission" or clean up after people anymore) is a disgrace. And for my dad -- he's working with the lowest of the low. It's just awful that someone can bury themselves in 100k of debt to barely make more than minimum wage and clean up shit.
- blackguardx 11y agoNursing is a highly paid, respected profession. It is a different job than a doctor, just like a designer is different than a programmer.
- hueving 11y agoYour sister doesn't sound like a nurse to me. An RN doesn't clean up feces.
- Omniusaspirer 11y ago
- bjd2385 11y agoMy mother is an adjunct math professor at three universities in the Western NY area. She teaches 7 classes to support the family while she's also going for her PhD (she's got like a 3.98 GPA or something btw). The thing that gets me is that we look around and the campuses have millions to put up for new buildings and infrastructure and sports, etc. But here they can't give my mother a full time job with benefits. Education is nothing more than an industry. They don't care if I pass or succeed, as long as they've got a job at the end of the day. I'm convinced of that.
- noblethrasher 11y agoI agree with your main point, but mentioning new construction is something of a non-sequitur because that funding usually comes from donors. We might be able to make the case that the donations don't cover the ongoing cost of operating the new buildings, but at least at my institution, the new buildings are usually energy-efficient replacements for old ones. But yeah, the whole thing is nutty: a few years ago at a Chamber of Commerce function, one of our extremely wealthy doners (you probably know of them) told the audience members that they should be providing a certain minimal level of funding to athletics, even if it meant reducing their normal contribution to the academic side.
- bphogan 11y agoThree things colleges care about: 1. Enrollment 2. Retention 3. Graduation with a job. Enrollment is priority one, so they need nice campuses to get you in the door, good facilities to entice you to come. They'll advertise small class sizes with individualized attention because the current generation loves to hear that. (Of course this means they need more faculty to be there in the room.) Graduation with a job is second because they need to show that people come out of the school. This of course becomes marketing material for #1. Retention is the one they leave up to the departments and faculty.
- ssharp 11y agoYou're not entirely wrong, but due to funding models of state colleges, these priorities may be a bit different. In Ohio, for quite some time, state funding was based on enrollment, so that's what state universities did: enroll as many students as they could. Then, it was decided that enrollment was a terrible thing to incentivize because the incremental enrollees were far more likely to drop out. So the state switched to funding based on graduation numbers, so retention and graduation are far more important and universities have tightened their enrollment standards and started building stronger relationships with community colleges.
- danieltillett 11y agoI used to be a tenured professor (senior lecturer) and while universities treat adjuncts badly they also don't treat tenured professors any better. While the job has a lot of good points respect from your employer is not one of them. At least here in Australia tenure really doesn't exist anymore. If they want to get rid of you they just wait for the next departmental reshuffle (these seem to occur every couple of years) and eliminate your position.
- kauffj 11y agoIf you intern as a CS major, you will probably be paid somewhere between $10-$25/hr. If you intern in Hollywood, you will make a nominal amount. Does anyone find this surprising? There is a practically unlimited amount of programming work to be done and not enough programmers to do it all. On the other hand, there is a finite demand for movies and a very large number of people who would like to do it. Many people would like to be professors. Unsurprisingly, this depresses the wage. What else is to be expected? Adjunct salaries will rise and/or more tenured professorships will be offered when either consumer demand rises or supply falls. Anything else is just wishful thinking.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ves 11y agoYou'll probably be paid a lot more interning in SWE or DS, actually, which furthers your point.
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago>There is a practically unlimited amount of programming work to be done and not enough programmers to do it all. I certainly find that statement surprising, considering that most of the programming work already done is economically useless. Unicorn-balloon inflation is not a real job.
- chitowngal 11y agoThere are many good points in this article, and I agree about the general gist that adjuncts are not well-served in this situation. That being said, I think that the article sets up an artificial binary between adjuncts and tenured faculty. There is a whole third leg of employment that is contingent full-time teaching. That is to say, one-year professorships, and lecturer/instructor/preceptor positions that employ people full-time, but without assurance of continued employment in the year to come (indeed, often with an explicitly NON-renewable contract). There is a large chunk of academic teaching from faculty who make an okay (not great) income for a year, but have no security for years to come, and are forced to go through an extremely grueling application process year after year (see this article from Slate.com on more about that process: http://www.slate.com/articles/life/education/2014/09/how_do_professors_get_hired_the_academic_job_search_explained.html http://www.slate.com/articles/life/education/2014/09/how_do_...).
- NoGravitas 11y agoThe "visiting assistant professor" treadmill is definitely in the same badness league as adjuncting. Another trap is the "tenure track positions" where no one actually gets tenure, and they end up being re-advertised every three years.
- jayess 11y agoSo if someone is willing to teach a class for $2000 per semester, they shouldn't be allowed to? I've tried to get into adjunct teaching, but there are so many applicants that it's almost impossible. Supply and demand. Adjuncts are paid what the market dictates, and that's ok.
- therobot24 11y agoProblem is a two-way street. Making only $2000 a semester may deter an adjunct from 'going the extra mile'. Not that a full-time professor would do so because they're full time. However, a low wage doesn't necessarily encourage the adjunct to do more than the minimum. Also, if you figure that the department head will just fire and hire until they find someone what will put in that extra time you're kidding yourself. They work on semester contracts, firing and hiring over and over again will be throwing too many new/untrusted people into the classroom only to start-over in another few months, not to mention the lag-time between hires. What ends up happening is the department heads will maybe bring in a new candidate the next year if there's a lot of complaints against an adjunct, but otherwise they just keep the same scheduling.
- alberte 11y agoThe solution is get on the administration track https://www.higheredjobs.com/salary/salaryDisplay.cfm?SurveyID=30 https://www.higheredjobs.com/salary/salaryDisplay.cfm?Survey... e.g. Chief Student Financial Aid Officer $83,726
- alberte 11y ago...actually when you think about it - if the market forces argument was all there was to it administrators would be getting paid very little to, there's an abundance of administrators
- bobochan 11y agoI am glad that employers that mislabel employees as independent contractors are paying for their mistakes, but I am always a little disappointed when these articles appear. I am an adjunct professor, but I also have a full-time job as a programmer that has spanned almost 30 years. Wikipedia says "adjunct professors are often nominated in recognition of active involvement with the appointing institution, while they are employed by government, industry, a profession or another institution" and that definition fits me perfectly. Sad articles about the "plight of adjuncts" come out frequently, but I hope people understand that there is another side to the equation. The opportunity to work with motivated and passionate students that really care about the material is absolutely amazing, and it is a great way to give back to the community. I have stayed in touch with a lot of students over the years, and it is incredibly gratifying to hear how their careers have developed.
- gamesbrainiac 11y agoMany articles regarding the mistreatment of part-time academics have been making their way onto hacker news, and I feel that this isn't really going to change any time soon. More and more, universities are there to create a "brand image", not provide decent education. This is why there is such an emphasis on administrators, because decent academics just want to learn more and teach, not try to sell you on a whole host of rubbish. This is why things won't improve. If you have institutions that aim to provide more luxury to their students, so that they have "great college memories", then how do you expect colleges to pay more for better teachers.
- joesmo 11y agoIt's completely clear to me that universities using adjuncts as consultants are violating federal laws and likely many state laws as well. Like most other such problems, the only solution is a major class action lawsuit like the one against Uber. I have no doubt whatsoever that given a fair trial, any competent judge or jury would see abuse here, if for no other reason than they are forced to work at specific times in a specific place. There is just absolutely no way you can justify this as consulting work when they cannot decide either the time or location of the work being done. There are other obvious violations but these are so egregious, it's revolting. Of course, you have to see the lawsuit to its conclusion because the Labor department doesn't give a shit about labor laws being broken and will tell you as much when you try to bring that up.