4 ms·
How about smart TVs? Give it a few years and you’ll have hundreds of millions of TVs with a camera on them exposed to the wild.
by elorant 11y ago
How about smart TVs? Give it a few years and you’ll have hundreds of millions of TVs with a camera on them exposed to the wild.
- Silhouette 11y agoThe disturbing thing today about smart TVs in particular is that it's increasingly difficult to buy a TV without those features. Personally, I have no interest in them even without the obvious security and privacy concerns. I want my TV and speakers to be as good as possible at showing pictures and making sounds, and to accept signals from whatever sources I want to use in sensible ways. Everything else is just more cost, more scope for failure, and less future-proofing. The really disturbing thing about a lot of these IoT devices with sensors and remote communications in the future will be when they no longer rely on an explicit Internet connection being provided via the home network, and instead use some sort of mesh arrangement where they can get online independently and you won't even know about it. At that point, I think robust laws about both disclosure and the ability to opt out will probably be necessary.
- rangibaby 11y agoHave you considered using a PC monitor instead of a TV? Honestly, their biggest feature when used as a TV is their lack of "features".
- gambiting 11y agoIt's a bit hard to buy 50" PC Monitor though.
- j2981190 11y agoYeah, why did they decide to stop at 40"?
- Silhouette 11y agoUnfortunately, PC monitors tend to be missing a few too many features that really are basic TV functionality -- remote control, sound, large numbers of switchable inputs (particularly HDMI) on high-end models, etc. They also tend to be physically smaller but often with a higher native resolution than TV/movie standards, so not the best fit for efficiently showing that kind of content.
- golergka 11y agoEverything but size is solvable by building a small PC to use it as TV controller, no?
- kbenson 11y agoThe cost difference of this theoretical setup is now reaching laughable proportions (in time, money, or both)
- walterbell 11y agoHow about a short-throw projector?
- tdkl 11y agoDon't plug it in the LAN ? Set the firewall rule for the TV to block internet on the router ? (I agree with you, the "smart TV" bonanza is going too far)
- izacus 11y agoWell, that works until the smart TV refuses to set up without internet connection like modern STBs and mobile phones.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pdkl95 11y agoAt some point - probably sooner than we expect - the hot new system-on-a-chip will have a built-in baseband processor and (probably software) radio. Once that is available, negotiating for off-peak/low-priority use of the cellular network will suddenly become very popular and the analytics (spyware) will no long needs your permission when it wants to spy on you.
- hughw 11y agoAny device could have its own connection to the mobile network, a la Kindle.
- qb45 11y ago> How about smart TVs? Give it a few years and you’ll have hundreds of millions of TVs with a camera on them exposed to the wild. Without available firmware updates, you forgot to add.
- achillean 11y agoFYI: you can already find smart TVs connected to the Internet. Here is a search query for Vizio TVs: https://www.shodan.io/search?query=port%3A8099+unknown+message https://www.shodan.io/search?query=port%3A8099+unknown+messa...
- bostik 11y agoThis is tge reason I pushed down hard on our design for TV walls and monitoring screens. We have set up a number of TV screens around the office (some as walls, some individuals). I refused to have any of them plugged in to our office network, because I don't trust the smart TVs to either remain secure or not to spy on us "accidentally". So each TV will be a dumb screen. Output is provided by two Raspberry Pies - one for each of the first two HDMI inputs. HDMI 1 = monitoring, HDMI 2 = office IPTV. The TV feed network is physically separated from everything else, and connected to a dedicated switch. With no uplink to internet. And to give some context, we discussed our setup with some of the Cloudflare engineers in London. They consider our setup "pretty hardcore". From a company that lives by security, we consider that a compliment.
- icedchai 11y agoAren't most people at least putting their TV behind a firewall / NAT box?