3 ms·
C is self-contradicting. "10x engineer" means "an engineer that's ten times better than most others", and if most others are ten times worse than someone, then
by StavrosK 11y ago
C is self-contradicting. "10x engineer" means "an engineer that's ten times better than most others", and if most others are ten times worse than someone, then that person is a 10x engineer.
Also, I hate the term "10x engineer". Everything follows a normal distribution.
- rewqfdsa 11y ago> Everything follows a normal distribution. Evidence suggests that technical talent is bimodal.
- danbruc 11y agoCan you back this up with some data? This might actually match my observations but I never considered the possibility that it might be a bimodal distribution.
- tamana 11y agoWhat evidence? There was a famous study by a college professor 10 years ago, but he retracted his research as flawed.
- tbrownaw 11y agoIs there anything more to that than just willingness to learn (like how some people will ignore the instructions and then demand help because "it doesn't work")?
- criley2 11y ago>Also, I hate the term "10x engineer". Everything follows a normal distribution. A normal distribution doesn't preclude the existence of a 10X, just describes the rarity.
- StavrosK 11y agoYes, and it's so well-understood that talking about whether 10x engineers do and don't exist is ridiculous. It seems like it's just a circlejerk, where everybody secretly thinks they're a 10x engineer so we keep talking about it.
- dwiel 11y agoIt doesnt even describe the rarity without a mean and standard deviation
- jasode 11y ago>Also, I hate the term "10x engineer" Even if people were to use a new term such as "3-Sigma Programmer" instead of "10X Programmer", the ensuing debates would still be the same. To make peace with the "10x" label, I suggest people just think of it as a figure-of-speech instead of a mathematical term. We don't get hung up when people say "Star Wars IV was ten times better than Phantom Menace" or "I'm not even 1/2 the football player I used to be."
- StavrosK 11y agoThen what are we arguing about? Whether there are people who are much better than other people? That's trivially true.
- braythwayt 11y agoWell, what if you don’t have “most others” being 10x worse than someone in general, but you have a few .1x engineers. If you put them all on the same team as a 1x engineer, there will be the perception that one engineer is 10x most programmers.
- banku_brougham 11y agoYes, absolutely everything follows a normal distribution. Everything.
- laxatives 11y agoNothing follows a normal distribution at the ends. Almost everything has fat tails.
- empthought 11y ago> Everything follows a normal distribution. Yes, this is why the 60 wealthiest people have as much wealth as half of the world combined.