2 ms·
1. "a source close to the filmmakers has told the Daily Mail that BB-8 is definitely 'a she'" is not really what I'd call reliable. Furthermore, in the actual
by geofft 11y ago
1. "a source close to the filmmakers has told the Daily Mail that BB-8 is definitely 'a she'" is not really what I'd call reliable.
Furthermore, in the actual film (which was released after this article was published), BB-8 is only referred to as "he"/"him". The anonymous informant claims, "JJ was determined to make BB-8 cute and strong – and female." But Daisy Ridley is quoted by Time as saying, "I remember J.J. saying, 'He's not a child.'" Abrams is quoted as telling Entertainment Weekly, "I named him BB-8 because it was almost onomatopoeia. It was sort of how he looked to me, with the 8, obviously, and then the two B's." There's a video of Abrams answering the question just before the film's release at http://collider.com/bb8-boy-girl-gender-star-wars-7-the-force-awakens/ http://collider.com/bb8-boy-girl-gender-star-wars-7-the-forc... with, "I always referred to him as 'he', but that's just sort of a, you know, I haven't checked. I haven't looked under the hood."
So I doubt the leaker's claim that Abrams was "determined to make BB-8 female".
2. A female robot is just a tiny bit different from a female human. But it's not even that: it's a gender-ambiguous robot, whose femininity consists of solely a pronoun used by one executive and an anonymous source, and could have easily been male. That seems to be a serious cop-out. You might as well say that the Millennium Falcon satisfies the request for female toys (the ship is regularly referred to as "she" in the original trilogy).