5 ms·

I've been looking for an on-premise Trello for months and WeKan seems to be the best option for now. How would you guys feel about deploying such a project for

I've been looking for an on-premise Trello for months and WeKan seems to be the best option for now. How would you guys feel about deploying such a project for 300 people? Too soon?

the_common_man 11y ago
As pointed out in another comment, there are no tests. Developer confidence doesn't matter at that point. You can help them out at https://github.com/wekan/wekan/issues/467 https://github.com/wekan/wekan/issues/467
- medlazik 11y ago
  Thanks. I realize how premature my wish is but unfortunately not in my qualifications to help on the project. Modern group chat and Kanban are two apps my users desperately want and I can't deliver unless I capitulate to our cloud overlords, such a sad state of the industry.
  - bovermyer 11y ago
    Wouldn't Mattermost solve the group chat issue for you?
  - webXL 11y ago
    This sentiment is what's sad. You appear to want something good, free and quick. Life is all about picking 2. Accept that and be happy.
    - medlazik 11y ago
      Who said I wanted it to be free? I'm also in France and our clients don't want us to manage their projects on American servers.
      - berkay 11y ago
        You can get a self hosted HipChat for the group chat.
        medlazik 11y ago
        We've had a pilot for 6 months, users stopped using it. Something's fishy with the HipChat team. They've been asked to fix iPhone notifications[0] for more than a year now and all I see is new emoticons and silly features. Nobody with an iPhone can use HipChat, no wonder everyone went to Slack. Smells like internal sabotage, crazy stuff really. [0]https://help.hipchat.com/forums/138883-suggestions-ideas/suggestions/3830661-iphone-don-t-seem-to-be-receiving-any-notification https://help.hipchat.com/forums/138883-suggestions-ideas/sug...
  - joeyspn 11y ago
    > Modern group chat [...] There's another great Meteor project named Rocket Chat that you should check out... https://rocket.chat/ https://rocket.chat/
    - medlazik 11y ago
      We've tried them all and unfortunately none of them are ready for prime time. Rocket chat and Mattermost are the ones I'm the most looking forward to, looks like they should be ready in a few months. HipChat Server looks ready but it's not, way too many problems they're not willing to address for whatever reasons.
      - detaro 11y ago
        Did you document your issues somewhere publicly? (blog post?) A good comparison of the options would be interesting to have, since the topic seems to come up quite often.
        medlazik 11y ago
        I haven't but it's a good idea.
MrBlue 11y ago
"How would you guys feel about deploying such a project for 300 people?" As long as they don't all try to connect at the same time you should be fine.
kentonv 11y ago
I've been using Wekan daily for a while now and I'd say it's pretty solid. I hope you'll also consider running Wekan on top of Sandstorm (I'm the lead developer of Sandstorm). Wekan's developer is a fan of Sandstorm, as you can see here: https://discuss.wekan.io/t/support-exclusively-sandstorm/135 https://discuss.wekan.io/t/support-exclusively-sandstorm/135 You might find some other apps you'd like to run on-prem. :) https://apps.sandstorm.io https://apps.sandstorm.io
- medlazik 11y ago
  I've used Sandstorm when I tried Wekan but didn't really take the time to look into it, couldn't find anything about ldap integration with either Sandstorm or Wekan. Now I've just read a bit more about it and a centralized app portal sure looks very interesting. I'll contact you guys in the next few weeks for your "Sandstorm + Business" offerings ;)

I've been looking for an on-premise Trello for months and WeKan seems to be the best option for now. How would you guys feel about deploying such a project for 300 people? Too soon?

the_common_man 11y ago

As pointed out in another comment, there are no tests. Developer confidence doesn't matter at that point. You can help them out at https://github.com/wekan/wekan/issues/467 https://github.com/wekan/wekan/issues/467

medlazik 11y ago
Thanks. I realize how premature my wish is but unfortunately not in my qualifications to help on the project. Modern group chat and Kanban are two apps my users desperately want and I can't deliver unless I capitulate to our cloud overlords, such a sad state of the industry.
- bovermyer 11y ago
  Wouldn't Mattermost solve the group chat issue for you?
- webXL 11y ago
  This sentiment is what's sad. You appear to want something good, free and quick. Life is all about picking 2. Accept that and be happy.
  - medlazik 11y ago
    Who said I wanted it to be free? I'm also in France and our clients don't want us to manage their projects on American servers.
    - berkay 11y ago
      You can get a self hosted HipChat for the group chat.
      - medlazik 11y ago
        We've had a pilot for 6 months, users stopped using it. Something's fishy with the HipChat team. They've been asked to fix iPhone notifications[0] for more than a year now and all I see is new emoticons and silly features. Nobody with an iPhone can use HipChat, no wonder everyone went to Slack. Smells like internal sabotage, crazy stuff really. [0]https://help.hipchat.com/forums/138883-suggestions-ideas/suggestions/3830661-iphone-don-t-seem-to-be-receiving-any-notification https://help.hipchat.com/forums/138883-suggestions-ideas/sug...
- joeyspn 11y ago
  > Modern group chat [...] There's another great Meteor project named Rocket Chat that you should check out... https://rocket.chat/ https://rocket.chat/
  - medlazik 11y ago
    We've tried them all and unfortunately none of them are ready for prime time. Rocket chat and Mattermost are the ones I'm the most looking forward to, looks like they should be ready in a few months. HipChat Server looks ready but it's not, way too many problems they're not willing to address for whatever reasons.
    - detaro 11y ago
      Did you document your issues somewhere publicly? (blog post?) A good comparison of the options would be interesting to have, since the topic seems to come up quite often.
      - medlazik 11y ago
        I haven't but it's a good idea.

MrBlue 11y ago

"How would you guys feel about deploying such a project for 300 people?" As long as they don't all try to connect at the same time you should be fine.

kentonv 11y ago

I've been using Wekan daily for a while now and I'd say it's pretty solid. I hope you'll also consider running Wekan on top of Sandstorm (I'm the lead developer of Sandstorm). Wekan's developer is a fan of Sandstorm, as you can see here: https://discuss.wekan.io/t/support-exclusively-sandstorm/135 https://discuss.wekan.io/t/support-exclusively-sandstorm/135 You might find some other apps you'd like to run on-prem. :) https://apps.sandstorm.io https://apps.sandstorm.io

medlazik 11y ago
I've used Sandstorm when I tried Wekan but didn't really take the time to look into it, couldn't find anything about ldap integration with either Sandstorm or Wekan. Now I've just read a bit more about it and a centralized app portal sure looks very interesting. I'll contact you guys in the next few weeks for your "Sandstorm + Business" offerings ;)