23 ms·
Generation Uphill
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- cheriot 11y agoWhere's the connection between mellinials in China and the West? Wildly different challenges.
- throwaway13337 11y agoBoth groups have a hard time with the basics: getting a job, being able to afford a place to live where the jobs are, and most importantly (implied by the difficulty finding a mate) getting respect because of the lack of first two.
- spangry 11y agoI'd say more difference than connection. China is facing a terrifying 'demographic cliff' due to the previous 1 child policy, much more so than western nations. This also skewed gender towards males in the Chinese Gen Y cohort (http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=89572563 http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=8957256...). Similar story is rural India; lots of 'missing women' from the population. In both cases, the first born son is/was culturally expected to be the 'old age pension fund' of the parents, whereas girls were considered financial liabilities until they could be married off (i.e. someone else's problem). The very disturbing implication being: if you can only have 1 child, and you believe only boys can support you in retirement, what do you do when you give birth and find out it's a girl?
- simula67 11y agoYes, this is why it is illegal to determine the sex of the child before birth in India https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prenatal_sex_discernment#India https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prenatal_sex_discernment#India
- spangry 11y agoI honestly wonder if this does more harm than good. By which I mean it leads to more of this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-child_policy#Effect_on_infanticide_rates https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-child_policy#Effect_on_inf... and this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Female_infanticide_in_India#Contemporary_data_and_statistics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Female_infanticide_in_India#Co... "The 'one-child' policy has also led to what Amartya Sen first called 'Missing Women', or the 100 million girls 'missing' from the populations of China (and other developing countries) as a result of female infanticide, abandonment, and neglect".
- tonyedgecombe 11y agoChina's 'demographic cliff' was already happening before the one child policy was introduced.
- analyst74 11y ago> The very disturbing implication being: if you can only have 1 child, and you believe only boys can support you in retirement, what do you do when you give birth and find out it's a girl? In China's urban populations at least, it is increasingly common for women to take care of their aging parents, I imagine this is partly due to one-child policy. Another interesting shift in social norm is, now single guys need to have a house to be considered an "eligible bachelor", which is a considerable financial burden to many parents due to ballooning housing costs. Those who preferred sons 20 years ago are probably feeling the burn right now.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- noobie 11y agowww.economist.com - Access Denied Error code 16 This request was blocked by the security rules Okaaaaay Edit: Strangely The Economist seems to be blocking Tunisian IP addresses.
- tobias3 11y agoI had to enter a captcha yesterday for the first time at their page. I think they are under a DDOS attack.
- Lunchbox_radio 11y agoSHEN XIANG LIVES in a shipping crate on a construction site in Shanghai which he shares with at least seven other young workers. He sleeps in a bunk and uses a bucket to wash in. “It’s uncomfortable,” he says. Still, he pays no rent and the walk to work is only a few paces. Mr Shen, who was born in 1989, hails from a village of “mountains, rivers and trees”. He is a migrant worker and the son of two migrants, so he has always been a second-class citizen in his own country. In China, many public services in cities are reserved for those with a hukou (residence permit). Despite recent reforms, it is still hard for a rural migrant to obtain a big-city hukou. Mr Shen was shut out of government schools in Shanghai even though his parents worked there. Instead he had to make do with a worse one back in his village. Now he paints hotels. The pay is good—300 yuan ($47) for an 11-hour day—and jobs are more plentiful in Shanghai than back in the countryside. His ambition is “to get married as fast as I can”. But he cannot afford to. There are more young men than young women in China because so many girl babies were aborted in previous decades. So the women today can afford to be picky. Mr Shen had a girlfriend once, but her family demanded that he buy her a house. “I didn’t have enough money, so we broke up,” he recalls. Mr Shen doubts that he will ever be able to buy a flat in Shanghai. In any case, without the right hukou his children would not get subsidised education or health care there. “It’s unfair,” he says. There are 1.8 billion young people in the world, roughly a quarter of the total population. (This report defines “young” as between about 15 and 30.) All generalisations about such a vast group should be taken with a bucket of salt. What is true of young Chinese may not apply to young Americans or Burundians. But the young do have some things in common: they grew up in the age of smartphones and in the shadow of a global financial disaster. They fret that it is hard to get a good education, a steady job, a home and—eventually—a mate with whom to start a family. Companies are obsessed with understanding how “millennials” think, the better to recruit them or sell them stuff. Consultants churn out endless reports explaining that they like to share, require constant praise and so forth. Pundits fret that millennials in rich countries never seem to grow out of adolescence, with their constant posting of selfies on social media and their desire for “safe spaces” at university, shielded from discomforting ideas. This report takes a global view, since 85% of young people live in developing countries, and focuses on practical matters, such as education and jobs. And it will argue that the young are an oppressed minority, held back by their elders. They are unlike other oppressed minorities, of course. Their “oppressors” do not set out to harm them. On the contrary, they often love and nurture them. Many would gladly swap places with them, too. In some respects the young have never had it so good. They are richer and likely to live longer than any previous generation. On their smartphones they can find all the information in the world. If they are female or gay, in most countries they enjoy freedoms that their predecessors could barely have imagined. They are also brainier than any previous generation. Average scores on intelligence tests have been rising for decades in many countries, thanks to better nutrition and mass education. Yet much of their talent is being squandered. In most regions they are at least twice as likely as their elders to be unemployed. Over 25% of youngsters in middle-income nations and 15% in rich ones are NEETs: not in education, employment or training. The job market they are entering is more competitive than ever, and in many countries the rules are rigged to favour those who already have a job. Education has become so expensive that many students rack up heavy debts. Housing has grown costlier, too, especially in the globally connected megacities where the best jobs are. Young people yearn to move to such cities: beside higher pay, they offer excitement and a wide selection of other young people to date or marry. Yet constraints on the supply of housing make that hard. For both sexes the path to adulthood—from school to work, marriage and children—has become longer and more complicated. Mostly, this is a good thing. Many young people now study until their mid-20s and put off having children until their late 30s. They form families later partly because they want to and partly because it is taking them longer to become established in their careers and feel financially secure. Alas, despite improvements in fertility treatment the biological clock has not been reset to accommodate modern working lives. Throughout human history, the old have subsidised the young. In rich countries, however, that flow has recently started to reverse. Ronald Lee of the University of California, Berkeley, and Andrew Mason at the University of Hawaii measured how much people earn at different ages in 23 countries, and how much they consume. Within families, intergenerational transfers still flow almost entirely from older to younger. However, in rich countries public spending favours pensions and health care for the old over education for the young. Much of this is paid for by borrowing, and the bill will one day land on the young. In five of 23 countries in Messrs Lee and Mason’s sample (Germany, Austria, Japan, Slovenia and Hungary), the net flow of resources (public plus private) is now heading from young to old, who tend to be richer. As societies age, many more will join them. Politicians in democracies listen to the people who vote—which young people seldom do. Only 23% of Americans aged 18-34 cast a ballot in the 2014 mid-term elections, compared with 59% of the over-65s. In Britain’s 2015 general election only 43% of the 18-24s but 78% of the over-65s voted. In both countries the party favoured by older voters won a thumping victory. “My generation has a huge interest in political causes but a lack of faith in political parties,” says Aditi Shorewal, the editor of a student paper at King’s College, London. In autocracies the young are even more disillusioned. In one survey, only 10% of Chinese respondents thought that young people’s career prospects depended more on hard work or ability than on family connections. All countries need to work harder to give the young a fair shot. If they do not, a whole generation’s talents could be wasted. That would not only be immoral; it would also be dangerous. Angry young people sometimes start revolutions, as the despots overthrown in the Arab Spring can attest.
- minikites 11y ago> Throughout human history, the old have subsidised the young. In rich countries, however, that flow has recently started to reverse. Ronald Lee of the University of California, Berkeley, and Andrew Mason at the University of Hawaii measured how much people earn at different ages in 23 countries, and how much they consume. Within families, intergenerational transfers still flow almost entirely from older to younger. However, in rich countries public spending favours pensions and health care for the old over education for the young. Speaking in broad strokes (i.e. I'm sure there are plenty of individual examples to the contrary) the baby boom generation is the most selfish generation in recent history, voting to cut taxes and benefits for government and societal services after they had gotten their full use out of them. http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/yes-summer-job-paid-tuition-back-in-rsquo81-but-then-we-got-cheap/ http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/yes-summer-job-paid... > What really made me feel ancient is that the 1981 UW student guide shows the Med school charged only $1,029 a year back then. Today: $28,040! > The reason a summer at KFC could pay for a year of UW med school in 1981 isn’t that we were so hardworking and industrious. It’s that taxpayers back then picked up 90 percent of the tab. We weren’t Horatio Algers. We were socialists. > Today, the public picks up only 30 percent of UW tuition, and dropping. Imagine what would happen if young people actually voted.
- magicGLASSman 11y agoWhy not get to the root of the problem? An education should not cost that much. Much of the reason the cost has outpaced inflation is the subsidizing of the tuition price paid by the student instead of making the process of educating less costly by using technology. Imagine what would happen if a degree was about what you know, not just a credential.
- reirob 11y agoEducation should not cost anything at all. Full stop. Free education for everybody should be considered the biggest achievement by human beings. If a society is not able to provide free education for the upcoming generations, then the basis of such a society should be questioned, rightfully so.
- orthoganol 11y agoI can relate to the allegation that baby boomers like to 'keep millennials down' - I truly cannot stand aspects of family renunions with aunts, uncles, even my parents who casually dismiss the majority of things I stand for or aspire to as 'a phase' or as 'nerdy'... meanwhile they swear by Fox News, pedal oversimplified, uncompromising viewpoints, and are more interested in talking to me about how I find time to party than the projects I work on ("Work hard, party hard, Orthoganol"). I sit at my grandfather's table when I can, maybe it's just an effect of old age, but I feel like his generation better understands the important things.
- WalterBright 11y ago> 'a phase' If you aren't a liberal by age 20, you don't have a heart. If you aren't a conservative by age 35, you don't have a brain. http://quoteinvestigator.com/2014/02/24/heart-head/ http://quoteinvestigator.com/2014/02/24/heart-head/ My generation blamed the previous one, as well. "Don't trust anyone over 30", "Hope I die before I get old", etc.
- orthoganol 11y agoI think it's too simple to say "this is how all generations think of the previous one." I think baby boomers, admirably, set out to create a new identity - coming of age at the height of the 60s, time of prosperity meaning more independence, with Vietnam and the civil rights movements probably casting doubts about the prior generation's values (rightfully so). A clean break of sorts. I think the problem is they threw out the old, but failed to actually assert something substantial that could raise the next generation. Vague values and sentiments, really. Millennials get told to just be ourselves, find our passions, and are encouraged to party, drink, have sex... don't work too hard. Partying is treated almost as importantly if not more, as working hard to make something out of yourself and your life. Nerd culture is despised, maybe because they all watched a ton of jock 80s movies. I don't doubt a correlation between being raised on those values and the depression and mental illness rates we see today among young people... you can surely overcome it eventually, but you're raised on it by default. I'm painting with a broad stroke, but I think the baby boomers represent a sort of 'break' with the generations before them, and it didn't set up the next generation so well. My grandfather's generation, while they weren't socially progressive by any means, seems more grounded overall - they at least have access to the wisdom of many generations before.
- gizi 11y agoThe internet has solved most problems that the article is referring to; but not for everybody. From his "village of mountains, rivers and trees" he could create the next facebook on his laptop (or even something less ambitious). The reason why he does not do that, has nothing to do with a lack of "hukou" privilege. When he says: "It is unfair", he is fixating himself on a problem that he cannot solve, instead of moving on. Seriously, the "hukou"-holding Chinese are as ignorant as he is. They will not create the next facebook either. There is nothing to learn from them or their schools. That is what him and 99% of the world's population don't seem to see. With the internet around, location does not matter. You can make exactly as much money as your intelligence allows you to. That means: almost nothing in terms of money for the "hukou" guys.
- tdaltonc 11y agoI don't think I got a satisfying answer to "Why now?" Why has the gerontocracy suddenly taken over in so many countries?
- roymurdock 11y agoThis article does not address trends in health care or pension spend. These are the two largest total (federal, state, and local combined) spend items in our collective budget. 2015 figures: Total Spend: 6.18tn Total Revenue: 6.08tn Healthcare: 1.32tn (21.3%) Pension: 1.20tn (19.7%) Education: 0.93tn (14.8%) Defense: 0.80tn (13.1%) Welfare: 0.50tn (8.2%) Other*: 1.43tn (23.1%) *Other = Protection, Transportation, General Government, Interest Healthcare expenses lean heavily towards the old but are funded by the working age population. What happens as the birth rate decreases and the average individual lives longer? Expenses increase for the working-age population. Currently, social security is taking in ~$74bn less in payroll taxes than it pays out in benefits. The $2.83tn fund is invested in federal debt that pays 3.4% interest. So the interest payment (from the Federal government) of $96.2b is enough to cover the deficit. By 2020, interest will no longer be enough to cover the deficit between revenue in from taxes and expenditures out to retirees. At that point, the SS fund will need to start redeeming treasuries for cash. The federal government will then need to issue new debt and/or raise taxes to cover SS treasury bond redemptions. If the Federal Reserve follows through in its quest to raise interest rates and inflation, it will be relatively expensive to raise the $2.83tn in debt that we will need to fund SS through 2029, when it is projected to completely deplete its reserves of treasury notes. At this point, SS will only be able to pay out 75% of promised benefits given the current tax rate and demographic trends. I'm less concerned about spend on education (which is broken) than I am about how we plan to fund our health care and pension systems. The only feasible way I can see is through increased taxation. I just started working last year. Hell of a time to enter the work force! Overall it seems to me like we are paying an increasing amount of our federal budget on the older population than we anticipated we would need to and that we did not adequately provision for.
- iofj 11y agoAnd to think I'll be "getting a pension" (or so I'm told) in 2047, or 18 years after Social security is broke, assuming 4% average return, which we're not getting.
- stygiansonic 11y agoFrom the article: "They are also brainier than any previous generation. Average scores on intelligence tests have been rising for decades in many countries, thanks to better nutrition and mass education." Is this true? From what I've read on the Flynn effect[0], these are only possible explanations. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect#Proposed_explanations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect#Proposed_explanat...
- JBiserkov 11y ago>Politicians in democracies listen to the people who vote. A reasonable observer would conclude that either a) the statement is false because politicians listen to the people with power/money b) the set of democracies is empty, and the statement, while true, is a tautology.