4 ms·
I find it incredible, too. As UnoriginalGuy says, lab tests don't always tell you what's going wrong in the field. But the fact that they don't know what's ha
by CamperBob2 11y ago
I find it incredible, too. As UnoriginalGuy says, lab tests don't always tell you what's going wrong in the field. But the fact that they don't know what's happening (if that's true at all, some other posts have called the whole article into question) is still the designers' fault. With modern hardware, the most important thing -- the thing you start building on Day #1 of the project -- is built-in diagnostics.
In the case of something like the 737 rudder problem, those planes were designed 40 years ago, in an era when it wasn't practical to record every bit of operating data in real time, or add cheap, lightweight sensors to everything in sight. That's not true anymore. Whether they're building a drone, a fighter plane, a spacecraft, or even a modern passenger car, there is no excuse for requiring people to stand around some wreckage scratching their heads. The onboard controllers should be able to tell them exactly what went wrong. If they can't, then that's the problem to be solved first.
- metaphor 11y agoI'm having a difficult time imagining anything "cheap" about a complex sensor diagnostic system integrated into a defense aerospace platform with big daddy ACAT 1D program status whose acquisition strategy revolved around cost reduction.
- CamperBob2 11y agoWell, here we're seeing the cost of not adding that stuff.
- toss1 11y agoYes, we do now have far better onboard sensor suites and logging than in decades past. And this can provide incredible amounts of information, and get us closer to the source of issues much faster. Many times, it makes the issue immediately obvious and documented. HOWEVER! Do NOT make assumptions and fool yourself into thinking this is a cure-all. There are many problems that, while the logged sensor data narrows it down and provides clues, it can sometimes either not provide the critical clues, or can even be misleading. Yes, sometimes adding more sensors focused on the issue may help, but not always. Sometimes it is just down to the hard work of finding the peculiar circumstances and interactions that cause previously unknown failure modes. Been there, done that (UAV & motorsport systems), seen lots of very smart & experienced engineers stumped for way longer than you'd expect.