3 ms·
The NSA chief shouldn't be pro-encryption if they're doing their legal job: collect anything needed to advance America's interests or advise on threats to natio
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
The NSA chief shouldn't be pro-encryption if they're doing their legal job: collect anything needed to advance America's interests or advise on threats to national security; protect communication security of defense-related systems. Like Hayden said, you draw a box around him and he'll push straight to the edges of it to accomplish his mission. The problem is the NSA's mission is too broad, unrealistic, and essentially evil. It basically requires them to do what they're doing as there's no other option and the I.C. will get blamed by Americans and Congress if anything happens. Surveillance and security theater follow.
I wrote it up in detail here:
http://pastebin.com/J2kc9miz http://pastebin.com/J2kc9miz
This is coming from someone whose alternatively imitated them (IAD Type 1 specifically) or attempted to counter them (high assurance security) for around a decade. What goes in determines what comes out. The problem is not the NSA: it's what they're required to do and lack of strong accountability in how they do it. That they were non-threatening to Americans before 9/11 & mission expansion supports my claim.
- willvarfar 11y agoNickp on schneiers blog comments?
- nickpsecurity 11y agoYep! :) That's still where the master copies of my essays and designs stay. Aside from the text file of links to them I email people on occasion. Been more INFOSEC discussions over here, though, so that's where I've been if you were wondering.