2 ms·
I recently finished reading "IBM and the Holocaust" by Edwin Black. Hitler's purges are really not reasonably debatable: the Third Reich employed statisticians
by scott_s 17y ago
I recently finished reading "IBM and the Holocaust" by Edwin Black. Hitler's purges are really not reasonably debatable: the Third Reich employed statisticians who came up with racial theories to determine how "Jewish" a person was. They published their work in journals. They clearly tried to couch their bigotry in scientific terms.
With that said, I don't know what your operating definition of "intellectualism" is. Mine is just one who values and seeks out learning for its own sake.
- jerf 17y agoFair enough. I'll leave my post as-is for the record but consider it edited. Further followup, it is obvious that "intellectualism" can have many definitions. My primary point is to demonstrate that for a large set of definitions, mistrust is rational. Playing with the definitions as so many of my repliers do makes it easy to lose the point in a flurry of words as we redefine "intellectualism" to something harmless by definition, which proves nothing about what's out there in the real world. All this is a way of obscuring and hiding from my point, though, which is that there is a kernel of truth here. That there are definitions of "intellectualism" that are not scary does not prove that there isn't a rather large, scary line of "intellectualism" that has proved very dangerous in the real world, seductive academic ideas and theories trusted over empirical evidence to dangerous effect.