6 ms·
Yep, you beat me to it. It's like a variant on the old joke[1]: "You must be a profiteer." 'Sure, I guess I count as one. How'd you know?' "Well, you learn
by SilasX 11y ago
Yep, you beat me to it. It's like a variant on the old joke[1]:
"You must be a profiteer."
'Sure, I guess I count as one. How'd you know?'
"Well, you learned about the immense, tragic problem of homelessness, and apparently your first thought was, wow, awesome, a cheap labor force I can use to cut costs!"
'Hm, okay, fair enough. You must be a philosopher then.'
"Yes! You're right! How'd you know?"
'Well, because homelessness has been around for ages, and appears to be intractable, and you've been unable to make any real progress on it, and yet when I offer homeless people an alternative to their current state, and some of them take it, somehow, the whole problem is all my fault."
[1] https://www2.bc.edu/~radinr/Management_Humor/jokes.htm https://www2.bc.edu/~radinr/Management_Humor/jokes.htm
- bottled_poe 11y agoYes, yes, very good. But seriously, if you are paying your employees below minimum wage, then one of the following must be true: -Your business doesn't make enough income, possibly a sign of a bad business model; or -You are intentionally paying your employees as little as possible, which I see as profiteering. Perhaps there are other reasons?
- afarrell 11y agoDo you feel the same way about Goodwill?
- vkou 11y agoGoodwill's a non-profit. Despite their earning statements, Amazon is only a 'non-profit' on paper.
- jonah 11y agoGoodwill may technically be a "non-profit" but they're hardly altruistic.
- SilasX 11y agoRight, that's exactly a paradox/error that the Copenhagen critique elucidates: two groups have (basically) the same effect on the world (providing the opportunity to have regular work to do in exchange for money), but you only rebuke one of them, since they're doing it for profit. I can think of logical reasons to justify distinguishing them, but I rarely see such reasons made explicit. (One reason might be that there's a greater incentive to cut corners on worker treatment when you're for profit rather then just doing it out of the goodness of your heart, but that would justify at most tighter oversight, not moral condemnation of doing the thing at all, as we normally see.)
- bduerst 11y ago>paradox/error There is none. The ends don't justify the means (Kantian ethics). There are network effects of a giant for-profit organization exploiting the jobless, vs a non-profit that is regulated to be aligned with the jobless. If you're using rational beings as a means to your ends, they need to be part of the ends, which is why Amazon is being criticized.
- Pyxl101 11y ago> exploiting the jobless You're committing the fallacy described by the "Copenhagen interpretation of ethics". http://blog.jaibot.com/the-copenhagen-interpretation-of-ethics/ http://blog.jaibot.com/the-copenhagen-interpretation-of-ethi... First, why do you describe offering someone a job as exploitation? It's totally not. Giving someone an option they didn't have before makes them strictly better off. They can choose between it and their other options. Working a job when you didn't have one before tends to make a person better off - either way it's up to them, and either way, it's one more option they didn't have before. Second, just by interacting with the situation, you don't become responsible for it. The homeless' situation is not a potential employer's responsibility any more than it is yours personally or any other person's on the world. What are you doing about the homeless problem? Employers who go out of their way to offer homeless jobs, and to indicate that they won't discriminate based on that background, are actually giving them the opportunity to improve their lives. By comparison, most people involved in the thread will have done nothing at all to help homeless or give them opportunities, despite criticizing employers who do. (Please read the link above; it offers a useful discussion of the issues.)
- normand1 11y agoNo company is paying people below minimum wage... it's literally the minimum wage.
- LoSboccacc 11y agoIsn't the whole point of outsourcing paying below minimum wage? (Also I guess more lenient pollution laws)
- RijilV 11y agoThese positions were in Western Washington outside of Seattle. Standard minimum wages apply and Amazon has a history of paying above min wage.
- Arnt 11y agoNo, the main point is to get labour at a lower total cost, even though you can't predict very well how much you'll need. Sign up to a call center, and they'll say "we'll answer your calls and bill you per call. If you want to do it yourself you can, but in order to cover the peaks you'll have to hire so many people that most are idle during the troughs... we know how to plan this and scale and things and more things, and you don't so why don't you just let us do it?" Getting around irritating minimum wages and other laws is a fringe benefit. Scaling the headcount is the big one.
- belorn 11y agoTo make the term "minimum wage" useful, it must have a bunch of qualifier like "minimum wage as set by the law for a set amount of work hours, under the condition that they don't earn other wages". Otherwise special conditions like symbolic wages will ruin the term for everyone.
- specialist 11y agoThere are plenty of exceptions to minimum wage. Training, interns, students, restaurant servers, etc. YMMV per jurisdiction. Not to mention wage theft, not paying overtime, pretending your workers are not employees, etc.
- 11y ago
- rebootthesystem 11y agoSure: Minimum wage is too high and the market should set it, not government. BTW, when I started working minimum wage was under $4/hr. Within four years I was making over 6 times that much. Two years later, over twelve times. Another four years had me at 25 times minimum wage. The secret? I worked and studied hard. I took nothing for granted and $4 per hour was not enough to be comfortable.
- gambiting 11y agoSo how about using prison labour, where people are paid 10 cents(or however much, it's an example not a solid number) an hour? The only difference between homeless people and prisoners in that case is that homeless people are not in prison. But the job they do serves the same purpose - offers them something to break the cycle of what they are doing currently.
- rmc 11y agoAlthough homelessness has been around for ever, there are things governments can do to reduce it. There is a reason there are more homeless people in San Francisco than all of England.
- gadders 11y agoYes. Homeless people are encouraged to move there, and people working in charities rely on their existence for their livelihood. http://www.city-journal.org/2010/20_4_san-francisco-homeless.html http://www.city-journal.org/2010/20_4_san-francisco-homeless...
- PavlovsCat 11y agoHow old is homelessness, though?
- DonHopkins 11y agoIt used to be call cavelessness.
- PavlovsCat 11y agoGot anything more than the assumption it was around "since forever"? The only stuff I could find relates to modern history.
- crdoconnor 11y ago>Well, because homelessness has been around for ages, and appears to be intractable It's not at all intractable. Giving jobs to the jobless and homes to the homeless is exactly as straightforward as it looks. The homeless and jobless serve a function, though - to keep wages and agitation down for the precariously employed and the precariously housed. They're like this mainly for the benefit of corporations like Amazon which farm cheap labor. Effectively the homeless serve as a form of 'public good' for the owners of capital. That's why proposals to house or give homeless jobs with government money are met with sheer disgust by the same media that happily endorses spending billions of dollars dropping bombs on brown children.
- BetaCygni 11y agoIt is not straightforward at all. Most homeless people suffer from a mental illness. You'd have to treat that first. Some of them might not want to be treated though... The notion that the owners of capital would want to have homeless people is absurd. The "capitalists" would like everyone to be working, as higher production means more profits for them. The state may need to step in with a minimum wage (or basic income), but otherwise the system should work fine.
- crdoconnor 11y ago>It is not straightforward at all. Most homeless people suffer from a mental illness. Unsurprisingly unemployment and homelessness and being told that it's all your fault causes mental illness, especially when combined with attempts to self medicate with drugs or alcohol. >The notion that the owners of capital would want to have homeless people is absurd. The "capitalists" would like everyone to be working, as higher production means more profits for them. More unemployed + homeless => More afraid workers => Workers who are willing to take a lower wage => Higher profits The notion that higher production automatically leads to higher profits is pretty comical.
- Decade 11y ago>>It is not straightforward at all. Most homeless people suffer from a mental illness. >Unsurprisingly unemployment and homelessness and being told that it's all your fault causes mental illness, especially when combined with attempts to self medicate with drugs or alcohol. Achievement unlocked: Trivialized mental illness. Being homeless is certainly stressful on the psyche, but not every crazy homeless person started as a sane homeless person. Some people just cannot function as independent adults. One person I know managed to score Section 8 housing, and she trashed the apartment and threatened the landlord and ended up on the street. Until her condition deteriorated enough for the police to call a 5150 on her. But she doesn't consider herself crazy. Just stressed out. Modern liberation theory means the institutions consider her to be an adult, so if she says she doesn't want to stay in an asylum, then there's no way for us non-super-rich people to stop her from leaving psychiatric care and ruining her life. There is no firm boundary between crazy and sane, and even being delusional doesn't prevent one from being a productive member of society. We just don't have enough appropriate services for all the crazy people in this country. http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=NGY6DqB1HX8 http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=NGY6DqB1HX8
- pron 11y agoI don't understand. Are there any philosophers saying that the problem of homelessness is Amazon's fault? Because it seems to me that the people who say that that's what philosophers are saying, simply say that to ridicule a position they don't fully understand so they don't have to listen to what the philosophers actually have to say. I mean, if philosophers have been studying the issue for ages, maybe, just maybe they have a point that's at least worth listening to? Because I do know one thing: no one is blaming Amazon for creating the problem of homelessness.