4 ms·
SJW may be a type of feminist, but it alters the meaning of the phrase: "The author is a SJW." as above. Your example just conflates issues, but to use that ex
by Chris2048 11y ago
SJW may be a type of feminist, but it alters the meaning of the phrase: "The author is a SJW." as above.
Your example just conflates issues, but to use that example:
"John is a catholic, so he isn't going to criticize the pope", has a different meaning to "John is a christian, so he isn't going to criticize the pope".
Furthermore, SJW is to feminist as Catholic is to Christian; namely, a subset. Hence avoiding the word 'feminist' is taking your advice.
- acdha 11y agoAgain, this is not that hard: if someone self-identifies as an SJW, you can use that term to refer to them. If they don't, avoid it. In both cases, it's better to specify the precise classification you have in mind rather than confuse everyone who doesn't know how _you_ define that term. For example, you defined SJW as a subset of feminism but the term is also often directed against people who are protesting what they consider racism; gun violence; discrimination against people who are handicapped, practice non-mainstream religions, etc. I know of at least two conservative Republicans who were dismissed as SJWs because they disagreed with things said under the gamergate banner, and they certainly wouldn't label themselves as feminist or progressive.
- Chris2048 11y agoNot that hard? That isn't the issue, and I'll take my own advice, Thanks. BTW, Do you avoid any word ending '-ist' unless someone self-identifies? SJW is no more ambiguous than 'liberal'. If you want a precise classification, follow the context of the conversation. My definition of SJW isn't unique to me. > you defined SJW as a subset of feminism > the term is also often directed against people who are protesting ... Ok, subset of SJ activists, granted feminist activists aren't the only type. But people can protest the same things and not get that label also. It's not what, it's how. That's the extra semantic behind it - Much like the label 'sycophant' will be applied on the basis not for trying to gain advantage, but for how they do it. > who were dismissed as SJWs because they disagreed with things said under the gamergate Many things can be used as a slur. Give me kosher version of SJW I'll use it. In the end though, you can replace the slurs with more clinical descriptions of the kind of behaviors SJWs partake in, and it'll still be negative. Calling someone an SJW is basically accusing them of a particular type of bias, and cultural membership, on the basis observations of their behavior being consistent with that culture. Throw out that practice, you'll be throwing out a lot more than just that phrase.