3 ms·
If the companies spent their savings, rather than hoarding them, the economy would instantly grow, and we would most likely see more jobs with better pay. The
by stickfigure 11y ago
If the companies spent their savings, rather than hoarding them, the economy would instantly grow, and we would most likely see more jobs with better pay.
The article makes it sound like these dollars are somehow being removed from the economy. If they're put in a bank, the bank loans it out to someone else. If they buy treasury bills, the government then takes the money and spends it. Even if all this money was converted to paper notes and stuffed into giant mattresses, the net effect would simply be to deflate the currency and increase the value of everyone else's money.
Hoarding money isn't like hoarding oil or rice or microchips. Maybe GM spending money would grow the economy more than GM loaning it to the federal government so they can spend it, maybe not. Depends on what they spend it on - the return on education is probably higher than the return on fancy pensions or factories for products that nobody buys.
- armenarmen 11y ago> If they're put in a bank, the bank loans it out to someone else. If they buy treasury bills, the government then takes the money and spends it. good call, this is Econ 101 stuff that most people just don't know. Saving money in a bank or government bonds is not the same as locking it in a vault or burying it in your backyard. It is still out moving around in the economy.
- rchaud 11y agoWhile the article certainly worded that portion poorly, there is a difference between monetary velocity of retained earnings parked in a mutual fund, and earnings plowed back into a business. In the former scenario, it takes a much longer time for the money to flow back into the purchase of goods and services. By reinvesting in the business, there is far less of a time lag for that to result in growth-generating economic activity.
- js8 11y agoI think difference between savings and investment (or consumption) is in reversibility. Savings are reversible, basically if you "invest" in any liquid enough assets that keep value, then you save. Investment (and consumption) is irreversible, once you made the decision, it's done deal - somebody does the work, energy is spent, entropy is produced and so on. That's why, contrary to mainstream economic opinion, it is useful to save. Saving lets you react to investment from competitors, by postponing the decision after they made their move. This gives you advantage (power) if you're big enough.
- RobertoG 11y ago"It is still out moving around in the economy." What is this money doing if there is not profit perspective? Nothing. Nobody is claiming that we are short of money, the claim is that this money is not invested.
- dnautics 11y ago> If they're put in a bank, the bank loans it out to someone else Except, that's not happening. The fed is paying banks to not lend out money.