7 ms·
Man arrested for filming Boston police with cellphone camera sues city, officers
- theblackbox 17y ago"Now, Glick - a criminal defense attorney, according to his lawyer" I don't get it. Have Journalistic standards slipped so much that they couldn't even corroborate this simple piece of information? Or is it something I'm missing?
- warfangle 17y agoBecause it's a comment on an ongoing case, the newspaper probably attempted to corroborate the fact with Glick himself, but he probably referred them to his lawyer. It's the smart thing to do, even (some might say especially) if you're a lawyer yourself. Comments on an ongoing case should go through the lawyers involved instead of the individuals involved: they have to be very careful about what they say so as not to tank the case.
- ilamont 17y agoI noticed that too. But it's not hard to verify his occupation, or at least that he used to practice law, either through court documents, LexisNexis, or newspaper archives. One other thing that came up last night on the local public radio station: They interviewed someone from the ACLU who said that if the camera was hidden during the taping, that would be a violation of the law (it wasn't, apparently). That made me wonder: If I had a Web cam on my computer facing outside the window, and it is not obvious that it is a camera (on an iMac it's impossible to see from more than a few feet away) and it captured such an arrest, could I be arrested for secretly taping the scene?
- FahnRobier 17y agoOnly if you are recording audio as well. The wiretapping law applies to secretly recording audio, not video. Edit: A good read, from the RCFP... http://www.rcfp.org/taping/ http://www.rcfp.org/taping/
- swixmix 17y agoIt's not very secret if you're holding up a cell phone. And if that is decidedly secret, then nobody should care as long as the unlawful audio is removed before distribution. I use the term unlawful audio because only the personally identifying information should need to be censored/removed.
- FahnRobier 17y agoI used "secret", probably shouldn't have. The article I referenced says that it varies by state, especially with regards to consent. Some states are single-party, some states require all party consent. But if you're on the street in public, you'd think everything is fair game... especially if you're a public servant. It's nice to see someone taking a stand and clearing it up (in one state at least).
- sokoloff 17y agoOne could argue that the camera was hidden inside of what appeared to be a cell phone.
- moron4hire 17y agoBeing Boston, I'm surprised the cops didn't paint it as a bomb scare. Boston PD has to be neck-and-neck with LAPD for most corrupt police department in the country.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- nebula 17y agoPretty much every other cop movie that I watched had LAPD in it. I wrongly(?) inferred from that were good.
- mtinkerhess 17y agoI imagine the high incidence of LAPD officers has to do with the large movie industry in LA; people making movies in LA are more likely to set them there.
- tibbon 17y ago1-31-07 Never Forget
- moron4hire 17y agoThe Abu Ghraib protester was first http://www.democracynow.org/2004/6/3/boston_protester_faces_felony_charges_for http://www.democracynow.org/2004/6/3/boston_protester_faces_... Then the ATHF thing you referenced http://blog.makezine.com/archive/2008/01/mooninites_from_one_of_th.html http://blog.makezine.com/archive/2008/01/mooninites_from_one... Then a freaking traffic counter that had been put in place by the department of transportation http://www.boingboing.net/2007/02/28/boston-police-blow-u.html http://www.boingboing.net/2007/02/28/boston-police-blow-u.ht... and the MIT student with the LED sweater http://boingboing.net/2007/09/21/mit-student-arrested.html http://boingboing.net/2007/09/21/mit-student-arrested.html These are only the ones I know of. Maybe there are more cases of Boston PD going nutso over some imagined bomb threat. It reminds me of the aftermath of 9/11, all of the soccer moms in my rural home town, running around and buying up all the bottled water and duct tape in town, like they expected The Terr'ists to be interested in bombing Middelofnowheresburg, PA. I'm sure Boston is a great city, but stories like these make me never want to visit there, lest I worry if I forgot a half-finished Arduino blinky-light project in the back seat of my car. I don't view Boston as that important of a city for someone to want to bomb it.
- pmichaud 17y agoThis is an important case to watch, and I think the precedent set will have compounding effects in the future, either leading to a more or less transparent government, depending on which way it falls.
- nebula 17y agoI'm a little surprised at the tone of your observation. I thought U.S. citizens were the most empowered on the planet. More transparent government is clearly the desirable. If the outcome of this case can determine that, then the outcome should be in favor of transparent government. If the law of the land doesn't agree, then it's time it's changed; isn't it? Well that's what it looks like to me trapped under an oppressive government on the other side of the globe, idealizing the freedom of American citizens.
- sailormoon 17y agoAre you being sarcastic? I honestly can't tell. At any rate, in a Common Law system like the US's (and most other British Inheritors'), the outcome of a court case like this decides the law. The system relies on the judges to interpret the constitution's protections of rights. What they say goes. Of course, it can be appealed all the way up to the Supreme Court but then that's the final word and the lawmakers don't have much to do with it.
- jrockway 17y agolawmakers don't have much to do with it Traditionally they don't, but they could if they wanted to. If the Supreme Court rules that something is not legal, the legislature can make it legal. The Constitution can also be amended, making the issue of constitutionality null. Some of the most powerful Constitutional protection is in the form of amendments; the Bill of Rights. Technically, the freedom of speech is implicit in the text of the main body of the Constitution. (Any powers not specifically given to the Federal government falls to the States and People.) But the explicit text of the First Amendment has made it much easier for the People to retain their right to Free speech and press.
- swixmix 17y agoI agree with Mr. Nee that police officers "are entitled to the same rights as every citizen" because they, simply, are. I believe any individual should be allowed to record anything they please. But I also believe the distribution should be controlled by those who can be identified in the recording. The biggest deciding factor in this case should be if the recording was interfering with keeping the peace or not. If it's a personal issue, then the Officers were acting in a personal capacity and they were abusing their power. They should handle the situation the same way I would if someone were recording me. If I reported to the Police that someone was unlawfully recording me, what do you think they would do?
- georgecmu 17y agoYou don't have the right to control any video/photo recording of yourself that's done in a public place. All you can do is cover your face and walk away. EDIT: the person recording only needs your permission if the photo or video is going to be used to promote goods or services.
- ilamont 17y agoFor some perspective on this, check out how public photography is regarded in France: http://www.largeformatphotography.info/forum/showthread.php?t=35938 http://www.largeformatphotography.info/forum/showthread.php?... http://photo.net/street-documentary-photography-forum/009utT http://photo.net/street-documentary-photography-forum/009utT
- ShabbyDoo 17y ago"The lawsuit argues that public places are not covered by this law." What if they were? Could the local news do a live broadcast from the street without fear that someone would walk up behind them, shout something, and then claim that his rights had been violated?
- jrockway 17y agoI am pretty sure anyone can claim anything. I think you would have a pretty hard time going anywhere with a case against the news people, though.
- simon_ 17y agoIt seems clear to me that police actively carrying out their duty have (and should have) immensely more obligations and fewer rights than citizens generally. For example, while I certainly don't have the right to demand identification from a random person on the street, I better have the right to demand identification from a police officer giving me an order.
- nebula 17y agoTrue in most cases, but I think there might be exceptions like when dealing with an emergency like a hostage situation.
- trafficlight 17y agoThat's the kind of logic that got us into this mess. At no point, regardless of the situation, should a police officer be above the law.
- ismarc 17y agoAnd the reason why police officers have badges that uniquely identify themselves worn on their uniform.
- proee 17y agoSounds like a good idea for an iPhone app. You could look up a cop by ID and get any tips on dealing with him/her.
- Confusion 17y agoDon't be ridiculous: of course there are circumstances under which a police officer is above the law that dictates he should identify himself. If he's in a firefight and forcefully shoves you out of the way when you walk up asking for his identification, he has no obligation whatsoever to show you his ID. If he is in hot pursuit, you have no business stopping him to ask for his ID. If he has just broken his leg, you can't honestly expect him to identify himself. How many more examples do you want? I understand the parent is being irrelevantly pedantic, but your comment isn't making it any better.
- imgabe 17y agoSo if this case succeeds and the two party consent law isn't valid in public, does that mean that the police could follow a suspect around and record their conversations with a directional mic without a warrant? (as long as the conversations took place in public) This might end up being a case of "be careful what you wish for".
- sailormoon 17y agoInteresting point. Where does "obvious" recording stop and "covert" recording begin? Can you break the law by simply having a high-sensitivity microphone? And note the recent case of a man being charged with indecency for being nude in his own kitchen - but visible from a public place. So if anything conceivably visible/audible from a public place is now classed as "public", a laser mike on a window, or a zoom camera recording mouth movements (which can be reliably decoded into speech) might arguably be permissible.
- timwiseman 17y agoWith the obligatory "I Am Not a Lawyer" out of the way, I should point out that in many places (it varies state by state) two-party-consent is not required. Two party notification is required. There can be some significant differences in some cases. Again, far from an expert in law anywhere, but my understanding is that in most states you can go around in public openly recording conversations with no problems. The issue comes when you try to do it illicitly. A microphone that is obvious would cause no problems, but one that is concealed or otherwise nonobvious could be an issue. If anyone really knows what they are talking about, I would be most appreciative for confirmation or correction. As to how it should be, yes, I think that you should be able to record anything legally as long as the other party has no reasonable expectation of privacy (and yes, without their notification or consent as long as they do not then have a reasonable expectation of privacy). If you do something in a public place, you should assume it is being recorded. If you do something in the privacy of your own home or a bathroom stall, you should be able to do it with no fear of being recorded without your consent. I know this begs the question of where we draw the line between public and private, but I think there will be little disagreement on most cases. Those fringe cases where there is disagreement I would tend to lean towards allowing recordings. I think this should be true of all citizens, but I think it becomes especially important of public servants such as Police Officers whom the public has a right to demand accountability from. The Law Enforcement Agencies in America are fantastic, and I have the highest praise for them in terms of their performance and the effect they have on the streets of America. But they should never forget that they are public servants and (at least indirectly) accountable to the public in a Democracy.
- sailormoon 17y agoI thought police in LA were going to start wearing cameras on their heads to record everything! http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,580667,00.html http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,580667,00.html Isn't that fairly strong evidence that it's OK to record public interactions without consent?
- ggchappell 17y ago> Isn't that fairly strong evidence that it's OK to record public interactions without consent? Possibly, in California, but not in Massachusetts. Compare the 3rd paragraph of this page: http://www.rcfp.org/taping/states/california.html http://www.rcfp.org/taping/states/california.html with the first paragraph of this: http://www.rcfp.org/taping/states/massachusetts.html http://www.rcfp.org/taping/states/massachusetts.html
- Yaa101 17y agoIf the officers in question just do their work normal within the law they should not be afraid to be filmed, the behavior of these police officers is at least fishy in that perspective. Also it had to occur sooner or later that they arrested the wrong person, a criminal defense attorney no less.