7 ms·
An amusing example of this sort of problem shows up sometimes on airplanes with onboard WiFi. If the phone doesn't get a GPS lock right away (common when you're
by mikeash 11y ago
An amusing example of this sort of problem shows up sometimes on airplanes with onboard WiFi. If the phone doesn't get a GPS lock right away (common when you're in a metal tube) then it may show the position based on the mapped location for the hotspot MAC address, which is often at a completely different airport.
Obviously, Skyhook isn't driving around mapping airliners, but I think these days they have the mobile devices themselves do the mapping, by phoning home with the WiFi hotspots it sees while out and about.
- lucb1e 11y ago> I think these days they have the mobile devices themselves do the mapping, by phoning home with the WiFi hotspots it sees while out and about. That thought is correct. Google has been doing this for years, popping up an agree-to-continue like screen on Android phones on which everyone clicks "sure, I just want to use GPS now" and then uploads every place they ever go to Google. Mozilla is working on their own version of this to create a variant of a more open nature: https://location.services.mozilla.com https://location.services.mozilla.com
- kuschku 11y agoAnd it’s horrible when no one activates it, and you’re the first to do so – every minute your phone will activate WiFi, scan, activate GPS, get a lock, and upload the data. Battery is empty in a few hours. But, after doing so for a few days in a row, your battery consumption goes down again, probably because it has mapped enough for now.
- egypturnash 11y agoOr maybe because it's not seeing many new SSIDs because you mostly go to the same four or five places in the same routes.
- kuschku 11y agoThat’s what I meant - it has mapped enough around my home that it doesn’t see new SSIDs anymore. In the end, I turned off Google’s location service anyway.
- zimpenfish 11y agoUK trains with WIFI causes similar issues confusing e.g. London and Manchester stations.
- gnu8 11y agoMaybe the industry should assign a bit in the BSSID to indicate a mobile AP that shouldn't be used for mapping purposes.
- nitrogen 11y agoMaybe private data like BSSIDs shouldn't be used for mapping purposes in the first place.
- simoncion 11y ago> Maybe private data like BSSIDs... Is it private when you're screaming it on the street corner for everyone to hear? If we're talking about vocal utterances, the law says "no". It's... disappointing that the addition of a computer to a activity makes people lose sight of the similarities between that activity and very similar ones that have long-settled legal treatment. Edit: To drive the point home: There are many jurisdictions that require you to affix your street number to the exterior of the building in which you live using numerals that are sufficiently large to be read clearly from across the street. Noone would honestly make the claim that the data provided by those numerals is in any way private information, and that broadcasting your street number to everyone who was walking or driving by is in any way a breach of privacy. :)
- mindslight 11y agoIt's even more unfortunate that the committees designing these protocols don't think this way. People with an identifier number tattooed on their arm don't walk around continually reciting it. In fact, they generally wear long sleeves.
- mikeash 11y agoThat's the most unexpected and off-the-wall Godwin I've ever seen.
- mindslight 11y ago