11 ms·
Bill Gates Expected to Create Billion-Dollar Fund for Clean Energy (2015)
- elcapitan 11y agoA good time for shady energy companies to get some funding ;) Germany had cases like Prokon http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/cbd86008-8394-11e3-aa65-00144feab7de.html http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/cbd86008-8394-11e3-aa65-00144feab7... destroying quite some investor money.
- pacificmint 11y agoYou say that as if the consequence is that we should not invest into alternative energy production. Prokon used unregulated financial instruments to take investments, and they obscured their financial situation by spreading their balance sheet over dozens of companies. It took the bankruptcy administrators a year to even figure out what the financial situation really was. I think what we should take from that is that oversight over companies that take financial investments, especially from consumers, should be tighter. That really has nothing to do with alternative energy.
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoGates seems to have bought into the propaganda FUD that renewable energy isn't today cheaper than fossil fuels. But it is, so why not invest in it. Yes, some money should go on longshot and forward looking R&D, but there's absolutely no need for Bill Gates to be talking down the existing solutions that are clearly better than coal in order to promote his own speculative investments. Luckily, the free market, despite the excessive subsidies that are granted to coal and other fossil fuels, has caught on to the trend and more and more money is pouring in. 97% of economists that publish in this field agree that doing nothing will cost us more than action right now. But still the "common sense" hasn't caught up with reality and relentless propaganda has convinced large numbers of people that solar, wind, efficiency and demand manangement are the domain of idealistic tree huggers and/or parasitic boondoggles rather than a pragmatic and cost effective solution.
- amlgsmsn 11y ago>but there's absolutely no need for Bill Gates to be talking down the existing solutions that are clearly better than coal in order to promote his own speculative investments. I'm lost, where is he talking down existing solutions and what are his speculative investments you're talking about?
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoSome background reading: http://energytransition.de/2015/08/we-are-good-to-go/ http://energytransition.de/2015/08/we-are-good-to-go/
- dredmorbius 11y agoRaw renewables capacity (nameplate IIRC, possibly w/ capacity factor applied) is on the order of fossil costs (though those are grossly understated by the market), but storable and dispatchable renewables / sustainable solutions aren't. The cost of stored energy is far higher than of nondispatchable wind and solar. This matters not only for grid power but for off-grid energy needs, ranging from chainsaws to backup generators to marine and aviation fuel.
- 7952 11y ago> propaganda has convinced large numbers of people that solar, wind, efficiency and demand manangement are the domain of idealistic tree huggers and/or parasitic boondoggles rather than a pragmatic and cost effective solution. The problem is that renewable energy is very capital intensive. Without some kind of price fixing (thank you tree huggers) it is excessively risky. When you have price fixing it is very attractive to speculators who make unpopular profits from electricity bills. The best way to make money is to already own a big power station and not bother reinvesting or maintaining existing capacity (coal). You reach a situation where no one has any incentive to build anything unless they are heavily subsidised. The public are stuck renting ever more expensive energy whilst funding massive building projects that they will never own.
- ZeroGravitas 11y ago
- timsco 11y agoThis article is dated November 27, 2015. Shouldn't he have created it by now?
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoIf a "clean energy" philanthropist really wanted to steer the world away from fossil fuels, they would lobby for the replacement of coal and oil with nuclear. It is impossible to meet rising global energy needs without either a: nuclear energy as a wedge, b: divine advancements in renewable tech and cost, or c: burning a ton ton ton of fossil fuels. I dream of a post-energy-scarcity-star-trek future pretty often, but the fact is that barring some revolutionary technological advancement, nuclear is the only long term hope we have to wean ourselves away from fossil fuels and towards renewable energies. "Green" tech it ain't either: refining rare earths is environmentally disastrous and even recycling the waste can be quite hazardous, such as lead battery recycling plants in Africa resulting in lead poisoning in surrounding communities. If we want to be serious about renewable energy and the long road it will take to get there, we will have to get over our fears of Chernobyl and Homer Simpson running the power plant
- melling 11y agoSo they should create a billion dollar lobby? Don't we want cheap, clean, renewable energy? Then there would be no need to lobby for anything. The market will do the rest.
- dredmorbius 11y agoMarkets have proven exceptionally unreliable at fully pricing energy. Much our present problem results from under-pricing of fossil fuels due to: 1. Negative pollution externalities. 2. Far more significant: failing to account for replacement costs of consumed resources. Fossil fuels are accumulated biofuels. We're consuming them at about 5 million times the rate of their initial creation, and at rates exceeding substantively most or all present net primary production. Enjoy the windfall. It won't last.
- melling 11y ago1. Yes, I am fully aware that the complete cost of fossil fuels is not captured. 2. We have hundreds of years of coal, for example. Many people are willing to use it all then worry about it then. Surely we'll have developed better energy technology long before then. 200 years ago we society didn't even have electricity. Anyway, my point is to not fight the system but accelerate clean energy development so that it wins in the current market. Solar prices have plummeted in the past 5 years, for example. What will it take to decrease the price further so that more people want it on their roofs, for instance?
- saosebastiao 11y agoI'm pretty sure we don't need billions of dollars of investments in clean energy, we need billions of dollars of investments in energy storage across a variety of scales ranging from household/vehicle level all the way to geographic regions. There are plenty of existing clean technologies that are as low or lower than the existing cost/kWh of dirty energy technologies. They are just intermittent and unreliable for base power distribution. Unfortunately energy storage is not as glamorous as clean energy production and doesn't get anywhere near the investment levels that it deserves.
- Retric 11y agoGrid scale energy storage is a 'solved' problem. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_pumped-storage_hydroelectric_power_stations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_pumped-storage_hydroel... EX: A single location is storing 4,200 gigawatt-hours per year: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huizhou_Pumped_Storage_Power_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huizhou_Pumped_Storage_Power_S...
- saosebastiao 11y agoIt is only solved if you are lucky enough to have suitable geography and a stable and wealthy enough government to support it, and are willing to irrevocably damage large ecological areas to build it. That solution isn't good enough to convert the entire world.
- Retric 11y agoThis things can actually be fairly compact and self contained. Traditional hydro is designed to store ~1 year of energy generally from seasonal rain, and needs a deep lake to build a useful head of water, which takes a lot of space. Pumped hydro is designed to store ~12 hours of energy and recharged every day. So, you can just have a small lake on top of a hill and another at the base within ~1-2 miles. As to geography you can also move electricity ~1,000 miles with minimal losses, So there is some dependence on geography but outside of some islands you can use pumped storage just about anywhere in the world as all you really need is a large hill to start with.
- bunkydoo 11y agoI don't think Bill Gates has much of a clue about what the world needs, he's very hypocritical. He lives a very consumptive 1% lifestyle (nothing wrong with that in my eyes - he earned it) but yet he turns around and preaches that everyone needs to change. Start with the man in the mirror bub. Elon Musk is a bit better than him since he doesn't preach - but I would agree with Gates that he's a little gung ho on space travel. I honestly don't think it is humanity's place to leave earth, we are fish in water. Whatever comes after us (speaking in terms of evolution) will be the alpha in terms of space travel.
- Artistry121 11y agoHow do you mean whatever comes after us? We are the only form of life we know of that can get into space using ingenuity. The alpha could be our descendants or created by tying our ingenuity in with the genetic background of other creatures. We are the best chance known of getting life off of one small planet - I think it is our place to expand life through the universe.
- noir_lord 11y ago> I think it is our place to expand life through the universe. Not sure if it's our "place" but for damn sure it's a good goal, getting life off the Earth and becoming sustainable in space massively reduces the risk of humans going extinct. The solar system is rich in resources we are going to need at some point.
- dredmorbius 11y agoI'd give Gates a bit more credit (and that's from someone highly, highly critical of his business practices and even much of his erstwhile philanthropic activities). His public persona is relatively glib, but there are signs of deeper awareness generally expressed only privately. E.g., "Gates' billionaire "Good Club" sees population growth as leading global issue (London Times / 2009)" https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/237yxs/gates_billionaire_good_club_sees_population/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/237yxs/gates_b...
- mrfusion 11y agoI never understood why we don't do geothermal? I guess it's just more expensive to dig giant holes than do prettying energy sources?
- cossatot 11y agoWe do do geothermal, just not much of it. There are two main categories, power generation and heating/cooling using a heat pump. Power generation requires a power plant, while heat pumps can work extremely efficiently on a building-by-building basis. Heat pumps are great, but can't power a city. For that you need geothermal, which generally means 'hydrothermal' because they all use steam to turn turbines (or to heat other fluids that turn turbines). Basically, you're right about the limiting factor being that it's expensive to drill deep holes. The heat distribution in the earth's crust is highly variable, so geothermal is more favorable where the crust is hot, because you don't have to drill as deeply (and install and operate equipment at great pressures). In a favorable area, such as near active volcanoes or large hot springs, geothermal may be a viable choice if the area is available for drilling (i.e. not in a national park) and close to a metro area or other high-capacity electrical grid. When all of these factors work out, geothermal is great. The Geysers north of San Francisco has a capacity of about 725 MW[0], and basically powers SF. It loses ~1% production annually, though, because the hot water powering the plant becomes extracted, and cold water pumped in cools the rocks slightly. Note that the rocks will re-heat themselves, but it takes time. However, it doesn't always work out. Much of the hot crust in the US is in Nevada and Idaho, where there are very few people, and not a lot of groundwater. Colder crust has the hot water too, but it's at great depths (e.g. 3-4 km) which would cost maybe 50-100 million USD to drill to. (A recent temperature test well--not production--well near me cost $3MM to drill ~1000 feet, and it gets exponentially more expensive with depth. The well, located by a small hot spring not far from Seattle, had a temperature inversion and turned colder with depth, so the money went down the drain). I do some consulting work for a company[1] that is experimenting with a technique called 'Enhanced Geothermal' or EGS that tries to exploit hot, dry rock by pumping cold water in through an injection well and pumping now-hot water back out at a nearby production well. This opens up a lot more exploitable ground[2] but is still very expensive and not yet proven for production. A test is in progress at Newberry volcano in Oregon[3]. However, I have high hopes for geothermal longer-term. I think that the drilling costs may get a bit lower, especially as a lot of the technology is developed by oil and gas companies (and associated drilling companies that are now or soon to be out of work, with current low oil prices). Additionally, once EGS is more proven and therefore less risky, investors will be willing to put money in. I don't know if it will ever as profitable as fossil fuels, but once the geological and technological uncertainties are lowered, then it should start to become a great, fairly safe investment (i.e. the demand for electricity is unlikely to drop down much). [0]: http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2011/ph240/halasz1/ http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2011/ph240/halasz1/ [1]: http://altarockenergy.com http://altarockenergy.com [2]: http://www.nrel.gov/gis/images/geothermal_resource2009-final.jpg http://www.nrel.gov/gis/images/geothermal_resource2009-final... [3]: http://blog.newberrygeothermal.com/ http://blog.newberrygeothermal.com/
- hackuser 11y agoPeople will say: don't look a gift horse in the mouth. But that's exactly the trap we have fallen into: A very few obtain most of the wealth, many of them fund an anti-tax and anti-government agenda; as government shrinks, the power of these people relatively increases; and so the public has to depend on oligarchs rather than on a democratic government including for national issues like energy and climate change. Then the oligarchs say: Look how generous we are; how you depend on us; who dares complain? And governments and people have to focus their efforts on pleasing them on all matters so as not to lose precious funding they control (instead of the legislature). It's anti-democratic and, to use a provacative but applicable term, un-American. National issues should be decided democratically, not by a few oligarchs. We were founded on the rejection of an aristocracy. It may be unfair to Gates and to this fund but unfortunately, even with the best of intentions, he is part of the problem.
- eloff 11y agoYes, I think this is really unfair. In no way is Gates a part of the problem, the country would be in much better shape if there were more like him. He innovated, created tens (hundreds?) of thousands of jobs, and one of the biggest companies on the planet. To top it all off, he puts the majority of his personal wealth in a foundation that he and his wife run to the benefit of humanity in general. It has been my dream since I was a kid to do the same (on a much smaller scale, likely). I wish there were thousands more like Gates and Buffet.
- hackuser 11y ago> In no way is Gates a part of the problem ... But he is, by amassing and using power that should be democratic, whether or not that was his intent. Doing good things with that power only makes one an "enlightened oligarch". Though to be fair to him, I don't know what he should do - at least lobby for higher taxes for the super-wealthy, and economic policies that don't result in such conncentration of power - Bill Gates of all people can't claim to be a helpess, innocent bystander. I'll add that his power, even well-intentioned, can distort things for the worse. For example, there was (maybe is) a problem in some African nations where foreign AIDS (and/or malaria or TB) funding was so much greater than local health care funding that they hired away all the talent and net more people were dying from a lack of basic health services. In fairness, there is a middle ground. Realistically money always will provide some power, some people will have more than others they have a right to use their money as they choose, and it's great if they use it to help others. However, when that concentration of money becomes so great that it undermines democracy, then it's gone too far. > He innovated, created tens (hundreds?) of thousands of jobs, and one of the biggest companies on the planet. ... A side point but let's not whitewash Microsoft's history, which wasn't all bad, but wasn't unicorns and rainbows either.
- graycat 11y agoIf his concern is CO2, then he might want to watch a good movie, the BBC The Great Global Warming Swindle https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=52Mx0_8YEtg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=52Mx0_8YEtg
- littletimmy 11y agoWhy isn't the government doing this? Why do we have to depend on the benevolence of billionaires to do something so essential?
- rhino369 11y agoThere isn't a strong consensus among the worlds people that global warming is 1) real 2) bad, and 3) preventable. I myself doubt whether there will be strong action until major changes already start. And unless the whole world agrees to act in unison, it doesn't make sense for America to act unilaterally. China and India will just eat our lunches and do the polluting for us.
- cossatot 11y agoI agree about the former, but not with the last two sentences. China and to a lesser extent India have massive incentives to get clean energy ASAP. The pollution in China is out of control, and is a major toll on public health, tourism, and agriculture (especially fishing). In the US, with its low population density, we worry more about climate change, which is more abstract than the local environmental pollution that is so visible and problematic in Asia. While unilateral US action through regulation and taxation might not directly do anything to ameliorate the global problem, US investment in technology might. The US can absolutely sell technology to China and India, whether it's intellectual property sales/licensing, product sales/licensing, or simply by charging huge amounts of tuition for Asian engineering students to learn at US universities (this is currently a very large subsidy to US education).
- nikdaheratik 11y agoThe politics for this entire issue are very tricky. Putting your money where your mouth is and dropping hundreds of millions to fund clean energy is a good way to get the denialists to stop stonewalling. They can't claim that "it's all a conspiracy to grab some gov't money" if the person is actually putting even more of their own money towards this issue.
- graycat 11y agoDefinitely the diligent, paid, Greenie lobbyists are out in force today! They are determined, guys: They want your carbon taxes and subsidies! Vote'm down, guys. Vote'm down! The Greenies want a war -- vote'm down, guys!
- dang 11y agoPlease don't do this here.
- graycat 11y agoTell the people who down voted me about 15 points just in this thread. They look like attackers paid by the Greenies to down vote anyone who casts doubt on their quasi-religion and their carbon-taxes and big subsidies, e.g., about $100,000 of US Federal money for each Tesla car. I gave a reference to the excellent BBC video with details of the total solution to the whole climate change subject and got attacked for doing that. Attacked for giving a reference to the solution. Tell the attackers, or the Mods, or PG, or Sam. Let the Mods find the attackers and kick them off HN. These attacks are not the first: Once before I lost about 50 points from the Greenie attackers. There is no debate, no refutation, no dispute, no discussion, no references, no facts, and no thanks -- just attacks. The attackers are the ones who shouldn't do that here. I want to push this, see what HN is really about -- rational, scientific and technical communications or or paid off, propagandist, gangland, dirty politics. Come on, Sam, clean this up.
- dang 11y agoI'm a moderator. The problem is that by adding so much noise, like this, to your comments, you're lowering the signal/noise ratio of the site. Please don't do that. If you would condense your comments down to just their core information, they'd be good contributions.
- graycat 11y agoOne of my posts here was very short and got attacked. The length of my posts is not the reason I am being attacked: I've posted some very long posts at HN, right to the limit of 10,000 characters and sometimes longer broken into two posts without any attacks. No, I'm being attacked because I am giving a reference to a BBC video clip and explaining that clip that conflicts with the climate change paid propagandists. Surely you can see that. This is a war at HN about the climate change movement. I'm giving rational arguments against the movement and being attacked. PG, Sam, clean this up.
- graycat 11y agoLook, guys, some of you are all wound up, concerned, alarmed about the effect on the climate of CO2 from human activities and, thus, are eager to reduce burning of fossil fuels. Well, since you are concerned, I have some really good news for you. For your concerns, the news is much better than anything from research on solar cells, energy storage, wind farms, geothermal energy, nuke energy, carbon-taxes, etc. The news is really, really simple and says how to address your concerns in the best way, absolutely, positively the best way possible. In three posts in this thread, I've given a reference to a quite well done BBC video available at YouTube. The secret solution, best possible for your concerns? Sure: Do nothing. Absolutely nothing. Do zip, zilch, and zero. Totally f'get about it. Why? Because as in the video, CO2 has nothing at all to do with the climate -- in any meaningful sense at all. None. All details are in the video. It's like you had some doctors tell you you had a very sick child and then a week later told you that it was all a mistake, that some lab tests got mixed up, and, in fact, your child is fully healthy. And from CO2, the earth is fully healthy. Again, why? Because in fact, CO2 has no effect at all meaningful. It didn't in the past several hundred thousand years, isn't now, and won't for the foreseeable future. Best news you can get. Why? Because to save the planet from the dangers of CO2, you don't need to work on solar, wind, nukes, carbon-taxes, home insulation, subsidies, EPA shutdowns of coal plants, have cold houses in the winter and hot houses in the summer, etc. All those things you were doing to save the earth from CO2, you get to stop all of them. Now, is this a happy day for you? I'm not joking. Watch the movie. If you have any questions, then post them here and I will respond.