3 ms·
#4 was really "tax breaks for the rich". The check everyone else got was just an early chunk of their normal refund check. Surpluses are a big problem to the
by jandrese 11y ago
#4 was really "tax breaks for the rich". The check everyone else got was just an early chunk of their normal refund check.
Surpluses are a big problem to the "starve the beast" strategy though. The whole point is to run the government out of money so it is forced to reduce or shut down programs that are otherwise quite popular. That's why we implemented huge handouts to billionaires and not one but two unfunded wars.
- mschuster91 11y ago> and not one but two unfunded wars. Afghanistan was certainly a justified war, and Iraq was done under false pretenses and badly executed, but (if done right) it would have been worth the effort. Fighting oppressive regimes is always worth the price. The only thing that must not happen (yet again) is to fuck up the "what happens after neutralization of regime forces" part. Implementing a Marshall-like plan for Afghanistan and Iraq would certainly have led both countries to a richer life instead of the clusterfuck that both countries are now. Thousands of soldiers, millions of civilians unneccessary dead, all only because of political fuck ups.
- Analemma_ 11y ago> but (if done right) it would have been worth the effort. You could say that about literally any failed initiative in history.
- jandrese 11y agoOne can argue that even with a Marshall-like plan the region was doomed from the start. The country is not homogeneous like a European nation or especially Japan. It is made up of several ethnic groups who all want to dominate/eradicate the others. The British carefully drew the lines in the middle east to make sure the powers there would never be a threat to their empire and would instead be forever embroiled in petty tribal rivalries and incessant power grabs. It also insures that whomever is in power doesn't care about roughly half of the country and will almost certainly be corrupt as hell. The only power system that seems to work is the hideously authoritarian dictatorships, because they're the only ones who can make people believe that everybody is being oppressed equally and who have the agility to violently and ruthlessly quash uprisings while they are still small and peaceful. Of course even if the maps were redrawn to match the ethnic boundaries you would still have fairly regular border skirmishes. Due to the gender politics in the region there is always a need to get rid of the excess young males, and fighting otherwise pointless border wars is the time honored way to accomplish that.
- mschuster91 11y ago> The British carefully drew the lines in the middle east to make sure the powers there would never be a threat to their empire and would instead be forever embroiled in petty tribal rivalries and incessant power grabs. It also insures that whomever is in power doesn't care about roughly half of the country and will almost certainly be corrupt as hell. And it wasn't just the Middle East where this happened, it's happened all over Africa too, and the big colonial powers - again the Brits, the Portuguese, the Spanish, Dutch and the Germans - all did their part in creating the clusterfuck the entire region is suffering from to this day.
- aikah 11y ago> Fighting oppressive regimes is always worth the price Yes if there is a long term strategy in place. USA wasted billions on Iraq, it didn't make the middle more stable. > Implementing a Marshall-like plan for Afghanistan and Iraq would certainly have led both countries to a richer life instead of the clusterfuck that both countries are now. I don't believe that. The Marshall plan worked in Europe because despite all the nazi stuff, Europeans were somehow reasonable and could draw conclusions from their mistakes. Afghanistan, Iraq and co have a highly tribal culture, with a total different mindset than Europeans. The Talibans are still here, 14 years after and they still view the west as "the great Satan". Do you really think folks like these are reasonable? can they compromise ? I believe they cannot, that's their culture. No matter how much money one give these guys , unless there is a cultural shift, one is not going to achieve anything.
- shostack 11y agoCan you elaborate on what the "starve the beast" strategy is?
- jandrese 11y agoSpend recklessly until the government is out of money, then use the crisis as an excuse to cut back on popular services. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starve_the_beast https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starve_the_beast