8 ms·
Anywhere but Medium
- minimaxir 11y agoRelevant discussion: "Why have most tech and startup-related bloggers moved to Medium?" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10839118 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10839118
- davewiner 11y agoThanks for posting that link. It's important background info that apparently the other commenters weren't aware of. They basically have, due to their excellent product, deep pockets, and professional promotion, become the default place to post not just start-up posts, but political ones as well. All that background is assumed in my post because I've written about it many times before, in different contexts, and posted links to other commentary about Medium. As often is the case commenters on Hacker News don't always thoroughly research the background for THEIR opinions as they excoriate others for the same. ;-)
- jseliger 11y agoI don't see anything particularly wrong with Medium that might not be equally wrong of Wordpress or something similar. That being said, don't people who've generated an audience with a particular URL or platform want to keep that URL or platform? I write a Wordpress.com hosted blog at jakeseliger.com, for example, and lots of links point to jseliger.wordpress.com, and I wouldn't want to lose those readers by switching. At the same time, I contribute to a self-hosted WP blog at seliger.com/blog. From my perspective neither seems dramatically better or worse. But both have years of traction.
- minimaxir 11y agoMedium now allows custom URLs which alleviates that particular branding problem slightly. It does not fix the branding problems of every other looking the same and having to shove self-promotion at the end of every damn article.
- dexwiz 11y agoMedium is the next generation of magazine where the users are content creators instead of the publishers. You can post to medium and get the distribution benefits of a publisher that people know and look to for content. Not everyone wants or can spin up their own hosted blog and drive people to it at the same time. Many people want to focus on writing, not publishing, so they use something like medium or twitter. I agree there should be other publishers, but the doom and gloom over medium is a bit strong. Any publisher, social network, or central repo suffers from the same complaints.
- minimaxir 11y ago> You can post to medium and get the distribution benefits of a publisher that people know and look to for content. As noted in the article, that is exactly the problem as Medium is not an impartial judge.
- voyou 11y ago"Medium is the next generation of magazine" Magazines exercise editorial control, so they provide some some kind of signal of the kind and quality of writing you're going to get. Medium doesn't do that, so in an analogy to print publication, it would be more like... paper? a printing press? Actually, Medium is just like the internet, except there's only one Medium and there's lots of the rest of the internet. Medium is the next generation of AOL.
- danso 11y agoI don't disagree with the OP's overall sentiment, but it's worth noting why Medium has succeeded in attracting authors despite being yet another blogging platform. The implicit integration with Twitter probably helped adoption...but undoubtedly the "beauty" and simplicity of the authoring and reading interface had an effect...It's always been frustrating me to explain to people who want to get into blogging that _writing a blog post_ is separate from the work of making the blog itself look beautiful, and that should focus on the former and we can then work on the latter. Medium gives the latter without much work, and for aspiring writers, that's the incentive to finally try blogging out and feel like they've done something substantial. If it gets more people into the mindset of being creators instead of passive web consumers, I think Medium has been a good thing overall.
- notacoward 11y agoHe never seems to identify anything actually wrong with Medium except that it's popular already. People might be disinclined to write anything critical of Medium on Medium itself? Weak sauce. It comes across as a hipster-ish "I was blogging before it was cool" whine, or maybe somebody from Medium stole his girlfriend. What it's not is convincing. I'm actually more likely to use Medium now than I was before.
- mrkipling 11y agoI was actually going to say much the same, even > I'm actually more likely to use Medium now than I was before.
- Analemma_ 11y agoAnd another thing: is Medium really that popular? I mean, inside the tech bubble I know it is, but I feel like this might be another case of us having a warped view of the world (like how, outside "tech people" I still have yet to encounter somebody who has heard of Slack). To the general public Medium is just another thing alongside Tumblr and WordPress and Squarespace; I really don't think it's in imminent danger of taking over the web as a monoculture.
- siquick 11y agoI don't know anyone apart from myself who has ever heard of it. They may have visited it but its pretty common these days to visit sites from following a Facebook posted link and never take notice of the actual site name.
- derefr 11y agoI would hazard that that's half the point. Medium, to the writer, is a centralized blogging platform, like WordPress or Tumblr—but it's an extremely white-labelled one, where there's not much to indicate to the casual reader that an article is "on Medium" rather than just existing out on a "real" blog somewhere. I think people prefer Medium mostly for that reader experience. With that in mind, there's a much more Hacker-ly way to get the same reader experience—namely, using one of the many services that provide a "blog-post format gateway" for Github Gists: • http://www.roughdraft.io/ http://www.roughdraft.io/ • http://gist.io/3135754 http://gist.io/3135754 • http://bl.ocks.org/ http://bl.ocks.org/ Etc.
- ak217 11y agoWTF did I just read? The guy relates so many ways in which he thinks we shouldn't use Medium, but never presents an argument on why.
- eva1984 11y agoYeah..weird. I think somehow he is going to rant about how medium is a close platform, bad for the web...But in the end, it seems like all leads to Medium is a start-up and will eventually die???? What the heck...
- pc86 11y ago> So I suggested he post the comment to a blog so I could give it greater circulation by pushing it through my network. > In the back of my mind I thought that he'll probably put it on Medium. ... > Well, he did put it on Medium and sent me a link, and I sent back a comment saying that I was worried he'd do that, and unfortunately while I love his post I am reluctant to point to it on Medium. What an ass. If you feel that strongly about it, say something up front. But don't wait for someone to do the obvious (for better or worse, if you don't have a blog and want to get out two thousand words, Medium is the obvious place to do it) just so that you can lord your self-decreed moral superiority over them.
- notwhereyouare 11y agonot only that, he wanted to push it through his platform, not another one
- lucb1e 11y ago> don't wait for someone to do the obvious For what it's worth, I would not for a moment consider that someone might use Medium when publishing something in a blog post. I'd expect some Wordpress install, or perhaps Blogspot or wordpress.com if they're lazy. In fact if I'd have to rank methods of publishing by likelihood among my friends, a text file might be higher up than Medium. Perhaps in Silicon Valley it's very popular and perhaps this 'friend' (that posted it, to his dismay, on Medium) is indeed from there, but it's not as if it's that obvious that everyone would post to Medium. But yeah I do agree, if you think of something like that, you might as well say it instead of waiting.
- hbosch 11y agoThe great irony here is that the author tweets out to not post content on Medium.
- krallja 11y agoMedium broke the "Signal v. Noise" RSS feed by truncating articles. I complained to Basecamp; they blamed Medium. I complained to Medium; they said they might consider fixing it. Run your own blog on your own website. Then you don't have to depend on someone else to fix your bugs.
- chasing 11y agoFor someone with any amount of tech savvy, I just don't think there's any excuse for not posting writing on your own, self-hosted system. HTML in its most basic form is literally designed for this use case. Medium's cool now, but it won't necessarily be in a few years. And it's completely within the realm of possibility that they will disappear entirely at some point. It happens all the time. Big sites that people have contributed mass amounts of content to blink out of existence on a very regular basis. Sometimes without warning or the ability to back-up data. But the best case, like Winer points out, is that any links in become broken, comments get lost, etc. Your writing is yours. Own it.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoThis is what I did. Everything was too heavyweight or ugly for me, so I hacked together a PHP script: https://github.com/TazeTSchnitzel/blog https://github.com/TazeTSchnitzel/blog Doing it yourself means it's as simple or complicated as you like it, and you can add whatever feature you want. For instance, my blog displays a seasonal emoji next to the year: https://raw.githubusercontent.com/TazeTSchnitzel/blog/75d789bc4678f7919c72baafa3fb566bdeb9c513/src/index.php https://raw.githubusercontent.com/TazeTSchnitzel/blog/75d789...
- jensvdh 11y agoSome of your emoji are not rendering properly in Chrome. Specifically Key 1 and 2.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoHuh, indeed it is. Those should be snowflakes for Winter. Why does it break in Chrome on OS X, yet work in everything else?!
- noir_lord 11y agoI did the same http://benlowery.co.uk http://benlowery.co.uk it took like 100 lines of Python to take take a bunch of markdown files and render a blog. It was almost embarrassingly easy (code is on there). Really should write more content for it though.
- funkysquid 11y agoThis is more fun to read as the cross-post on Medium (https://medium.com/@davewiner/anywhere-but-medium-5450cb19f2c1#.6dawtzuj4 https://medium.com/@davewiner/anywhere-but-medium-5450cb19f2...), especially the parts about how people can't criticize Medium on Medium.
- ph0rque 11y agoNo mention of svbtle? Edit: I just visited the site for the first time in ages, and noticed it's no longer free to sign up. I take back any implied endorsement thereof.
- seiji 11y agoWhat is it and why would people use it? Mentioning something nobody uses and nobody has heard of doesn't seem like much of a a priority when critiquing a popular service.
- ph0rque 11y ago(Assuming you're not being sarcastic) https://svbtle.com/ https://svbtle.com/ is similar to Medium. Mentioning something ~nobody has heard of makes a lot of sense as an alternative to something that is too popular.
- cballard 11y agoIt's an invite-only blog network, for people that are sufficiently intelligent and witty. If you don't know about it or don't have an account, it's probably because you're unintelligent and not funny. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3742314 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3742314
- seiji 11y agoOh, interesting. That's certainly what the SV elite need, isn't it? Yet another closed social network for them to preach their wise and monied thought leadership down upon us lowly commoners. cloudbro social all the way.
- DrScump 11y ago<If you don't know about it or don't have an account, it's probably because you're unintelligent and not funny.> What if I'm unintelligent, but funny? Can I get a part-time account?
- 6stringmerc 11y ago>Since you're counting on them not just to store your writing, but also build flow for it, the inclination is to praise them, to withhold criticism. BZZZT! Wrong! Maybe for you, but not for me! I have no ingrained suppositions that the platform, free of charge, which hosts cheap-ass text in a usable format, and seems to be stable, would actually be bothered or compelled to promote my material. Not one bit of assumption on my part. I use it as a writing platform simply because it fits a need, and I didn't have to fork over for a domain and the maintenance that goes along with a self-implemented system. Or, if flow simply refers to it working, yeah, I guess I'm assuming that, but that's like a core competency. It almost reminds me of the Mitch Hedberg joke, the one where a chef becomes a master chef, and then a person asks, "Well, can you farm?" as though they should be a master of every aspect. I write. Medium hosts my writing, and I like the way the software works. Good deal for now, if it changes, I'll tear down and move on (like I did with Blend.io when they pivoted in a way I did not want to follow). If we're talking ownership, well, that's a "backup" issue for each writer. For serious, lengthy pieces, I'm working in a software like Word before I'm posting online. It's just habit, and I can save locally/backup and Medium is the finished, public product. Simple. In my experience - coming from music - the distributor is distinct and separate from the promotions arm. Though they may collaborate (PR working in conjuntion with Distributor to announce big release, etc), they are separate avenues in my opinion. In this piece the author really undercuts their own point by referencing Facebook...mostly because if I had to write a correlative article about the one website where NOT to host music or artistic endeavors because of the single-platform lock-in risks mentioned...it would be Facebook. Anywhere but Facebook. Distribution and Publicity are moving targets, faster now than ever. ReverbNation. That's a site that does distribution and promotion, and I don't think it's very good. BandCamp is more about distribution than promotion, and I see a lot of pretty happy customers over that route. Facebook is, for lack of a better concept, a necessary evil but simply one aspect in a fully functional, diversified approach to coming to market. Which also includes YouTube, the radio of the internet generation.
- needz 11y agoWell, at least medium.com loads. (site is down this moment)
- redwards510 11y agoInteresting. I have my own reasons why you shouldn't post to Medium. It makes you look like an elitist blowhard. The majority of Medium blog posts that I have read are: * 25 year old founder wants to explain how the reason his startup failed wasn't his fault. * 25 year old founder has a list of "10 ways to live a meaningful life" * 23 year old Javascript programmer proclaims "Node.js is dead, long live Node.js" (3 paragraphs) * 20something Bay Area resident thinks he's solved the housing crisis in 4 paragraphs. 95% Egotistic tripe. I can't think of any Medium posts I ever shared with someone else.
- askafriend 11y agoRelevant parody Twitter account: https://twitter.com/FalseMedium https://twitter.com/FalseMedium
- strictnein 11y agoMan, some of those are great. > "Some Precious Thing a Design Student Came Up With That Wouldn't Work in Real Life"
- redwards510 11y agoWow, that is absolutely perfect. Exactly what I was talking about. ex: "A Common Problem That I Didn't Give a Shit About Until It Happened To Me"
- LukeB_UK 11y agoI think that says more about you and the content you choose to read than it does about the content on Medium. I've read some great posts there with no egotism involved.
- hockeybias 11y agoDitto.
- xlm1717 11y agoI tend to notice the same thing. What I choose to read on Medium is from the posts that it decides to bring to my attention, either on the front page or through the email newsletter. I would bet posts with a lot of egotism tend to get more eyeballs and thus more suggestions.
- ThomPete 11y agoAs with the Mac App Store I think the danger is to think about your content as something that only should live one place. I decided to treat my content as I do my apps. As individual assets which are just looking for distribution. That's why I have my personal blog and then use medium as just another distribution channel for the content I write there. I also post it on linkedin and a couple of other places. If something else comes up I will also put it there if it makes sense. I normally get a healthy number of visits on my blog and while I wont get the traffic to my personal post I still get my thoughts out there when i use Medium (and some of the readers do cross from one destination to another) Just my 5 cents.
- kzahel 11y agoThe text is too large on this blog post on a mobile device. If it were written on medium, at least it would be more legible.
- valar_m 11y agoIn case you want to read it on Medium: https://medium.com/@davewiner/anywhere-but-medium-5450cb19f2c1#.1y9dqf7v7 https://medium.com/@davewiner/anywhere-but-medium-5450cb19f2...
- redthrowaway 11y agoSo, Medium is big. That's pretty much all I took from that. He lists no problems with it, except maybe they might one day be the sort of company to do something you don't like. This isn't a criticism. It isn't even a rant. It's not focussed enough to be either. It's somebody worrying about writing on the Internet being largely controlled by a single company. Which, of course, it isn't. Never was and never will be.
- swagv 11y agoMedium is just the latest fad until we abandon it too in a couple of years.
- FussyZeus 11y agoI don't use anything I don't own. I spend maybe a hundred bucks a year on a good virtual host and operate four websites off of it, along with a CloudFlare subscription for speed. I run an ownCloud server at home, everything is backed up locally and then offsite to one company I trust. If any of these entities went under I'd be out a small amount of money and some time getting setup somewhere else, but I'd be dinged, not dead. I get extremely uncomfortable with "platforms" of all types. I've been burned so many times when the shiny new website everyone used isn't shiny and new anymore and suddenly is gone, and bang, there goes everything you made right with it. And yeah, never used Medium. My websites don't get a ton of traffic but I don't need to be famous so, I really don't feel the need to produce content for a faceless Silicon Valley attention company.
- blt 11y ago> Medium is on its way to becoming the consensus platform for writing on the web Jesus, I hope not. I have better ways to burn my phone battery. The Medium version of this post contains 388kb of javascript and 312kb of CSS. Medium's engineering is terrible.
- Ecco 11y agoThe very same reasoning could be applied to any market leader. So then why is this guy hosting his repos on GitHub? Hell he should host his own GitLab instance, or even go all-in and ditch git altogether...
- lucb1e 11y agoTL;DR: Medium is a single platform with many blogs, instead of having each blogger have his own server to host on. Posting on Medium centralizes (as in, the opposite of decentralization). And Medium does not publish a 'statement of principles' to declare that they won't not put things on the front page just because they're critical of Medium itself. And the Medium page is larger than the plain text version, how terrible. We should not let Medium 'own' the media type called 'blog posts' (like Youtube 'owns' videos). My thoughts: he's saying Medium is evil because it's like every online platform ever. Now I'm a sucker for principles and host my own email, vpn, ftp, btsync and web server, and I indeed don't use Medium because I want to own and have control over what I publish, but saying Medium is evil because of these properties... maybe if it had been a post about online platforms in general, it might have had a point.
- strictnein 11y agoWe need to all go back to GeoCities.
- microcolonel 11y agoCan't read this page without Javascript. Anything but scripting.com.
- kmfrk 11y agoI think everyone using Medium at least owe it to themselves to try out the export feature and migrate one blog post. I did that with a few for archival purposes and such, and the export feature is basically an HTML file with all kinds of stuff going on in it. The idea of Medium is awesome, but the combination of their weird CMS and the way in which they store blog posts is annoying. Pros and cons and all that. That said, it's not like other blogging platforms are saints. I'm sure it'd be a mess to export my Tumblr posts too.
- Futurebot 11y agoFor anyone confused about Medium's export feature, it's available under Settings->Export Content from the user menu. Worries about platforms not providing this are warranted, but I think Medium already has this covered, even if some of the export HTML is messier than some would like. Until Medium, I hosted my own blogs on my own web servers (for ~17 years). I eventually got tired of dealing with updates, comment spam management (even with Akismet and friends), breakin attempts, and all the rest, so I moved there. I'd still like to see friendly URL and custom domain support, as well as some fixes to the editor (bulleted lists + blockquote indentation bugs are very frustrating), but overall, I've been fairly satisfied with it. His concerns might be a tad overblown in this instance, even if I agree with many of his concerns about the open web (and I personally still think RSS should be everywhere by default. It's still incredibly useful, even if only used for API consumption.)
- bootload 11y ago"When you give in to the default, and just go ahead and post to Medium, you're stifling the open web. Not giving it a chance to work its magic, which depends on diversity, not monoculture." If you have read enough of Daves posts you'll realise this is the Internet version of what happened with Microsoft and Apple. Something about absolute power and corruption. Dave has been remarkably consistent in this observation over the years. "Well, he did put it on Medium and sent me a link, and I sent back a comment saying that I was worried he'd do that, and unfortunately while I love his post I am reluctant to point to it on Medium. I asked if he'd consider putting it somewhere else. He asked where else. Hence the tweet." One reason not to put things on medium is the poor url design. Try remembering then typing this url into your browser ~ https://medium.com/@davewiner/anywhere-but-medium-5450cb19f2c1#.2gv2klp7h https://medium.com/@davewiner/anywhere-but-medium-5450cb19f2... The design is ok. We can understand up to the end of the title, 'anywhere-but-medium' then we get robot vomit '5450cb19f2c1#.2gv2klp7h', junk parts of the url no use to anyone except machines.
- ageitgey 11y agoDave Winer makes a point about how he posts to his own blog and only syndicates his content to medium.com via rss because he wants his content to live on for years. Ironically when you visit the medium.com version of his post[1], all the links in it were hijacked by ifttt.com and turned into ift.tt shortlinks. So his effort to escape the medium.com content jail landed him right inside the ifttt.com content jail as well. Double jail. Will those ift.tt shortlinks still load in 5 years? Who knows. [1] https://medium.com/@davewiner/anywhere-but-medium-5450cb19f2c1#.53guhnze5 https://medium.com/@davewiner/anywhere-but-medium-5450cb19f2...
- zachgersh 11y agoIf you wanted both a platform and an OSS approach why not just deploy something like ghost: https://ghost.org https://ghost.org I like supporting OSS business models that allow me to host my own platform or just post my content to their hosted version of said platform.