5 ms·
I'm surprised nobody has mentioned the geopolitical advantages of hoarding cash. A big pile of untaxed, uninvested cash represents a significant political barga
by chatmasta 11y ago
I'm surprised nobody has mentioned the geopolitical advantages of hoarding cash. A big pile of untaxed, uninvested cash represents a significant political bargaining chip for the corporation in control of it.
Apple can extract more from negotiations with the US government, for example, when it's holding $100b USD offshore. Quite simply, that money is leverage.
Over the next several decades we will see the decline of the nation state as the primary geopolitical powerbroker. Corporations already exert significant control over politics, and this trend will only continue.
Perhaps what the executives see that us plebes do not, is that this geopolitical shift has already begun, and is much further along than anyone realizes.
- jandrese 11y agoSigh, I was really hoping Cyberpunk stories from the 80s wouldn't turn out to be prophetic.
- chatmasta 11y agoUnfortunately more of them come true every month... On the bright side, at least cryptographers excel at predicting threat models.
- snowwrestler 11y agoIn reality they have turned out to be the opposite of prophetic. National governments are more powerful today, relative to corporations, than they were in 1992, when Snow Crash was published. In the 90s, a lot of people thought that businesses would leverage networked computer technologies to disrupt governments. People thought the Internet would be a new medium of exchanging information and wealth, impossible for governments to monitor and regulate. Does anyone think that anymore? What we see today--thanks to Edward Snowden and others--is that the Internet is thoroughly dominated by national governments. They have the best hackers and invest in the strongest technologies. For example it's hard to think of a smarter tech company than Google, and the GCHQ picked their pocket easily with MUSCULAR. Rather that disrupting the government, core technology companies like AT&T enthusiastically work with the government.
- sgt101 11y agoI think it's a liability. The US government can at any time tax that cash, and if Apples execs refuse to pony up then they can have fun in jail. If the US government decide to do that....
- jqm 11y agoThe government is slow and clumsy but Apple hires fast lawyers and lobbyists. So I wouldn't count on that.
- ojbyrne 11y agoTax changes that are retroactive are extremely rare, mostly because they are seen as unfair - changing the rules after the game. And if you tax the offshore cash generated starting now, then corps will change their behavior to minimize tax paid.
- rchaud 11y ago>If the US government decide to do that.... And therein lies the rub. Apple can mount a better defense than the US prosecution can, by dint of their bottomless legal fund. Apple can also put forward a united front, whereas you would need to summon an unprecedented level of political will and bridge-building to simply prevent Congress from derailing the DOJ prosecution through infighting.
- throwaway101321 11y agoHow many divisions does Apple have?
- n0us 11y agoAlso leverage against other companies who might challenge their position. No one is going to take on Walmart knowing that Walmart has the cash to undercut them while operating at a loss indefinitely while they drive the upstart out of the market.
- ryanlol 11y agoThere's legislation to prevent that.
- snowwrestler 11y agoNo one has mentioned it because, for the U.S. at least, it's not an actual advantage. U.S. treasuries transact at a global volume of about $1 trillion per day. $100 billion is a lot of money, but not enough to create any significant leverage in negotiations with the U.S. federal government. U.S. jobs and U.S. customers are far better leverage, because they vote. Cash doesn't vote, and the Federal Reserve can create as much of it as the U.S. needs at any time.