4 ms·
Docker has some really smart people leading it to success. But make no mistake, the economic thesis of Docker depends on a massive landgrab of vendor lock-in. T
by chatmasta 11y ago
Docker has some really smart people leading it to success. But make no mistake, the economic thesis of Docker depends on a massive landgrab of vendor lock-in. This acquisition is a hedge against any Unikernel company looking to make the same landgrab.
There's a reason Docker is so heavily funded by the biggest cloud companies. They're the ones who stand to benefit from specialized Docker container optimized for their own platform. It's a great way to package open source services and leverage the effort of the developer community into centralized profit.
It seems blatantly obvious that Docker is looking to build the app store of devops. I wish them the best of luck, but they are going to face some heavy resistance from open source initiatives. There is nothing about Docker that makes it fundamentally superior to the systems it's based on, specifically the LXC project. When developers finally wake up to the fact that they are sleep walking into a massive walled garden, Docker will lose some of its clout.
- bjt 11y agoWith the recent defection by Kubernetes against the Docker networking model, and earlier friction with CoreOS and the app container spec, this is already happening. Unfortunately, I think the voices of reason are still getting drowned out in the Docker hype.
- mwcampbell 11y ago> Unfortunately, I think the voices of reason are still getting drowned out in the Docker hype. I don't know about that. There has been considerable Docker backlash. One example from just a few days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10920370 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10920370 And this comment in particular: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10921076 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10921076
- cyphar 11y agoDocker doesn't build on LXC, they have their own implementation of a container runtime known as libcontainer, which has been used for over 2 years. I also want it noted that the OCI and runC mean that vendor lock-in is very hard. There is a tonne of work going into making Docker a wrapper for runC so you can replace Docker usage with runC and containerd without having to rewrite your configuration. I've been involved in the Docker community as a free software developer for a long time. I may have squabbles with some of the people who work at Docker Inc. but many of them are very passionate about software freedom, so I don't think it's fair to say the project is bad because the CTO (who hasn't committed code for almost a year) has views that are unfriendly to free software.
- shykes 11y agoI have to say, after having contributed thousands of commits to free software, recruited hundreds of people to do the same, and directed tens of millions of dollars to open-source contributions... this stings a little. For the record I don't have views unfriendly to free software. But I have upset many people by disagreeing with their design opinions, and as a result not merging their pull requests. Sometimes those people imagine a conspiracy of evil VCs smoking cigars, instructing me to reject their patch for an obscure capitalistic motive that they can't quite express. When in reality the explanation is simpler: I disagree on their opinion, and I have commit rights. If you point out an example of my supposed hostility to free software, I will be happy to refute it with objective facts. But then everyone is free to believe what they want to believe.