3 ms·
Go to Google right now and search for "passport renew" I see twelve sites which offer the service with no affiliation. All they do is ask for sensitive personal
by Someone1234 11y ago
Go to Google right now and search for "passport renew" I see twelve sites which offer the service with no affiliation. All they do is ask for sensitive personal information, charge you an additional fee (on top of the passport fee) and file on your behalf.
Unfortunately I've had friends & family fall for this and similar scams (see also "birth certificate copy" "criminal record" "arrest record" "US travel authorisation" "US visa" et al), and sometimes they don't even file on your behalf (just take your money and run).
These things have been going on YEARS, and I can find numerous examples in seconds with no research. When is Google going to put a stop to this?
PS - It is disturbing how many less computer literate people have no concept of what is an advert and what is a result in a search engine. They'll just click the top thing, which is scary for the above examples.
PPS - Bing is much MUCH worse. More scams, and ads are harder to spot (by design?).
- gbasic 11y agoWhat do you think are additional things that Google could do? I can imagine how hard this is to police. For example: - Let people mark different links as spam - Hire a larger team to police this
- Someone1234 11y ago> What do you think are additional things that Google could do? Certain searches should NOT be monetised at all. When people are looking at entering sensitive personal information (e.g. passport, visa, birth certificate, arrest record, tax filing) it is too dangerous to allow adverts which may contain phishing scams into the mix. Too many people click ads thinking they're search results.
- gbasic 11y agoDo you remember when ads were called out in gray? Now most non-techy people I know seem to click on the first entry (the ad), converting good SEO into a payment to Google.
- AJ007 11y agoFrom a different standpoint: - How much money does Google make from 'bad' ads? (Or how much does Alibaba make from 'counterfeit' product ads? Or Amazon, etc.) - How many false positives will 'good' actors tolerate before they substantially reduce their spending on your platform? - How many resources do you put on the problem while making sure you continue to earn a large % of revenue from the 'bad' actors while minimizing negative consequences from your users or regulators?
- gbasic 11y agoOne point I make is that even if Google makes significant money from bad ads, they still may be incentivized to ensure the experience is not substantially diminished (i.e., there's value to their reputation)
- AJ007 11y agoThat would fall under the third point. However, they have some big advantages that other companies do not get. For example, if you buy a bad iPhone once, that is really bad for Apple. Google as a search engine falls under a strange category. On one hand, users put more trust in what they see on Google, making the ad inventory more valuable. On the other hand, if something bad happens they understand it isn't from Google -- something which may not be as clear cut as say, purchasing a defective product off Amazon from a third party seller. (Then there is the revenue that comes for display ads, syndicated search feeds, things that 99% of users had no idea it was Google gaining much of the monetary benefit in the first place.) On top of all of this a large portion of users who do click on ads on Google have no idea they even clicked an ad in the first place.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kolbe 11y agoOne thing that I can't prove, but is likely true, is that .gov links are highly undervalued by google rankings. There are many many cases where a government web site provides the most obvious best result, but the fact that they don't do SEO or pay google forces the result too far down the page.
- chipperyman573 11y agoTheir websites are also pretty... awful. I usually find much more valuable information on non .gov sites just because it's not hidden fifty links deep. The only valid reason (imo) to go to a .gov site is to e-file (or whatever they're calling it) something.
- kolbe 11y agoI completely disagree. The site design is usually web 1.0 cringeworthy, but the content is trustworthy, accurate and truly free.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- gruez 11y ago>Go to Google right now and search for "passport renew" I see twelve sites which offer the service with no affiliation. https://i.imgur.com/iimLjyW.png https://i.imgur.com/iimLjyW.png Can't reproduce
- Someone1234 11y agoYou appear to be seeing no ads at all. Do you happen to have adblock installed? I can reproduce 100% of the time: http://i.imgur.com/9KJ4LSm.png http://i.imgur.com/9KJ4LSm.png
- sp332 11y agoDo you have malware injecting malicious ads?
- wmeredith 11y agoIf he does, we have the same malware. I am running Chrome 47 with Adblock on Mac OSX and I can reproduce 100% of the time. I can even reproduce it in an incognito window.
- tomtang0514 11y agoThen you guy are probably targeted by geo location
- Someone1234 11y agoNope. I tried it from a different geographical location (west coast of the US) and got exactly the same thing.
- Someone1234 11y agoNo. I receive identical ads on my Android smartphone connected to a completely different network (4G T-Mobile). So then I RDC-ed into an Azure instance (2012 R2) I have running in the "West US" zone, identical results. So if I have a malware infection then it has also infected my phone and a virtual machine running half way across the country. Three networks, three operating systems, same results.
- endemic 11y agoThat is pretty terrible. When I tried (http://imgur.com/KCpdOFg http://imgur.com/KCpdOFg), there was a legit content snippet from USPS (with graphic) right before the fold, but the rest of the page was ads. The ads should at least be differentiated more from actual search results; the small "Ad" badge is low contrast and easy to overlook.
- angry-hacker 11y agoCan reproduce the results for "passport renew" on Google. And yes, bing is much worse, look at those ads (or are they search results? hard to make difference): http://imgur.com/a/l7mMv http://imgur.com/a/l7mMv