4 ms·
The problem I see with shared cars is that people like to forget stuff in their cars. Cellphones, ID bages, food, wallets, bags... When I park my car at my wor
by mschuster91 11y ago
The problem I see with shared cars is that people like to forget stuff in their cars. Cellphones, ID bages, food, wallets, bags...
When I park my car at my workplace and I notice my badge fell out of my pants (or I forgot it), no problem, I can head back to the car and get my badge. If I take a cab I can always phone the cab central and have them ask the driver to look for the item (of course, this requires honest cab drivers and it will cost me a huge amount of money if the cab driver is already on the other end of the city by the time I notice). No way at all to do so with an autonomous car.
Also, a shift to autonomous cars would prevent another very common use case: after work I might want to do something else before driving home, like going to sports training. So now I'd have to carry my gun and ammo (or my sport gear, or ...) all the time around with me instead of leaving the stuff in my car.
Also, my own car still is freedom: public transport, even in Germany, shuts down after 2200 and restarts only at 0500, and if you're outside the city you rarely have time intervals for buses and trains lower than 20min - often it's more like 40min, 60min or even 120min. With a shared car system, I'd have to wait totally unpredictable amounts of time until a shared car is free, and there's nothing I hate more than waiting.
Getting people off individual cars would require absolutely massive investment in public transport. Might work out in cities, but in rural areas there's no way you can get people to abandon their cars.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoIndeed. I definitely use my car to carry a variety of tools and equipment with me all of the time, including emergency supplies. I'd have to start wearing like... a purse or something to keep even a fraction of that with me. Regarding hours... realizing the bus to your hotel in Iceland is no longer in service at 2 AM in a snowstorm in March is super excitng.
- reustle 11y ago> No way at all to do so with an autonomous car. How can you say that when they aren't even a thing yet? They could easily have a hotline to call in case of a situation like this, where they can manually pull it out of the queue and send it back to your location. It wouldn't be complicated or costly.
- mschuster91 11y agoWhat if another passenger has already taken the vehicle? Then you'd totally depend on the honesty of a stranger. Thanks but no thanks.
- nitrogen 11y agoMeta: What's with the bizarre downvoting of non-anti-car comments in this thread? It's like anything that isn't 100% in favor of a shared-everything-screw-the-rurals-and-introverts economy is anathema or something. Maybe instead of downvoting, why don't you (whoever "you" may be) try to figure out why people have a different opinion than you? Maybe you'll find that the world is a heck of a lot bigger than you imagined and people exist who really do have different experiences and needs.
- mschuster91 11y agoBecause HN is full of urban hipsters whose viewport is limited to their city.
- csydas 11y agoI cannot speak for the people down voting, but I can understand frustration with raising objections based on wants and desires which are not incompatible with cities focusing more on mass transit and self-driving fleets. Folk who do live in rural areas won't be impacted much by cities transitioning to fewer cars. If their work requires commute into the city, I'm not sure why or how the commute would be any worse once self-driving cars are introduced. The idea is to reduce car dependence and the control cars have within cities. Assume for a moment that self-driving cars can participate nigh-perfectly in traffic with human drivers, and that they become the majority within cities. Would this not mean that as car ownership in cities goes down, available parking may decrease, but the demand for parking will also decrease? As an introvert myself, I don't really have an issue with mass transit, since most everyone just wants to mind their own business. Once there are self-driving cars or once city culture shifts from car ownership to fleets of available cars, nothing is stopping you from having complete privacy as you travel if you desire it. What I'm saying is that these concerns aren't incompatible with the share ideas. Your normal routine might be slightly different, but your wants and needs are not incompatible with the ideas at all. I dislike downvote/upvote systems for discussion for the very reason you're expressing; it creates echo chambers, but it also expresses their position. I disagree with you, but I will tell you that it's because I think your wants and needs can be met perfectly if cities shift to less cars. Others apparently would rather just down vote to express their disagreement.
- shawn-furyan 11y ago> So now I'd have to carry my gun and ammo (or my sport gear, or ...) Of course there are all kinds of little assumptions in our daily lives that would suddenly change and have to be addressed. In this case though, do you really need 170 sq. feet to store whatever you are carrying with you? Opening parking lots to development will generate enough value to provide a couple 12x18x72 inch lockers for each space removed. That still clears up over 98% of the square footage currently being taken up by parking spaces, and it would obviate the need to use cars for personal storage. It might even lower theft since a big component of theft from automobiles is that a thief can look into a bunch of cars and only break in when something valuable enough is identified. And since lockers could be located inside where the people are, it would probably opportunities for would be thieves to have alone time with valuables. > people like to forget stuff in their cars If cars begin to be produced primarily for the purpose of transporting a single different person over and over again all day (with a smaller number of multi-passenger vehicles being produced for the relatively rare case of multi-passenger rides), then I imagine that eventually they would evolve a design that makes it more obvious when you drop things you are carrying. Currently cars[1] have all kinds of nooks and crannies for your wallet to fall into, because it's not that big a problem in most cases when you do that. But it would be fairly trivial to add a little fiber glass hip that sits flush with the seat. You would have to relocate the seat adjustment controls, but a lot of vehicles have already centralized those controls on the main console, and ridesharing vehicles would actually see enough benefit to consider such a change. [1] this includes taxis because taxis fleets are made up of essentially consumer vehicles. This makes sense, because you always have at least 2 people in a taxi, so you can't really comfortably make it that much smaller. But if there were fleets of rideshared self-driving cars everywhere, most cars would only need to carry a single person, and you can drastically reduce the size of a one-person car without sacrificing comfort. Edit: added third paragraph and the accompanying footnote
- ars 11y ago> with a smaller number of multi-passenger vehicles being produced for the relatively rare case of multi-passenger rides You clearly have no children. Most people do though. Multi-passenger rides are hardly rare. Going to work is not the only thing people use a car for.
- alooPotato 11y agoGreat, if you value those things so much you can pay to own your own vehicle (which you're basically using as a storage bin). But I think that there are a lot of people who would gladly cut down on the $8K-$10K/year of car costs.
- prostoalex 11y ago> The problem I see with shared cars is that people like to forget stuff in their cars. And the amount of your stuff will seem miniscule once you have kids. Car seats for different ages, extra food, water, diapers, sets of clothing, iPad holders, random toys, sports equipment, school supplies, and the list goes on.
- learc83 11y agoDo you refuse to go to restaurants because you're afraid that you might drop your wallet in a booth? Sure you can call the restaurant, but what if another customer already sat there and took it? I'm pretty sure this problem isn't nearly as big as you think it is.
- nitrogen 11y agoRestaurants don't drive off to somewhere else the instant you step out of them.
- learc83 11y agoThis was directed at the OP who said taxi's are OK because you can call the taxi company, but self driving cars aren't because if you don't call before someone else rides in the car you're stuff will be gone. My response is that a restaurant works the same way. If you don't return or call before someone else sits there, you're stuff will be gone. Addressing your point, taxis and buses immediately drive off after you step out of them. Do you avoid them because of this?
- natrius 11y agoRide-hailing apps will eventually take on urban storage as well. Want to avoid carrying something around? Press a button in an app. Want to use the thing you left? Press a button in an app. Want your stuff to head home with you? Press a button in an app.