7 ms·
An End to Parking?
- cballard 11y ago> WHAT WOULD A CITY look like if it suddenly needed 90 percent less parking? ...Amsterdam? > Take New York City, where there are roughly 102,000 public parking spaces below 60th Street—taking up roughly 18.4 million square feet, a space equal to about half of Central Park. > "San Francisco is going bananas for new housing, and Manhattan is always looking for space, and here we have this sitting in front of us," Samaras says. "That's what autonomous vehicles can do." You don't actually ned autonomous cars to do this. Just get rid of the parking (or, start charging market rate for it, and use the money to fund transit). There is an MTA trunk line on almost every avenue, and I'd argue that the ones without subway lines, as well as the major crosstown streets, should be turned into Portland Transit Malls. Enough with being nice to people that drive personal cars into Manhattan.
- ars 11y ago> Just get rid of the parking Might as well get rid of the people too while you are at it. You do know there are real, actual, humans that use those parking spots right? It's not like the car needs the spot. A person needs the spot. The goal of a city is to provide services for the PEOPLE. One of those services is parking, because PEOPLE need to park. > Enough with being nice to people that drive personal cars into Manhattan. Yes, definitely, kick all the people out. Who needs them, right?
- csydas 11y agoI think the intent behind the comment was to suggest that the parking is a need based on a superfluous want, and is intended as a criticism of cities that do have major transit systems which capitulated to the demand for car access. NYC has pretty substantial public transit presence that could and probably should be the transit answer for far more people, however, people chose cars for a variety of reasons. For some of the population, cars probably are a necessity; commuting may not always have a convenient transit option into the city and as such these people have a legitimate need. What the article, and likely the commenter, are suggesting, is that the "need" for parking is a result of a want for cars, not a need for cars, and the article is suggesting the trend is reversing. I think the commenter is suggesting is that it's time to start discouraging those who would take a car when they really don't need to, especially in high density urban populations with substantial public transit presence, and that with an alternative on the horizon, it's time for cities to start reclaiming space that was formerly given to parking. Tangential to this response, I am pretty glad to see that the article takes a more realistic look at the future with self-driving cars. I have been reading comments and articles for a long time where people envision "their" self-driving car, but I've always thought it far more practical to have fleets of these cars instead that are summoned rather than owned by an individual.
- ars 11y agoHave you ever driven in NY? Anyone who drives a car there needs to, rather than wants to. So I was mocking the idea that making things harder for people who already have no choice about driving is a good idea. It's not. You want less cars? Then make the alternatives better, people will automatically drive less. To try to change things from the other end is just a way to torment your fellow man.
- afarrell 11y agoThis is an example of an approach to social problems I sometimes see that I'm going to call "sink or swim". It is a form of proposal framed in terms like "Well, if we do this, it will force $group to either $do_what_we_want or $something_really_unpleasant" and then assumes that everyone in the group will just choose to do what the proposer wants them to do, because the alternative is unthinkable and possible horrific. It is in fact the case that if you take your child and toss them into the middle of the pool, you do force them to either sink or swim. But that isn't the same thing as actually getting them to swim.
- csydas 11y agoI find it difficult to believe that compared to cities of similar size and population density that New York citizens have a greater need for cars. The other similarly sized/populous cities all rely far more heavily on mass transit than New Yorkers appear to, many of the cities that are more populated/larger than New York also are far more mass-transit focused. (Not to say that cars/congestion issues do no exist in said cities, it's just that a greater % of the population rides instead of drives) What about New York makes it so different that driving is an absolute necessity as opposed to say, London? And what creates the need for ownership as opposed to a fleet of automated cars handling the movement around the city? I can envision how a car might be important for occasional living errands, like groceries, etc., but car ownership as a need? Could not the majority of New Yorker needs be filled by either street services like Car2Go/Zipcar or by a fleet of summonable self-driving cars?
- ars 11y ago
- cballard 11y ago> Yes, definitely, kick all the people out. Who needs them, right? 3/4s of Manhattanites do not even own a car, let alone drive it in the city as their main form of transportation. Yes, enough with catering to Jersey and LI people that are for some reason unwilling to use the perfectly fine NJT, PATH, and LIRR trains. If they will not use mass transit and expect to store their personal vehicle on some of the most expensive real estate in the world for free, yes, "kick them out".
- afarrell 11y ago> "San Francisco is going bananas for new housing, and Manhattan is always looking for space, and here we have this sitting in front of us," Samaras says. "That's what autonomous vehicles can do." Wouldn't a sizable portion of the electorate in San Francisco object in the name of affordable housing to building new housing in the space left behind by unused parking?
- tempestn 11y ago> object in the name of affordable housing to building new housing Doesn't building more housing increase housing affordability? Why would they object?
- afarrell 11y agoComprehensive sex education and access to contraception generally decreases rates of teen pregnancy. People still object to those two things in the name of avoiding teen pregnancy.
- danielrhodes 11y agoNo, in fact neighborhood groups generally get upset if new housing goes up without parking as it is believed the new residents will put additional pressure on public parking spots.
- zifnab06 11y agoI'll pick on Seattle, as that's where I'm currently living. To bus to my office, I have a 30 minute bus ride on one of the rapidride busses, then transfer to a king county metro bus. The second bus takes between 0 and 30 minutes to arrive, normally gets stuck in traffic on the route it takes, and arrives near my office in 10 to 30 minutes. This is assuming neither bus is full and picks people up at either stop. On the best day, I'm on a bus for 40 minutes. On the worst, 90. That's 1.5-3 hours a day dealing with a commute. Alternatively, if I drive, I leave when I want to and normally arrive in 15-20 minutes. On a good day I save an hour a day driving, and on a bad one almost 2 hours. I'm all for public transit, when it works efficiently. We currently do not have a rail system that reaches the majority of our population (its being planned though). I can't justify the additional time for my commute, because I'd always have to plan for the worst. The bright side is sound transit is working on a proposal to expand their existing light rail. I'm all for efficient, timely, and reliable public transportation. I live 4 miles from work. It shouldn't take up to 90 minutes for me to get there.
- yodsanklai 11y ago> I live 4 miles from work. It shouldn't take up to 90 minutes for me to get there. That should be 20-30 min by bicycle :) is that an option?
- tempestn 11y agoIn Seattle you're going to get pretty wet biking to work a significant percentage of the time. Depending on your job that might be an issue. (Or it might not at all. Before I worked from home I used to bike to work and shower there; it was great.) Also though, not everyone is able or wants to power their own transportation, and although I think biking is great, I this choosing not to is also perfectly reasonable and should also be respected.
- Symbiote 11y agoThe weather isn't that much different to Amsterdam or Copenhagen. But in both cities, buses have the exclusive use of some road space. This ensures a reliable journey time.
- la6470 11y agoYeah? Go to a place like China or India where there is no place to park your car. Nowadays almost everyone in the world have a car so we need place to park. If you don't want to own a car it is your problem. The new generation is losing independence FAST....
- ehnto 11y agoThat is the point of the article though, nearly everyone has a car and that is causing issues. I think for housing at least, building vertically is a good solution to storage of a car. Expensive of course but practical. Underground parking for businesses would also be good, moving parking off the streets is always nice. Unless, by moving parking away from streets you then just use it for more moving cars. That creats a very hostile and noisy environment. Sometimes the parked cars are a nice buffer between the street and pedestrians. Regardless, I wish our central city was nothing but walk and bicycle paths. It would be much more enjoyable and I would spend more time here.
- rahimnathwani 11y ago"Sometimes the parked cars are a nice buffer between the street and pedestrians." Sure, but the current design of the sidewalk has to accommodate a car door opening at any point, as someone could park anywhere. When roads are no longer used for parking, sidewalks could be lined with a narrow strip of trees or something, with a gap every 100m for cars to load/unload passengers.
- jurip 11y ago> Nowadays almost everyone in the world have a car In Helsinki, less than half of households have cars. In many areas of central Helsinki, more than 60% are carless. I'd be surprised if car ownership was significantly more popular in other European cities. If there's good public transit and the city is walkable, a car is a waste of money for most people.
- lis 11y agoRandom data point: There were 342 cars registered per 1000 citizens in Berlin in 2014 [0]. Same in other (large) cities I have lived in in Europe. Typically, using the public transport in Berlin will be much quicker than taking the car. [0] Sorry, article in German (and BZ..): http://www.bz-berlin.de/berlin/immer-mehr-autobesitzer-aber-weniger-fahrer http://www.bz-berlin.de/berlin/immer-mehr-autobesitzer-aber-...
- mc32 11y agoI never liked vast seas of parking or sprawl. It's not my thing; I like compactness. I prefer safe, crime free, walkable mass transit centered communities. I think it's more aesthetic, is better use of land, it's a healthier way to live, to experience the place you grow and die in. But, I loathe people telling people how things should be and what should better. Things will change organically, just as they organically changed from sodden cow and horse manure filled roads to paved, car filled roads. So too will cars acquiesce to something else. But stop, stop the condescension and promulgation that all that is car is bad. When something better comes along, people will choose the better thing. For good or bad, in the US, China, Japan, Europe and Africa, people choose cars when they're useful. Cars aren't foisted onto them. Yes, choices in development matter, but that's an altogether different topic. Back to aesthetics, while I would enjoy fewer cars and parking spaces, I do not look forward to buildings built closer together like in the middle ages. They're nice when you're taking a stroll, but they are impractical for emergencies, when people need to evacuate, when emergency vehicles need access. I prefer wide streets even in the absence of cars [ever experience mid rises banging against each other in an earthquake?]
- eloisant 11y agoMaybe you don't know it but cities are designed. There are urban planners who decide who to organise an area, public governements decide what land is open to what kind of buildings, etc. So decisions are taken about how to organise cities, and it's been this way for centuries. See how Haussmann transformed Paris in the 19th century for example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haussmann%27s_renovation_of_Paris https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haussmann%27s_renovation_of_Pa...
- WildUtah 11y agoMore topically, parking is built because city planners and local and state laws require it. It isn't optional, developers can't choose to organically build less over time, it isn't a matter of choice, and it won't acquiesce into anything else. And the predominance of parking everywhere in America didn't just happen. It was mandated by law. First world cities with low parking requirements have much less than 5% as much parking as American cities do. Because that is what people will build voluntarily and pay for.
- mschuster91 11y agoThe problem I see with shared cars is that people like to forget stuff in their cars. Cellphones, ID bages, food, wallets, bags... When I park my car at my workplace and I notice my badge fell out of my pants (or I forgot it), no problem, I can head back to the car and get my badge. If I take a cab I can always phone the cab central and have them ask the driver to look for the item (of course, this requires honest cab drivers and it will cost me a huge amount of money if the cab driver is already on the other end of the city by the time I notice). No way at all to do so with an autonomous car. Also, a shift to autonomous cars would prevent another very common use case: after work I might want to do something else before driving home, like going to sports training. So now I'd have to carry my gun and ammo (or my sport gear, or ...) all the time around with me instead of leaving the stuff in my car. Also, my own car still is freedom: public transport, even in Germany, shuts down after 2200 and restarts only at 0500, and if you're outside the city you rarely have time intervals for buses and trains lower than 20min - often it's more like 40min, 60min or even 120min. With a shared car system, I'd have to wait totally unpredictable amounts of time until a shared car is free, and there's nothing I hate more than waiting. Getting people off individual cars would require absolutely massive investment in public transport. Might work out in cities, but in rural areas there's no way you can get people to abandon their cars.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoIndeed. I definitely use my car to carry a variety of tools and equipment with me all of the time, including emergency supplies. I'd have to start wearing like... a purse or something to keep even a fraction of that with me. Regarding hours... realizing the bus to your hotel in Iceland is no longer in service at 2 AM in a snowstorm in March is super excitng.
- reustle 11y ago> No way at all to do so with an autonomous car. How can you say that when they aren't even a thing yet? They could easily have a hotline to call in case of a situation like this, where they can manually pull it out of the queue and send it back to your location. It wouldn't be complicated or costly.
- ars 11y agoThese autonomous cars are hardly a full solution. Or do you expect parents to attach car seats each time they call one up? And where do you put the car seats the rest of the time? Cary them along with you? It would be nice if the cars came with them built in, but I don't think it's possible to make a seat that can accommodate every size child.
- rglullis 11y agoWhy would it be so hard to drop the car seat requirement? Taxis are exempt from them, the security benefits are questionable already (more so once you factor that an autonomous car would probably have a different cabin and safety features), buses and trains don't need them... Not to mention that a society that gets away from being car centric would also grant more independency to children from their parents. In Japan, kids are used to go to school by themselves at age 5. In Berlin I see kids seemlingly from elementary school going around alone in the U-Bahn. Looks like parents not having to be kids' chauffeurs would be a net gain.
- eterm 11y agoYou'd have your own private autonomous car. You could keep the car seats, clutter, etc in it. It would drive you to work, then it would drive itself home and park there (or at an out-of-town free space) instead of parking in the city. Later, it drives itself back to your office to pick you up. No shared car required, no parking space either.
- lucaspiller 11y agoWhat about car sharing schemes such as Car2Go, Zipcar, etc, where you pay just for the amount of time you use the car? Unlike autonomous cars, these are available now and proven to be successful. Here in Rome Car2Go have over 600 cars, so you are usually no more than 5 minutes walk from one. You can also leave it anywhere in the 'home zone', rather than having to find a specific car sharing parking space. There is also another service run by the city that has a similar number of cars. The prices are quite high, but if you just need it for odd trips (i.e. not commuting every day) it's still going to be cheaper than owning a car, and a lot easier than having to deal with public transport.