4 ms·
Elder Care Startup Honor Makes Contractors Full-Time Workers with Equity
- JshWright 11y agoThe title case of the headline (without any punctuation) made this very difficult for me to parse... As far as the content goes though, I think this is fantastic. Elder care is a role that can be _incredibly_ challenging. It's nice to see folks getting the respect they deserve.
- mfoy_ 11y agoYes, I didn't know "Honor" was the name of the startup (Which focuses on Elder Care) until I opened the article. On an unrelated note, it's interesting to see that the decision to do this was less related to the current contract vs full-time debate and more related to Honor's specific industry and business model.
- bwilliams18 11y agoI don't think the full time vs contract debate and the industry and business model decision are as separate as you'd believe. It's the same thing in the restaurant world with tipping. Danny Meyer can assert that he's eliminating tipping because he can more fairly compensate employees, and I believe that's part of it, but the motivating factor is certainly the increase in minimum wage and its impact on the economics of the restaurants.
- robk 11y agoSome restaurants have gone back on the no tipping policy http://money.cnn.com/2016/01/19/pf/no-tipping-reversed-bar-agricole-trou-normand/ http://money.cnn.com/2016/01/19/pf/no-tipping-reversed-bar-a...
- goodJobWalrus 11y agoI would think that the problem they'd have if they didn't do this is that once the family got to know the care worker, they would offer them to work for them w/o Honor's involvement. Same issue Homejoy had, but in this case, it's even more important who works for you.
- tomasien 11y agoAs always with these things I think it's important to remember that for both the company and the worker, every situation is different. There are tradeoffs that both make when deciding to move from 1099 to W-2 and vice-versa. The implication whenever one of these companies, since as Managed by Q or Instacart, makes a move like this is they're saying "W-2 is the way to go and is obviously better". That is not the case. It does make sense here and I applaud them for being thoughtful and proactive.
- kelukelugames 11y agoWhy can't companies give every employee stocks or equity? Is $100 worth of stocks useless to someone on ~$40k annual income?
- alphast0rm 11y agoCompanies with 500+ shareholders have to file reports including audited financial information with the SEC [1], which would be a problem. [1] http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2011/11/29/facebook-may-be-forced-to-go-public-amid-market-gloom/ http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2011/11/29/facebook-may-be-force...
- rcarrigan87 11y agoHaving spent the past 3 years growing a home care business, one of the biggest lessons early on was to focus on the caregivers. Almost all our caregivers are black, single women living at the poverty line. Anything you can do to help them with childcare, making ends meet some months, offering extra hours, etc. is life changing. Ultimately, the caregivers are your product. I always wondered about companies like Honor. Their initial pitch was basically all existing home care companies are still in the stone ages, very inefficient, still using paper (typical SV storyline). The reality is there are a few really well built SaaS companies (Clearcare is the one we use) that can do all the automated scheduling, compliance, billing, caregiver ratings, family portal, etc. Elder care is a really tough business. Seniors are extremely susceptible to abuse and all kinds of things often go wrong. Dispatching caregivers through an app sounds like a nightmare. Seems from the article these guys are beginning to learn the ropes of the business. I hope they figure it out. The growing number of seniors is going to be an incredible challenge.
- randycupertino 11y agoI've also worked in senior care and have seen some incredibly horrific abuse cases. One caregiver would say he was taking the elder to the park for a walk, to a cafe for lunch, to the pharmacy to pick up meds and then to the store, but really he was driving them to his house, locking the elder in the back with the child proof locks enabled, and leaving him inside the car for hours while he went in his apartment and watched TV. We only found out because the elder tapped on the window when someone walked by the SUV (tinted windows) and that person called the police. Other things like triple diapering to not have to change the elder more than 1x per shift and massive yeast infections underneath the breasts due to lack of bathing and not changing clothes. The worst types of places I have seen are the "board and care" facilities for mentally disabled adults run by Russians in the east bay. There were a few rotted/unchanged/septic g-tubes that were absolutely horrific. It's been years and that specific smell of a rotting gtube is still burned into my brain. There was also this case in the East Bay where the facility abruptly shut down and stopped paying their workers and so all the caregiving staff just left except for the janitor and the cook who stayed on and cared for the seniors for several days until the fire department and sheriff finally responded: http://www.npr.org/2014/11/21/365433685/if-we-left-they-wouldnt-have-nobody http://www.npr.org/2014/11/21/365433685/if-we-left-they-woul... <--- Honor should give those two dudes who stayed jobs! It's a very challenging industry.
- salmonet 11y agoI think this could be a really great competitive advantage if it translates into them having the best workers and customers know that. One thing I've noticed in my experience with the home care industry (startup that serves seniors) is that contractors I meet are either extremely kind and intrinsically motivated or not at all. I would either love or hate for a given contractor to care for my own parents.
- Animats 11y agoAll those "gig economy" companies are going to be forced to treat their employees as employees. The main Uber lawsuit goes to trial in June.[1] The lawyer behind this, Shannon Liss-Riordan, has previously won against Starbucks, American Airlines, FedEx, and over a hundred other companies on similar issues. Uber's attempt to block class action suits and force arbitration failed. US District Court Judge Edward Chen rejected the validity of the arbitration clause. He called the clause "both procedurally and substantively unconscionable." Uber is going to lose this. Homejoy already lost, and shut down.[2] Postmates, Shyp, Instacart, Lyft, and Washio are being sued too, over the same issue. Labor law is pretty clear on this. [1] http://uberlawsuit.com/Uber%20sued%20by%20drivers%20excluded%20from%20class-action%20lawsuit.pdf http://uberlawsuit.com/Uber%20sued%20by%20drivers%20excluded... [2] http://techcrunch.com/2015/07/31/why-homejoy-failed-and-the-future-of-the-on-demand-economy/ http://techcrunch.com/2015/07/31/why-homejoy-failed-and-the-...
- graeme 11y agoIs labor law all that clear on it? I'm in Canada, so maybe there are differences, but under our law a case like Uber's seems like a grey area. The vehicles aren't standardized. Drivers aren't required to drive at any given times, or at all, I believe. It's not clear to me what distinguishes Uber drivers from, say, Airbnb hosts, who are clearly not employees. (There are factors that point towards Uber workers being employees, but no single factor is determinative.) The Homejob article actually focusses on the leakage aspects. I think their business model was doomed regardless of how they classified their employees.
- bsder 11y ago> It's not clear to me what distinguishes Uber drivers from, say, Airbnb hosts, who are clearly not employees. If Uber/Lyft were like AirBnB, it would be providing you a car with keys with the occasional optional driver. With AirBnB, getting "service" beyond the lodging is optional (and less common than it used to be). However, Uber/Lyft always provides the driver. The fact that the driver is an inseparable part of the service is what is eventually going to cause them to lose.
- 11y ago
- gohrt 11y agoIf management ever even hints to an employee that the Equity has >$0 estimated value, which could influence the employee's notion of an appropriate wage, then this is a scam, even more so than it is with the finally-business-savvy tech employees
- tzier 11y agoFormer CPA and Zen99 founder here. Home care givers are a special case under US tax code that requires them to be employees [1]. As honorable (yuk yuk) as it is that Honor is making them employees, they would have the worst case out of all the on-demand companies. Uber, for example, can point to nearly all taxi drivers being independent contractors. Honor would have to point to other home care individuals, who are either employees of a staffing agency or employees of the family (note: there are surely families who aren't complying). Based on IRS code + the reasons brought against Uber/etc, Honor would have a very low chance of winning the lawsuit. Overall, I do think making on-demand workers employees is a potentially smart move to differentiate. Having the best workers will be the key to winning longer term, because these are service companies enabled by tech, not tech companies. Code has no feelings; people do. Right now Uber is winning ridesharing because it has the most volume and hence most money making opportunities for drivers; but Lyft is putting up a fight almost purely because they treat their drivers better. [1] https://www.irs.gov/Businesses/Small-Businesses-&-Self-Employed/Family-Caregivers-and-Self-Employment-Tax https://www.irs.gov/Businesses/Small-Businesses-&-Self-Emplo...
- dr_ 11y agoMy career is as a physician in post acute care settings. From my experience one of the biggest, if not the biggest, issue regarding home care for seniors is the cost. The agencies near us are rather expensive for most seniors. It's covered by Medicaid for those who have it and some insurances provide benefits, but otherwise if you are a senior who needs care for several hours to 24 hours a day, you are typically paying about $20 an hour or $200 a day. Medicare does not cover it, and a lot of people cannot afford it. Which is why when we discharge people and make the recommendation for home care, and connect them with an agency, many patients and families do not follow through with it, beyond what their insurance may cover for a short period of time. Mind you I realize this doesn't mean the caregiver gets paid anywhere near $20 an hour or $200 a day, so I applaud Honors intentions of making them full time workers with, I hope, benefits. But the bigger issue is how do seniors pay for these services? It will probably require a change at the level of CMMS.