5 ms·
> Then I shut up! And most likely lose your license for a year in many cases and be charged with a civil offense. Maybe the officer can still "smell" it on you
by rdtsc 11y ago
> Then I shut up!
And most likely lose your license for a year in many cases and be charged with a civil offense. Maybe the officer can still "smell" it on your or see you drive erratically and so have enough "evidence" to pile on criminal charges as well.
In some states they could charge you with the driving under DUI as well.
It think refusal case is called "Implied Consent" -- you consented to it already by getting into the car and driving on public roads.
Not saying I agree with it or endorse that, just presenting it how it may work in some states.
- ccvannorman 11y agoSmelling (weed) is no longer probable cause to search a vehicle, Supreme Court said so. [1] [1] http://countercurrentnews.com/2015/07/court-rules-odor-is-not-sufficient-for-cops-to-have-probable-cause/ http://countercurrentnews.com/2015/07/court-rules-odor-is-no...
- bobwaycott 11y agoJesus christ. Thanks for a link with browser-takeover, ad-spam crap. Loaded the page, and the window's taken over by a popover from MacKeeper or whatever the hell it is. Click the dismiss button, and it opens a fucking new page to their site to download shit. Close that window. Think maybe I mis-clicked. Do it again--because it's still taking up the whole damn screen--same result. How do you read such a shitty site with such user-hostile practices? And even if you can, why would you post such a link to HN? Gah. Time to get an adblocker, I guess. Anyway, SCOTUS hasn't ruled on smelling marijuana and probable cause as far as I can tell. That was, to my knowledge, the Arizona Court of Appeals and the Massachusetts Supreme Court.
- Kliment 11y agoVery likely the person who posted it was unaware due to using an ad blocker or script blocker.
- bobwaycott 11y agoAnd now they are aware. Not everyone runs an ad/script blocker.
- jacquesm 11y agoWell, at least now you too have at least one good reason to run one.
- bobwaycott 11y agoGood grief. Do you seriously think I am, unlike all the other HN users who wear their adblockers on their sleeves, likely to be unaware of reasons for using adblockers? Having reasons for using an adblocker are entirely orthogonal to what happened when I clicked on a link shared by another HN user—a link I have an inherently higher expectation of trust for because it's from a fellow HN user. The user needed to know the site they shared is a piece of shit source that shouldn't be posted to HN.
- jacquesm 11y agoThe point is that to them that wasn't a piece of shit source. It's the ad tag that your browser downloaded that made it so and the content provider might not even be aware of this.
- 9935c101ab17a66 11y agoI just want to make sure you're aware that you completely and totally overreacted, and, if the tone you employed in your comment is your normal way of communicating online, I suggest you wait a day before replying to comments.
- wernercd 11y agoWhich is more reason to be aware of reasons to get one: security, Annoyances, security, mental effort to pay attention to ads (Takes effort/training to block/ignore/click X/etc), security, bandwidth (more for mobile), Oh... did I mention security (lots of attacks through ad networks)?
- jnbiche 11y agoSeriously, if you're that offended about these kinds of sites, get an adblocker. > Gah. Time to get an adblocker, I guess. I'd say it's been time for you to do that.
- bobwaycott 11y agoWhat I'm offended by is an HN user posting shitty sites like that into the comments. I expect more from HN users, and think the community should be aware of sites that do shitty things to users. Getting an adblocker isn't a solution for an HN user ignorantly posting a source that does shitty things to its users. Informing the user about their garbage link is the correct response.
- newjersey 11y agoI got a reckless driving ticket in Kansas even though the police appeared at least five minutes after my tire blew and I stopped in the side of the street on the grass. They couldn't have possibly seen me driving at all. It wasn't worth it to fight small tickets like this for me. I don't know what I'd have done if I was broke and unable to pay...
- cmurf 11y agoShitty little podunk towns, man. Just like the article. Few decades ago, shortly after moving from Kansas, I drove home for Thanksgiving. I saw a speedtrap many miles in advance, passed it, and miles later I see, in the rearview mirror, a cop cross the median and he bridged the gap with ungodly speed. At no time was he going my speed. He pulls me over, claims I was going 15 over using the pace method. He comes back with a ticket, but it has radar checked. I pointed out this discrepancy and said I won't sign the ticket. He says to sign it or I'm going to jail. Had it not been for Thanksgiving, I'd have called his bluff. Thing is, the rot goes to the top. The D.A. was in on it. And the town judge. It was all about making money. Plain, ordinary robbery. And I know that because I accused them all of it (over the phone). They were way way more pissed than they should have been if they were innocent. The vitriol I heard confirmed my suspicion. House of rats.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>It think refusal case is called "Implied Consent" -- you consented to it already by getting into the car and driving on public roads. If she hadn't wanted it, why did she wear that in public? The very notion of 'implied consent' shows how far our legal system has fallen.
- rdtsc 11y agoDriving is a privilege. People agree to certain rules when they start driving. According to the states this is one of the rules. If you don't want to play, don't drive. And that's exactly what they do. If you refuse, they won't charge you with criminal offense necessarily, but instead take your privilege to drive and impose a civil fine. That is a bit different than rape as far as I see, but I guess you don't see it that way. You are also voluntarily giving up freedoms when you sign up for the military or get a security clearance. You can try to claim free speech for divulging state secrets, but you'll still go to jail, because you signed a contract to that effect.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>Driving is a privilege. And yet, at least in the more spread out areas of the US, it is far more a necessity than voting. Why is it a privilege while voting is not? And as for differences, the basics of consent is consistent across where ever that consent is being applied. That the harms of violations of consent may differ does not change that.
- rdtsc 11y agoThe punishment for implied consent is they take away the privilege. They don't jail you That's a specific loophole. It turns into a civil court thing and DMV thing not a criminal thing. > Why is it a privilege while voting is not? Oh I agree with you. But we'd have to fix that first. It is a privilege because it is not made into law that travel by car on public roads is a universal human right like other rights in the Constitution. As far as the govt. is concerned citizens have the absolute right to ride their horse on public lands. Just like they did in the 1700s. As soon as anyone steps in a car, airplane, train etc, they lose some right and have to abide by certain rules.