7 ms·
Arcade City: Decentralized, Blockchain-Based Answer to Uber
- droopybuns 11y agoThis feels like an entertaining distraction by someone who massively underestimates their need to provide support to both drivers and customers. Uber's GPS mapping soloution doesn't work as magically as it needs to. Things change pretty quickly there. I don't think this could succeed without traditional support infrastructure. Also, block chain updates over mobile? What is the data plan of those drivers going to look like?
- aakilfernandes 11y ago> What is the data plan of those drivers going to look like? Light nodes or just plain http. You don't need to download the entire blockchain.
- zekevermillion 11y agoAssuming that it is even necessary to use ethereum for a distributed uber -- I see no need for the driver to maintain a copy of the blockchain, and certainly not in the vehicle. Groups of drivers who trust each other IRL could, for example, cooperate to finance a single full node and then make calls to that service to verify payment. Presumably, drivers could also use third-party mapping software / services, dispatchers, whatever aspects of the biz are not handled by the decentralized protocol.
- mostly_harmless 11y agoso now drivers need to host their own cryptocurrency pool?
- zekevermillion 11y agoWhat is a cryptocurrency pool? Are you thinking of a mining pool? No, there would be no need for that. Why would a taxi driver need to mine bitcoin? Let's ignore that taxi drivers could avoid using any cryptocurrency. It's possible to have the ride hailing and rating systems done without bitcoin. If we assume that bitcoin or a clone is the right network to use for the dispatch and ratings systems, then someone the taxi driver trusts has to run wallet software to verify that transactions are valid. It might be a good idea for them to have their own node for certain functions as well. Wallet and node software could be run very cheaply in the taxi driver's home, or even in a project shared between drivers. So the objection about mobile bandwidth is easily overcome.
- AndrewDucker 11y agoDoes this mean that the Blockchain will contain every taxi request ever made using this system? That's going to get pretty unwieldy after a while.
- kmicklas 11y agoNo worse than if a blockchain based system were used for regular old financial transactions.
- Rmilb 11y agoSide chains, lightning network, and other off-chain transactions can solve this problem.
- joosters 11y agoShame they don't exist yet. But I often hear how lightning will solve everything.
- jedberg 11y agoI'm not entire sure many of the Uber drivers realized they are just a temporary stopgap until self driving cars are a reality. Uber I'm sure will be one of the first, if not the first, company to have a massive fleet of self driving cars. At that point their costs will be so low they'll be able to undercut anyone still using human drivers.
- hueving 11y agoThey are a stopgap in a similar way McDonald's employees are stopgaps until full automation. It's a long way out; and, even if it is closer than expected, that type of employee hasn't exactly invested a lot of their life into training for the job so it's not like they are getting screwed.
- vosper 11y agoI suspect Uber will actually beat McDonald's to automation. I tried to find any evidence that McDonald's in trying to automate their restaurants, and all I could find was a joke news article.
- petra 11y agoLooking at mcdonnalds doing automation is just one avenue restaurant automation will happen.It's just as likely that some other company/startup will lead, for example momentum machines' burger robot(assuming not vaporware) or eatsa's restaurant model.
- tommoor 11y agoThey already have machines that take your order through a touchscreen in some McDonalds... that's half the jobs gone in one swoop!
- smackfu 11y agoOne thing they do now is put the drive-in order-taker off-site at a call center. I guess not so recent, considering this article is from 2006: http://www.nytimes.com/2006/04/11/technology/11fast.html?pag&_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2006/04/11/technology/11fast.html?pag...
- Jaepa 11y agoI just want to mention. It looks as though this site is violating the same orgin policy (is proxying it ads). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Same-origin_policy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Same-origin_policy
- yid 11y agoThe same-origin policy is not an optional choice that can be "violated".
- chatmasta 11y agoI love the thought behind this. The biggest threat to Uber is not Lyft or taxis or any competitors, but the emergence of a decentralized, p2p ridesharing platform. Ridesharing companies already call themselves "p2p" but that's a farce. There is nothing p2p about a single $XXX billion corporation controlling millions of rides. In the Uber/Driver relationship, it seems at first glance that Uber has all the power. But in fact, the drivers have far more leverage. A single driver can drive for multiple apps, and in fact a significant percentage of the drivers I meet are simultaneously using Uber and Lyft. Currently drivers using multiple platforms are pretty much only using Uber and/or Lyft. There is no third competitor. But if one emerges, especially with superior driver incentives, drivers will use it, even before any riders are on the platform. Even if demand on a new app is sparse, drivers have no reason not to download it and run it on their phone alongside Uber and Lyft. In the meantime while they wait for supply to grow, they can just continue using Uber and Lyft. But if this "third competitor" offers far greater incentives than Uber and Lyft, then once it's supply side achieves parity with its demand side, drivers will prefer it to Uber and Lyft. So what does a "third competitor" look like to Uber or Lyft? It looks like a company (or something else!!) that gives 95% or more of revenue to its drivers, i.e. operates on minimal margins. What are the requirements of a true p2p ridesharing platform? -- - Bare minimum dependency on centralized third party resources - Decentralized reputation and dispute resolution protocols - Decentralized payment system, possibly involving an auction model - Equilibrium of supply and demand - Legal compliance without a dependency on a centralized market maker -- No technological barrier exists to any of these requirements. The most difficult aspect of a p2p ride sharing platform would be legal compliance. How do riders vet drivers, and how do drivers insure themselves? Perhaps the solution is a third party, uninvested in the ridesharing platform, that controls the reputation, dispute resolution, and insurance system. Asking the ridesharing platform to carry those responsibilities will only result in bloat and overhead costs that cut into the margins of drivers. Whereas if a third party manages legal compliance, drivers can price the cost of it into their own driving services, instead of the platform "passing down" the cost to drivers (and exaggerating its magnitude). The second most difficult aspect would be bootstrapping supply and demand. The supply side is relatively easy, as long as the driver onboarding cost is low. The demand side is more difficult, because people trust Uber and Lyft. Building that trust in a decentralized system would not be easy, especially without legal compliance. I challenge someone to create the Napster of ridesharing. No central servers allowed, mobile clients only, no financial overhead per transaction. The next step would be to create the trusted third party responsible for legal compliance. A p2p platform that achieves supply/demand parity and solves the legal compliance problem will destroy Uber and Lyft, because the centralized costs of a p2p platform are zero. The drivers price their own services and have incentive to find the most economically efficient legal compliance. Therefore prices are lower than Uber and Lyft, so ultimately people will prefer p2p over centralized. sidenote: I'm from the Portsmouth area. If anyone at arcade city is reading this, reach out! :)
- programminggeek 11y agoEnd users don't know or care what a blockchain is.
- vosper 11y agoEthereum, while interesting, is even more obscure than Bitcoin. It's not well tested, and by their own admission is not production ready. https://www.ethereum.org/ https://www.ethereum.org/
- azinman2 11y agoUhhh what? Blockchain blockchain blockchain! And uber! How in the world are these connected. He's presenting it like its this obvious thing that needs to be connected when it's not clear at all why any blockchain needs to be involved.
- aakilfernandes 11y agoMonopoly prevention. Once the api is on the blockchain, no one can build a wall around it and charge an entry fee.
- yid 11y agoWhat about transaction latency, driver/passenger reputations and ratings, local legal compliance, payment for auxiliary services like maps and point-to-point navigation? All those things sound like they'd be worse off. The end benefit to the consumer being monopoly prevention isn't likely to outweigh the service guarantees of a centralized service.
- dayon 11y agoHow does Craigslist handle reputation? And yet, I'm sure you'd rather use Craigslist for certain purchases than eBay.
- yid 11y agoYes, but I'd ideally go to a licensed, brick-and-mortar store for the reputation and reliability over either eBay or Craigslist, if it weren't for the prices and availability of items. My point is that the benefits of centralized, non-blockchain solutions can outweigh what you lose when you go decentralized, and that's something that should be questioned of every new blockchain application.
- HillaryBriss 11y agoYes. Good point. It's an interesting thought experiment. What if the broad spectrum of Craigslist service providers included car drivers who could (somehow - hand wave) offer rides on Craigslist? How much confidence would you have in them? What condition would you expect their cars to be in? What kind of driving record could be expected from the drivers? How would you choose a driver from that spectrum? Would you expect to pay less or the same as for an Uber ride? Under what circumstances would you just avoid using a Craigslist driver altogether?
- srameshc 11y agoThis is great ! Not perfect probably right now but none the less a great start. I was talking about something like this a few weeks back and thought it would be in next few years I see a similar product. But it has just been weeks since that discussion. I truly believe that side chain has answer to such open solutions and I am very excited to see things being built.
- bobajeff 11y agoThis is really cool. There is very little technical details in the article but I gather they already got a system in place, it's using etherium, it's decenralized, and the people behind it have been uber and lyft drivers.
- trvlngwlbry 11y agoBuilding out both sides of a two-sided market is extremely hard. While this decentralized system might be appealing to drivers, Uber and Lyft have created such a great experience for riders, that I don't see a compelling reason for riders to move to this system -- even if moving to this system is as easy as downloading Arcade City. And without the riders, the drivers won't give it very long. That said, chicken-and-egg scenarios exist in every industry, and get hurdled all the time, so I'll be interested to watch how it goes for this one.
- rayiner 11y agoIronically, the driving force behind Uber's popularity is its centralization and uniformity. Uber replaces the hodge-podge of thousands of different taxi operators with a single company that offers a single app with a single billing system everywhere in the country, while holding drivers to strict vehicle and service standards.
- bobajeff 11y agoI don't know if that's the reason for uber's popularity. I think it, along with other ridesharing sites, are just another option in addition to taxi, car rentals and public transportation.
- ssharp 11y agoI wouldn't discount OP's comment at all. It's the main reason I use Uber. I couldn't care less about it's service vs. taxi's, or ridesharing, or most other things. The things I like about it are: 1) I have a single app that I can request a car in mere seconds in just about every major city 2) Payments are handled automatically That's it. And #2 is an added bonus. #1 is the killer feature for me. I don't have to stand around trying to hail a cab, nor do I have look up a cab company's number to call a car and hope they have one available within a reasonable timeframe.
- bobajeff 11y agoI'm not discounting it; just treating it as conjecture. I myself think it's important to look around at different options when looking for transportation and lodging.
- tptacek 11y agoThis is a little like "conjecturing" about the reason people liked iPods more than CD Walkmen. Even in places with very good cab service (NYC and Chicago), cabs are a fucking pain to work with, and Uber is incredibly simple to work with.
- anonbanker 11y agoSomeone decided to write an uber-replacement on top of Ethereum. This is a lot cooler than the kickstarter replacement they had in the tutorials. Looks like this is where the development is headed. I really didn't want to have to learn Go; is there a rust implementation yet?