3 ms·
Dogs are a key element in letting them rob people on the side of the road. Ya know, after I had written my parallel comment and gave it some thought later, I c
by mikestew 11y ago
Dogs are a key element in letting them rob people on the side of the road.
Ya know, after I had written my parallel comment and gave it some thought later, I concluded that it's all just bullshit. The dog didn't alert by sitting, and the officer didn't cue him. They were going to search the car regardless.
You say 'no', but, the puppy says 'yes' and there go your rights. It is pretty magic.
Here's where I disagree with you (but only in the details). The dog didn't say anything. I mean, I've seen dogs sniff for drugs (and find them). I've watched amateur Noseworks competitors (slightly related to the training sniffing dogs). No dog "alerts" by sitting, at least none I've ever seen. Dogs sit all the time, it would be a stupid cue. That dog could have just stood there and ripped the meanest fart you ever smelled, and the thieves (pardon: cops) would have said that the dog "alerted". "Yup, smells like he found something!"
As you point out, the dog is a prop, a talisman. That car was getting searched, full stop. They just needed a "get out of the 4th amendment free" card in the shape of a German Shepherd. They might as well train gerbils for that. They fit in your pocket, cost less to feed, and with a little propaganda we can all be led to believe they work just as well as dogs (and they probably will if you're just looking for false positives).
(And to be clear, I'm not saying you can't train a dog to sniff for drugs or bombs. Obviously they can be trained for this, and to a high degree of reliability. They can, however, also be trained to bark, dig, or whine on command, whether they smell drugs or not.)
- rdtsc 11y ago> As you point out, the dog is a prop, a talisman. > Here's where I disagree with you (but only in the details). Oh I agree, the dog saying 'yes' was meant to be the officer using the dog to note on paper that 'dog said yes'. As you said, in case of this group, they didn't have to pretend much at all. I imagine others would actually have a functional, probably somewhat non-obvious alerting signal. But this groups was getting good results without trying much. I think they probably learned their lesson from this -- spend more time training the dog to actually alert and figure out how to make it do it reliably and out of the sight of the camera.
- mark-r 11y agoHow do you reach the conclusion that they've learned any lesson from this? Have the officers been reprimanded in any way? If this couple had any amount of cash on them, it would have been confiscated as "drug money". Good luck getting it back, even in the absence of any evidence. That's why these tactics are tolerated, it's a source of income for the department. Who cares if a few innocent out-of-staters are taken advantage of? The whole situation just makes me sick, and I'm continually surprised that it hasn't been ruled unconstitutional.
- rdtsc 11y ago> How do you reach the conclusion that they've learned any lesson from this? Have the officers been reprimanded in any way? That was sarcasm. The point was the cops probably didn't get reprimanded, laws probably didn't change. But, they probably got chewed out in Monday morning meeting about taking better care, for example: make sure dog alerts off camera or takes a subtler cue. After precious department funding is at stake here, it is not amateur hour. Maybe imagine it like a mafia leader instructing his henchmen to properly dispose of bodies, otherwise it leave evidence and makes everything difficult ;-)
- rand334 11y agoPolice don't get reprimanded in America. They just get paid vacation at worst. Shoot a handcuffed guy in the back of your squad car? "Oh, he must have had a gun we just didn't find when we searched him." Right. Right.
- Vivtek 11y ago"Enjoy your two-week paid fishing trip."
- smcl 11y agoRe-read the actual lesson GP stated the officers learned - that they should be more subtle when giving giving cues to the dog.
- biturd 11y ago
- niels_olson 11y ago> no dog alerts by sitting Um, actually, that's exactly what every military working drug dog I've seen does. Source: spent a year as the legal officer on my first ship. Had a dog come to the course. Had a dog on the ship. And they definitely have a non-negligible false-positive rate. But, certainly, the video, as described, supports a cue.
- girvo 11y agoYeah. Drug dogs here in Australia are trained to sit as a cue, at least as far as my experience with them goes.
- duncan_bayne 11y agoJust like the Police here - sitting on their arses is what passes for working ;-)
- exDM69 11y ago> No dog "alerts" by sitting, at least none I've ever seen. Dogs sit all the time, it would be a stupid cue. These dogs are trained to alert by sitting down and not to sit down when doing their job. Just look at any video footage from sniffer dogs in training or working.