4 ms·
"If you look in slow-motion, the dog passes an open window on the passenger side with no alert. The handler then leads the dog around the front. Then, on the dr
by mikestew 11y ago
"If you look in slow-motion, the dog passes an open window on the passenger side with no alert. The handler then leads the dog around the front. Then, on the driver's side, he turns his body around and gestures toward the window. Suddenly, the dog sits. That's the alert."
As I've always suspected. I could take just about any random dog from your local animal shelter and train them to do that in about 20 minutes (look up "clicker training Zach" on YouTube, watch what he can teach in half that time). And point at the window is the cue? Amateur hour. Given the amount of time given to train a K-9 unit, I could come up with something much more subtle, and I only train dogs as an amateur volunteer, not a professional K-9 trainer.
Alternatively, many dogs that I've trained long-term will default to "sit" when they can't figure out what you want. Could have been that the dog didn't know what "point at window" means, but the mutt knows it means something. Doggy runs through his mental database, comes with no match for "point at window", defaults to "sit".
TL;DR: the more time I spend training dogs, the more I'm convinced that drug dogs are about as reliable as polygraphs, if not worse because the handler can game it.
- stordoff 11y ago> many dogs that I've trained long-term will default to "sit" I've definitely seen this with my dog. Say her name, and see just looks at you. Say her name and raise your hand up flat, and she'll sit straight away. Say her name, and do some other hand gesture, and she'll pause for a few seconds and usually (90% of the time I'd guess) sits down.
- duncan_bayne 11y agoI've seen that. We did some obedience competition with one of our dogs. If she didn't understand a command, she'd cycle through the first three things she learned (sit, down, roll over) until stopped :-)
- tonyarkles 11y agoGlad to see that our dog isn't too weird with that behaviour! When she doesn't know what to do, she cycles between sitting and laying down, pretty rapidly. Great entertainment!
- Shivetya 11y agoit does not matter if you or I think the dog alerted. These types of cops are preying on ignorance of the law by those they are attempting to rob. Did these cops know there was a dashcam or were they just that assured nothing could touch them in their county. Thuggery by the police doesn't continue unless they have their District Attorney in the bag